7 ms·
A well known Googler once told me that if you aren't building you own silicon, you don't know security. This is one of my main reasons for being all in on GClou
by verdverm 7y ago
A well known Googler once told me that if you aren't building you own silicon, you don't know security. This is one of my main reasons for being all in on GCloud.
- ohaideredevs 7y agoCan you elaborate on this please, or link me? I am genuinely interested - do they build their own servers or something? I know they lay down their own network cables.
- mav3rick 7y agoYou can see from recent news about speculation of backdoors in hardware that any sort of trust has to start from the bottom up.
- mda 7y agoHence, https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/titan-in-depth-security-in-plaintext https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/titan-in-depth-se...
- mattlondon 7y agoThey certainly build their own networking gear (1) and their own TPU silicon, as well as laying down their own cables and even transatlantic cables (2). Then there are the pixel phones and laptops etc. I cant readily find a link, but their rack-mount servers are I believe "custom" designs just for them (presumably done in-house too), although from what I know they use off-the-shelf CPUs from Intel and AMD (there was an announcement very recently that they were using Epyc now for example) & GPUs etc. It would not surprise me if only the x86 CPUs & GPUs were the only external things they use, and I bet they're looking at their own custom ARM chips for certain workloads (like they use their custom TPUs for certain workloads). 1 - https://www.wired.com/2015/06/google-reveals-secret-gear-connects-online-empire/ https://www.wired.com/2015/06/google-reveals-secret-gear-con... 2 - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/07/18/google_dunant_cable/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/07/18/google_dunant_cable...
- lallysingh 7y agoThe book "In The Plex" confirms your statements about them designing their servers in-house. But they probably use standard chipsets.
- freedomben 7y agoGiven the recent hardware-level security issues that Intel and others have suffered, I think it's safe to say that security is hard. Just building silicon doesn't make you a security expert, clearly.
- pkaye 7y ago> Just building silicon doesn't make you a security expert, clearly. What about building silicon and have the project zero level security experts in house?
- fataliss 7y agoBut do they though? Does project zero review all products made by google on top of the rest of the web? I doubt their oversight happens at the silicon designing stages. Maybe once it's out they battle test it, but I doubt it'd happen before that.
- delroth 7y agoProject Zero is a tiny subset of Google's security team. And while they do have an unusual concentration of extremely competent security researchers, it's not like they are the only competent security researchers/engineers in the company. Similar research happens internally, at all levels of the stack, including designing silicon (e.g. Titan chips that were shown publicly).
- joatmon-snoo 7y agoGoogle's Elie Burzstein and Jean Michel Picod gave a fascinating talk at Defcon last week about silicon-level SCAs: https://elie.net/talk/a-hackerguide-to-deep-learning-based-side-channel-attacks/ https://elie.net/talk/a-hackerguide-to-deep-learning-based-s... Disclosure: also work at G.
- pkaye 7y agoIts possible the Project Zero team consults or throws ideas to other teams. It is possible Google is able to recruit additional people of similar caliber for the silicon design teams.
- jhayward 7y agoThe problem with acting on that statement is the assumption that Google will use their knowledge of security to protect everything their customers / service consumers want protected, such as privacy. Google has a very fundamental conflict of interest w.r.t. privacy that stems both from revenue (advertising) and product development (e.g., labelling personal data acquired from consumers). Google will almost certainly act against their data product producers (individuals) best interests based on its very deep requirements to obtain private benefits from not protecting them.
- mav3rick 7y agoGoogle's privacy controls have been very good over the years.
- svachalek 7y agoTrue if you mean "control" in the sense of "package and sell".
- metalliqaz 7y agoGoogle apparently* has good, accessible privacy controls, however by using them to increase your privacy, you effectively break many of their apps. They are designed to work with your personal information. * I have no way of knowing if they actually delete any personal data when I ask them. I suspect that they just don't show it to me anymore.
- kartayyar 7y agoThis is not true. Deleted data is indeed deleted. Making sure deleted data is actually deleted is super important to Google and any other company because of GDPR compliance. This is the kind of thing that you go over laborious detail in over privacy design docs at Google to make sure you have it covered. Source: I'm a Xoogler.
- metalliqaz 7y ago
- wmf 7y agoAWS has Nitro, Microsoft has Azure Sphere, HPE has iLO, etc.
- NathanKP 7y agoAWS also has AWS Graviton processors (Arm based)
- akhilcacharya 7y agoNitro is crazy cool. I don't know if Google has anything publicly known that's equivalent.
- wmf 7y agoGoogle has Titan for security but for I/O they have tended to do everything in software, presumably for the flexibility. But the new GVE might be a Nitro-style NIC.
- DannyBee 7y agoThis is ... not correct. Not by a long shot. Unfortunately, not a lot of it is public.
- wmf 7y agoI see this kind of comment from Googlers a lot, but either document your architecture or suffer the misinformation from people trying to understand it via reverse engineering. You can't have it both ways (I mean you probably can because Google, but you don't deserve to).
- dogma1138 7y agoOr you don’t have the resources that Google has. This statement holds water only to a handful of companies that can actually afford to build their own silicon.
- beaner 7y agoMost people use those handful of companies, so it holds a lot of water.
- dogma1138 7y agoI’m not saying it doesn’t make sense to Google, I’m saying it’s too broad of a statement to be generalized.
- dragonwriter 7y agoYou seem to be assuming that the message was “if you understand what is going on, you will choose to build your own silicon”—if so, then, yes, it overlooks threshold resource needs to do that. OTOH, the intended message could be “you can't fully understand the issues without the insight gained by building your own silicon”, in which case it would be just as true of companies without the resources to build their own silicon.
- dogma1138 7y agoSecurity is about managing risks in a world where resources are limited. Building your own silicon is the last thing you do to ensure security even if you are Google, you only do that when it’s the last broad viable attack vector left for your adversaries to exploit.
- Shebanator 7y agoPoor amazon and microsoft, unable to afford to build their own silicon
- dogma1138 7y agoThe world isn’t Amazon or Microsoft, and even for them it’s borderline questionable if designing silicon at scale is the best use of their resources at this point. As I’ve stated already it’s the last thing you do when you think about security not the first. When the security posture of your code, configuration, facilities, supply chain etc. is so good that the only attack vector left for adversaries to exploit to compromise your organization in a sufficiently broad manner is the hardware is when you start thinking about building your own silicon. Or when ofc there are actual business needs for this e.g. you want to be independent of other SoC/ASIC designers or there aren’t any solutions that meet your needs. Which also comes to the actual point other than the Google key/hsm solutions that look more of a rebadge than a home grown design Google is focusing on things like the TPU due to business reasons aka $$$ not security. Google isn’t going away from Xeon/EPYC or x86 any time soon, and I find it very questionable if anyone would make a security argument against NVIDIA GPUs as far as Google goes since Google even wrote their own driver stack and CUDA compiler.
- wil421 7y agoDidn’t the NSA tap Google’s backbone? Everything was unencrypted all they needed were taps at willing backbone providers. [1] Who needs to beat the silicon when you can just tap the pipes. If Bill Barr’s recent encryption speech is ever realized silicon wont matter. [1]https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/google-encrypts-data-amid-backlash-against-nsa-spying/2013/09/06/9acc3c20-1722-11e3-a2ec-b47e45e6f8ef_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/google-en...
- mav3rick 7y agoAnd Google responded by encrypting data immediately.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoAnd proceeded to become the industry leader in "don't trust the network" defense in depth.
- robocat 7y agoGoogle also responded immediately to getting hacked by the Chinese - no more Windows laptops or PCs for developers 10 years ago. The security of Chrome is astounding (and certainly far better than Apple or Microsoft). The only black stain is Android... (Edit: disclaimer: I use Android)
- drevil-v2 7y agoWhat other choice did they have though? Post the Shrug ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ emoticon on google.com and carry on?
- agumonkey 7y agoDo you think they had a special team for black box testing of critical processors ? I'd be curious to read how they assessed security from vendors.
- nitwit005 7y agoYou aren't building your own silicon (Google is), so you haven't exactly solved that problem. You're trusting that Google is doing what you want. Besides, they haven't exactly replaced their supply chain and brought everything in house. Much of their hardware is coming from the same sources as their competitors.
- xwdv 7y agoAnd if you’re building your own silicon, you don’t know business. Which explains the pathetic market share of GCloud, and the source of your statement.