4 ms·
Good faith reporting of suspected fraud sounds fine, but a couple concerns about this: > In one case, investigators at State Farm withheld several crucial repo
by neilv 7y ago
Good faith reporting of suspected fraud sounds fine, but a couple concerns about this:
> In one case, investigators at State Farm withheld several crucial reports contradicting their fraud allegations from the bundle of evidence they handed over the law enforcement. In another, a Farmers manager admitted under oath that there was an "unwritten policy" within the company to withhold evidence from customers that could help prove their innocence.
Besides the appearance of possible bad faith, that might also -- in the context of government relying on the insurance company to do some of the investigative work -- thwart government obligations to share evidence with a defendant.
- olliej 7y agoIf the insurance company withholds the evidence from the police and prosecutors they never “know” it exists and wouldn’t need to provide it. What irks me is that they can destroy people’s lives with impunity: if they lose they just have to pay out the insured amount, they don’t need to compensate someone for making them homeless or for destroying their business. All officers and prosecutors should be criminally liable as they are accepting bribes for prosecuting these victims. The insurers should be liable for subverting the course of justice, and any deliberately withholding evidence that demonstrates the claim of fraud is false should make the insurance companies liable for all costs, and all “witnesses” should be separately liable for false testimony.
- celticmusic 7y agohonestly, these companies should be fined so heavily that it's just not worth it for them. I understand that legitimate insurance fraud needs to be investigated and prosecuted, and I'm all for it. But you give them all the evidence, period, and let them decide. You do not manipulate them to save yourself from a payout. That crosses a line that has no grey in it.
- gamblor956 7y agoIt is a finable offense...in some states, like California. Indeed, something like this could even get an insurance company's license to sell insurance in one of those states revoked.
- deogeo 7y agoIn addition to the obvious case of bribery, deliberately misleading the police with intent to falsely imprison someone has got to be some kind of crime far worse than bad faith - defamation at the very least. If I called the police and said "Several men entered the building, and then I heard gunshots, please hurry!", and didn't mention that I knew the building to be a firing range, I'd rightly go to jail for a long time. How is this case different?
- drtillberg 7y agoIn this case the accused person sued the insurer who reported them to police and apparently won a settlement (that curiously did not forbid him from disparaging the insurer post-litigation). The hypothetical you gave would be more on point if instead of deliberately withholding key information, the 911-caller made a truthful allegation for an ulterior motive. So more like, 'there are suspicious cars idling outside the firing range and people walking around with guns. Someone swung the muzzle in my direction for a moment and made me feel unsafe.' As for the insurer paying the salary of the officer who investigates-- yeah, poor optics there but the extension of the hypothetical scenario would be that the police deprioritized gun crimes without funding and won't show up and investigate otherwise. So the real newsworthy issue here, which the article missed, is why police departments in Pennsylvania don't investigate insurance fraud felonies unless someone in the private sector is willing to cover their expenses.
- deogeo 7y ago> In this case There are many examples in the article of insurance using misleading or faulty evidence, and people ending up in prison or homeless as the result. > So the real newsworthy issue here, which the article missed, is why police departments in Pennsylvania don't investigate insurance fraud felonies unless someone in the private sector is willing to cover their expenses. It is mind-boggling why you would think the investigators would be impartial when paid by the insurance companies. The examples from the article certainly point to the direct opposite of that.
- 7y ago
- LorenPechtel 7y agoYeah, failing to turn over exculpatory evidence is a clear indication of bad faith to me.