5 ms·
Wow, I've really got to hand it to Goldman. From the article: Thanks to Goldman’s imprimatur, Facebook’s value increased 20 percent virtually overnight....The
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Wow, I've really got to hand it to Goldman. From the article:
Thanks to Goldman’s imprimatur, Facebook’s value increased 20 percent virtually overnight....The other benefit for Goldman in leading the public offering — aside from major bragging rights — is that it can use its marketing, sales and distribution muscle to make sure the value of Facebook at the time of the offering exceeds the $50 billion valuation at which Goldman invested.
Increasing the value of the firm they are investing in? Great job guys.
While on paper it seems that these high rollers would be foolish to invest in Facebook at such a lofty valuation, they will still most certainly feel increased loyalty to Goldman for making such an exclusive opportunity available to them.
Giving their other clients investment opportunities not available elsewhere? Awesome. Wish I were Goldman's client. (Note: all of Goldman's clients are accredited or institutional investors, and are fully capable of making their own decisions on whether to buy this Facebook SIV.)
Further, if the value at IPO will be at least $52B ($50B + 4%) (as an earlier paragraph suggests it might), all the clients who purchase this SIV will at least break even.
Overall, it looks like Goldman is doing a great job for all their clients. Keep up the good work guys.
Also, the conflict of interest is nonexistent. Goldman holds a long position in Facebook. So do all their clients. Everyone has the same goal here: increase the value of Facebook.
As for the "average investors" who the article claims will be hurt by all this, there is a very simple way to avoid that: don't buy FB. If everyone does this, the IPO will be a failure, and Goldman + Zuckerberg + Goldman's clients will all lose money. If you are very sure FB is overvalued, short it. If you are right you will be taking money from Goldman and Zuckerberg.
- IgorPartola 16y agoOne correction: Goldman did not increase the value of Facebook, just the appearance of their value. Who knows how much Facebook is actually worth? Their profits are tiny compared to the latest valuation. They are up to their ears in invested money. Their business model is showing ads that nobody clicks on. Goldman and the private investors might make out all right. But their recent investment has done little in my eyes to make Facebook more valuable.
- endtime 16y agoFacebook's worth exactly as much as people are willing to pay for it. If Goldman gets people to invest at a higher valuation then they've increased Facebook's value by definition.
- IgorPartola 16y agoUntil the bubble bursts...
- tptacek 16y agoThis is a content-free comment. There may be a bubble, or, the decreased cost of capital afforded Facebook by Goldman's work will allow them to make major strategic investments, maybe multiple where they only could have afforded one, that will drastically increase the value of the company. This "bubblicious" stuff is only valuable if you support it with evidence.
- IgorPartola 16y agoI believe Facebook is overvalued. I cannot provide hard evidence since I cannot look into their finance books, but from what I understand their yearly revenue is about 4% of their latest valuation. I also do not see how their business model can sustain itself, let alone grow exponentially. Yes, they have a ton of users, but they manage to extract precious little money out of them. Getting back to my original point: I believe FB is overvalued, but apparently someone out there is willing to buy their shares at these prices. Eventually, it will come to light that while FB is profitable, etc. they are not going to grow much and their stock will plummet. Until then, the FB stock craziness will continue.
- tptacek 16y agoTwo things. First, have you really done the math on how much money Facebook earns for each penny it extracts from end-users? Do you use Facebook today? I do, and I couldn't tell you what they're really making money on. They don't appear to have turned on the money spigot yet. Second: When you cry "bubble", you have to be talking about the market as a whole. It makes less (some, but less) sense to me to talk about there being a "Facebook bubble". With that said: it's not just about how much money Facebook gets; it's also a question of what Facebook does with the money. During the Internet bubble, companies went public and spent the cash on Super Bowl ads with no revenue, or go-for-broke ship-free-hardware-to-all-of-America schemes. But Amazon was also a product of the Internet bubble. Were they a bad investment?
- jbooth 16y agoI have to agree on your last point regarding average investors. Hard to have sympathy for anyone who buys something at a certain price and loses money. That being said, it seemed like there were several aspects of "pump and dump", rent-seeking (we can get FB, noone else can, so we charge a totally made-up premium), as well as "make a big transaction at an improper valuation in order to get the inside track with FB's CFO for big fees on other transactions later" to the deal. That's not really how markets are supposed to work.. Meanwhile, it's still damn near impossible to a get a business loan, I hear.
- tptacek 16y agoIt has always been damn near impossible to get a business loan. It was damn near impossible to get a line of credit, even for a business with steady cash flow and multiple years track record, in the mid-late 1990s†. Debt financing for IP-driven businesses whose only physical collateral depreciates at near the speed of sound sucks. Don't blame Goldman for that. † Unless the companies I was at that tried were doing something wrong, but, before you whip out the snark, I wasn't the one running those companies.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoMy local pizza shop bought their oven with a business loan. They bought it from the bank, who had repoed it from another bankrupt pizza shop.
- tptacek 16y agoI can't tell if you're agreeing with me or not, but the differences between the "pizza shop" and "ISP" scenarios are pretty huge even before you get into the credit and business histories of the business owners. Sorry to be a pedant. By the way, curious: how did you find this out? When your pizza place gets a new oven, do you just go ask them about how they financed it? Do you ask these kinds of questions of business owners in general? How do they respond?
- 16y ago
- va_coder 16y agoI don't know about you guys but I'm already seeing Facebook looking more like MySpace in the sense that a lot of people got on, but I see less and less usage by most people in my circle. Of course a few people use it heavily, but the majority of my circle seems to have lost interest. Just an anecdote.
- byteclub 16y ago"Increasing the value of the firm they are investing in? Great job guys." Did Goldman increase the number of Facebook's users or add a new awesome feature? Did they address the privacy concerns of Facebook's users? Did they make Facebook experience better for the users? No, no and no. All they did is increase the "perceived financial value" of the company, which as we know from not too long ago, is intangible and fleeting at best, and total BS at worst (Reminds me of the $100bn "valuation" that 37signals got http://37signals.com/svn/posts/1941-press-release-37signals-valuation-tops-100-billion-after-bold-vc-investment http://37signals.com/svn/posts/1941-press-release-37signals-...) As far as I am concerned, Goldman can do whatever it wants as long as its actions don't have negative effects on the rest of us. Internet bubble of 90's hurt many people, and so did mortgage bubble of late 2000s. I don't want Goldman to contribute to and profit from another one of those. How do we make sure it doesn't happen?
- tptacek 16y agoNo, because GS isn't an engineering firm; they're a finance firm, so what they do is decrease the cost of capital for Facebook's own investments, which might include: * Rolling up other companies in their space (Yelp, Twitter, 4square, Instagram, Rdio, who knows) * Buying their way into a strategic but lateral market (search, advertising, mobile, hardware, ISP, who knows) * Drastically improving hiring and retention by improving comp packages and adding headcount * &c &c &c Your comment seems basically nonsensical, suggesting as it does that there is no way to improve Facebook that isn't visible in a commit log. I also object to the comparison between the Internet bubble and the mortgage bubble; the structural causes of both were different, the underlying value of the tulips being sold in both were different (at the end of the Internet bubble we had, you know, an Internet), and most importantly the mortgage bubble was a financial black hole that sucked every homeowner involuntarily into its gravitational field, whether or not they were jackass speculators.
- brown9-2 16y ago"perceived financial value" - is there another? All measures of "value" are based on perception.
- patrickgzill 16y agoI can understand Apple, Xbox, PS3, iPad, Linux, Solaris, etc. fanbois ... but can't understand the Goldman Sachs variety. GS is one of the scummiest of Wall Street's firms, which is saying something. That they were selling MBS tranches to clients, then simultaneously taking out options that would pay GS money when those exact same tranches failed, really tells you all you need to know. GS' crimes are so varied and so well documented, I find it hard to believe you could not be aware of them. Simply asking yourself "what part of this investment is something you would expect a commercial bank to invest in" as you reflect that GS is classed as a commercial bank in order to have access to Fed lending at essentially 0% interest, should perhaps give you pause. EDIT: note for clarification, that the MBS tranches were assembled/packaged by GS themselves; GS was not simply selling a third-party product.
- RickHull 16y ago> That they were selling MBS tranches to clients, then simultaneously taking out options that would pay GS money when those exact same tranches failed, really tells you all you need to know. No, it doesn't. This not necessarily scummy or a conflict of interest. GS could have hedged its own long positions, for one (i.e. still net long). Or GS could even be net short, overall, and still have independent divisions, advisers, or traders who are individually long.
- ShabbyDoo 16y ago"That they were selling MBS tranches to clients" Did they tell their clients that these investments were sound? In 1999, I could have called my financial advisor and told him I wanted to buy Pets.com (or whatever) stock. He might advise me against it, but would have sold it to me. And, he might have had it shorted in his personal portfolio at that time without disclosing this to me. Does that make him a bad guy?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoActually, to make the analogy to Goldman closer, your financial advisers wife would be the one actively managing his personal portfolio. And his wife would be legally barred from telling him what positions she held. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall