3 ms·
"Many lawmakers surely realize this" I'm not sure. They're lawyers, not engineers, and I don't see any reason for lawyers to conclude "It's fundamentally compl
by jerf 16y ago
"Many lawmakers surely realize this"
I'm not sure. They're lawyers, not engineers, and I don't see any reason for lawyers to conclude "It's fundamentally complex, impossible to get right, and going to have problems" rather than "Well, they just didn't try hard enough to make a good law". And certainly the belief that they can create a solid law through sheer staggering complexity rather than despite sheer staggering complexity is a more parsimonious explanation of what has been happening lately than the idea that they know that simpler laws are better.
There are few enough computer programmers who figure this out even with the math staring them in the face and great engineers all but spoonfeeding these tidbits of wisdom; I can't imagine this is anything like the common perception of law in lawmaker circles, and especially not in circles where people believe activist government is on average the solution to everything.
- jbooth 16y agoIf there's even a debate about having a law, it's because there's a real or perceived failure by the market to do the right thing. In this case, it'd be because Goldman's activities have nothing to do with the proper role of finance and everything to do with exploiting the already existing bugs in the market system. Nobody's saying that the government should write laws regarding toilet paper manufacturing, for example. There's a difference between "make a working complex system even more complex", and "attempt to fix a completely broken system, with full knowledge that your fix won't be perfect either".
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jerf 16y agoIn general, you can not actually fix bugs by encrusting more code onto your system. At some point the buggy code has to come out. It is not true to say governments never cancel laws, but they sure don't do it anywhere near often enough. This isn't really free market vs. regulation, a debate I think cuts in the entirely wrong direction anyhow, it's simply a system engineering question. Complexity begets more complexity. Simple solutions to real world problems actually beget complexity too, but less so. People in general need to be able to ascertain whether a given action they may take is legal or not in advance of being hauled into court and having a judge decide, and complex laws remove that. Legal complexity eventually becomes its own tyranny all by itself. (And if you do want to play "free market vs. regulation", I would challenge you with: "exploiting the already existing bugs in the market system." or "exploiting the already existing bugs in the regulation of the market system"?)
- Yzupnick 16y ago>They're lawyers, not engineers, and I don't see any reason for lawyers to conclude "It's fundamentally complex, impossible to get right, and going to have problems" Very true, my brother who, is the press secretary for a relatively prominent senator, said to me when we were debating the health care bill, "Complex problems have complex solutions." and then... "Getting to the moon was a complex problem, and I'm sure it took lot more than 2000 pages to explain the process of getting there."
- anamax 16y ago> "Getting to the moon was a complex problem, and I'm sure it took lot more than 2000 pages to explain the process of getting there." Yes, but how many of those pages were written by congressional staffers? > "Complex problems have complex solutions." Not necessarily. Besides, the question is not whether the solution is complex, it's whether the proposal is a solution. The fact that a proposal is complex doesn't tell us whether it is a solution.