4 ms·
To confused HN commenters: Correlium works by offering VMs of iOS and all models of Apple device, and allowing Terminal access (i.e. pre-jailbroken) access the
by gjsman-1000 7y ago
To confused HN commenters: Correlium works by offering VMs of iOS and all models of Apple device, and allowing Terminal access (i.e. pre-jailbroken) access the operating system underneath.
For example, as a security researcher, I could order a copy of iOS 11.1 running on an iPhone 6 32GB. It would be spun up and accessible in about 3 or 4 minutes, and I could run direct commands on the Darwin kernel underneath.
Why is this illegal? Correlium DOES NOT have a physical iPhone 6 that it is screen recording. They actually have made copies of various iOS releases, and are running them on virtualization software, while making big bucks from the researchers for this technology.
Will Apple win? Well, if you look at the Apple vs Psystar case of 2007 (in which Apple won pretty much every case and appeal and every injunction they filed for), the odds of victory from Correlium is about as likely as Bill DeBlasio winning the 2020 Election.
- blazespin 7y agoThere is a fair use case here. My understanding is that you're allowed to do this sort of thing for purpose of security research. It most definitely is not unethical. Illegal perhaps, but unethical? Please. If they are trying to make money off selling to people doing something other than security research (say, playing games and using apps), than yeah, that'd be unethical.
- ikeboy 7y agoUnder what doctrine / case law?
- blazespin 7y agoFair use for purpose of research.
- jakear 7y agoI can’t steal something then sell it to someone else “for research purposes only” and be okay.
- jtbayly 7y agoFair use/research is not what Corelium is doing. They are selling the product to other people. What those other people do is beside the point. Edit: Oops. Meant to reply to blazespin.
- gjsman-1000 7y agoTo make copies of iOS (against ToS), run it on non-Apple-branded devices (against ToS), and make profit off it? Like, I could see fair use for an individual security researcher, but a business making profit circumventing Apple's ToS and security in multiple ways, and encouraging others to do the same? I find it unlikely to pass.
- blazespin 7y agoI hope it does. Why are researchers doomed to make their own tools from scratch?
- gjsman-1000 7y agoInstead of just Apple though, think of a bigger picture here: Let's say someone ran a service to help you hack AirBNB. Legal? Let's say someone ran a service which spun up Windows Virtual Machines, of any model, which were not genuine licenses, for the sake of "security research." Legal? Let's say someone ran a service which helped you find bugs in anti-cheat software and run those bugs on your PC. Legal? Etc. It's tough.
- zenexer 7y agoLet's say someone ran a service which spun up Windows Virtual Machines, of any model, which were not genuine licenses, for the sake of "security research." Legal? Microsoft outright encourages this. From https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/tools/vms/ https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/tools/v...: Before installing, please note: These virtual machines expire after 90 days. We recommend setting a snapshot when you first install the virtual machine which you can roll back to later. Edit: Furthermore: The Microsoft Software License Terms for the Microsoft Edge and IE VMs are included in the release notes[1] and supersede any conflicting Windows license terms included in the VMs. By downloading and using this software, you agree to these license terms. [1]: https://az792536.vo.msecnd.net/vms/release_notes_license_terms_8_1_15.pdf https://az792536.vo.msecnd.net/vms/release_notes_license_ter... From the license: NO ACTIVATION. To prevent its unlicensed use, the software contains activation enforcement technology. Because the software is licensed for testing use only, you are not licensed to activate the software for any purpose even if it prompts you to do so. Not only are you encouraged to use the software without paying for a license for testing purposes, you're outright forbidden from doing so.
- gjsman-1000 7y agoSorry, meant to write illegal, not unethical.
- mlindner 7y agoFair use doesn't apply when you're acting for profit and making complete copies. That's like arguing that setting up a book production shop and selling fraudulent copies of the book (for borrowing only) is "fair use". This is _quite_ unethical.
- jakear 7y ago“For educational purposes only” would be most similar. Still clearly not ethical.
- jahewson 7y agoFair use is relevant here but one of the main tests used by the courts is whether or not the use is commercial - this kind of for-profit redistribution is unlikely to pass muster.
- rifung 7y ago> It most definitely is not unethical. Illegal perhaps, but unethical? Please. I would argue it IS unethical. When speaking of ethics, the intention matters. If they were just offering these tools to security researchers at cost or for free, then I could agree, but they aren't. They're intentionally doing something that wasn't allowed to make money.
- fragmede 7y agoUnfortunately the service does cost money to run, and it is hard to pay operating costs without some sort of income, so it's hard to fault the service for charging money for a valuable service, especially on HN. This lawsuit (if it goes to court - many cases do not) would decide whether it is, or is not, "allowed". Still, contracts can contain all sorts of clauses, not all of them will be permitted/enforceable by law. Famously, non-compete agreements aren't enforceable in California but that doesn't stop them from appearing in California employment contracts.
- saagarjha 7y agoCorellium isn’t making copies of iOS; it uses restore images from Apple’s servers.
- ascagnel_ 7y agoThat just means they're not running afoul of copyright laws. By setting up the VMs, they're running afoul of the EULA, and Apple has the right to seek legal remedy for their actions.
- segmondy 7y agoWhat if they bought a phone for every VM they offer? So let's say they offer 5000 VMs, they buy 5000 equivalent phones. Do you think they will still have a chance?
- gjsman-1000 7y agoProbably not. That would be much better legal footing, but still has problems. The iOS copy isn't running on the actual iPhone, which is a massive violation of the iOS ToS which says that iOS can only run on an Apple-branded device. There is also legal precedent upholding this in Apple vs Psystar (2007), in which a company claimed "fair use" when selling their own "hackintoshes" and a UEFI product which made building "hackintoshes" easier. How did Psystar do? They lost. Terribly. And they had a surprisingly robust legal team, making it all the way to the point to appealing to the Supreme Court (the SCOTUS denied the request).
- gjsman-1000 7y agoWhat WOULD WORK is buy 5000 iPhones and doing passthrough. In this setup, you have 5000 iPhones, all running iOS, and the screen is recorded with touch-inputs replicated on the real iPhone. Even if they were jailbroken, the odds of Apple winning would be way, way lower than this case. Or, well, enter a legal contract with Apple.
- ascagnel_ 7y agoI don't know if the Aereo decision would come into play here -- they were declared in default, even though each user would "rent" their own unique antenna. There's also a bunch of details to that case that may make that decision irrelevant here.
- tyingq 7y agoThey could reappear in a country that gives no credence.
- chj 7y agoIf Correlium just provides the VM and the researchers download iOS releases directly from apple servers, is it still illegal?
- Aloha 7y agoIt'd be perfectly legal at that point, as the infringement would be with the end user at that point.
- HNcantBtrustd 7y agoDoing God's work. Every Apple purchase makes me feel like I'm creating a computer vilian. But I grew up during the FOSS craze.