3 ms·

It is 100% a Facebook product. It is FB. I 100% guarantee all data mined from your WhatsApp account is linked either to your FB account or your shadow FB accoun

It is 100% a Facebook product. It is FB. I 100% guarantee all data mined from your WhatsApp account is linked either to your FB account or your shadow FB account if you never signed up. Sure maybe the "experience" hasn't changed from a UI standpoint but FB is weakening WhatsApp's end to end encryption and mining your conversations so under the hood the experience is radically different. There is a reason the founders of WhatsApp quit FB post acquisition (literally leaving hundreds of millions of dollars behind) in disgust over the privacy abuses Facebook was proposing. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/09/26/whatsapp-co-founder-explains-why-he-left-facebook.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/09/26/whatsapp-co-founder-explains...

dajohnson89 7y ago
is there any evidence of WhatsApp conversations being monitored?
- pcmoney 7y ago
  Last I checked: Actual text of convo: not yet but soon. Metadata: yes.
  - sidr 7y ago
    So you believe whatsapp is not e2e encrypted? Or they're going to roll it back?
    - kefabean 7y ago
      They don’t need to roll-back the E2E encryption, they can just access the data right there on the device after it’s decrypted and upload data back to FB via a sidecar. It will start with basic mining of content on the device with ‘anonymous’ summary or aggregate data being uploaded but it’s a slippery slope...
      - deleted 7y ago
        [deleted]
- sodosopa 7y ago
  would you trust Facebook after the many ways they've sold your data?
  - bryan_w 7y ago
    Facebook doesn't sell data
    - sodosopa 7y ago
      https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-46618582 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-46618582
danpalmer 7y ago
Oh I know! I just mean that the product _feels_ nearly identical (apart from stickers which aren't intrusive) to how it felt pre-acquisition.
grawprog 7y ago
>WhatsApp's end to end encryption and mining your conversations so under the hood the experience is radically different. An anecdotal experience i might just chaulk up to coincidence if not for this but, was talking with a friend in WhatsApp something about babies, my friend was browsing Facebook at the same time about a minute or two after our conversation about babies, my friend started getting a bunch of baby videos popping in her Facebook feed that hadn't been there prior to our conversation.
ub 7y ago
You are making a bunch of assertions with no basis. WhatsApp's encryption hasn't been weakened. FB can't look at encrypted message content, neither can WhatsApp. A lot of people use WhatsApp because of the encryption guarantees, please don't spread unverified claims.
- blub 7y ago
  Facebook owns the communication end points and can do whatever they want with the message contents before they're sent encrypted. Given their history, I would be surprised if they don't do some on-device metadata analysis.

dajohnson89 7y ago

is there any evidence of WhatsApp conversations being monitored?

pcmoney 7y ago
Last I checked: Actual text of convo: not yet but soon. Metadata: yes.
- sidr 7y ago
  So you believe whatsapp is not e2e encrypted? Or they're going to roll it back?
  - kefabean 7y ago
    They don’t need to roll-back the E2E encryption, they can just access the data right there on the device after it’s decrypted and upload data back to FB via a sidecar. It will start with basic mining of content on the device with ‘anonymous’ summary or aggregate data being uploaded but it’s a slippery slope...
    - deleted 7y ago
      [deleted]
sodosopa 7y ago
would you trust Facebook after the many ways they've sold your data?
- bryan_w 7y ago
  Facebook doesn't sell data
  - sodosopa 7y ago
    https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-46618582 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-46618582

danpalmer 7y ago

Oh I know! I just mean that the product _feels_ nearly identical (apart from stickers which aren't intrusive) to how it felt pre-acquisition.

grawprog 7y ago

>WhatsApp's end to end encryption and mining your conversations so under the hood the experience is radically different. An anecdotal experience i might just chaulk up to coincidence if not for this but, was talking with a friend in WhatsApp something about babies, my friend was browsing Facebook at the same time about a minute or two after our conversation about babies, my friend started getting a bunch of baby videos popping in her Facebook feed that hadn't been there prior to our conversation.

ub 7y ago

You are making a bunch of assertions with no basis. WhatsApp's encryption hasn't been weakened. FB can't look at encrypted message content, neither can WhatsApp. A lot of people use WhatsApp because of the encryption guarantees, please don't spread unverified claims.

blub 7y ago
Facebook owns the communication end points and can do whatever they want with the message contents before they're sent encrypted. Given their history, I would be surprised if they don't do some on-device metadata analysis.