4 ms·
I agree; in NYC, it's not uncommon for a software engineer to make $50+/hour; if you value your time at that rate, that means that some of these take home tests
by tombert 7y ago
I agree; in NYC, it's not uncommon for a software engineer to make $50+/hour; if you value your time at that rate, that means that some of these take home tests are effectively costing you $250-$500, when there's no guarantee that it will even result in a job.
What also frustrates me the most is when they say "use whatever language you want", I use Scheme or Haskell, and I get feedback to make it more "modular" by making it more object-oriented. The reviewers of the take-home assignment will be too afraid to admit that they don't understand Haskell, too afraid to admit that they made a mistake making the language a wildcard, and automatically assume that it's less scalable because it's not Java.
- mrfusion 7y agoI hope they’re making way more than $50/hour in NYC.
- NeverFade 7y agoYeah, $50/hr * 200 hrs/month = 10k/month = $120k/yr = $80k post tax. Not a great income at a place where a half decent 1br can easily cost you over $40k/yr.
- tombert 7y agoIf you're willing to go uptown to Washington Heights or Inwood, you can get a decent two-bedroom for around $2,000-$2,500 a month, at least I was able to without too much effort. I survived for about a year with a wife (who wasn't working at the time) at $90,000/year (I was working for a university). Definitely became about a million times easier to live when I left academia and started making six figures.
- NeverFade 7y agoI guess, but then your commute will become a nightmare. Either way, let's get real for a second: a software engineer is a highly trained professional working in an high-demand field. There's no reason for them to be earning $120k/yr, which is a pretty low salary in a very high CoL area like NYC.
- tombert 7y ago> I guess, but then your commute will become a nightmare. I mean, not really? I just hopped onto the A train straight down to NYU; it took me like 40 minutes door to door, and being on the train allowed me to read, so it's much better than driving. I make substantially more than that now, but have moved to Brooklyn since then; door to door it takes me about 50 minutes, but I wouldn't classify that as "a nightmare". > a software engineer is a highly trained professional working in an high-demand field. At the time I was a college dropout whose only professional experience was in startups, 4/5 of which had gone bankrupt, though the university actually paid their actually-qualified people pretty poorly. My coworker had a masters degree in data-science, and was only making $75,000/year.
- NeverFade 7y ago> I make substantially more than that now, but have moved to Brooklyn since then; door to door it takes me about 50 minutes, but I wouldn't classify that as "a nightmare". Depends on your perspective, I suppose. Personally, spending 2 hours every day in commute is definitely not how I want to spend my life. A major reason I would move to a city like NYC is to eliminate such a long commute. Last few times I took the train to Brooklyn, the train was always delayed by several minutes. Sometimes 15+ minutes. Trains were packed, especially during rush hour, and there was nowhere to sit. Occasionally they'd just stop place for technical reasons for as much as 10-20 minutes. Definitely not a smooth or pleasant experience. Regarding compensation: $120k is becoming entry-level compensation in the Bay right now.
- rolltiide 7y agoThe express trains will get you from inwood to columbus circle in... 5 minutes? 10? I have no desire to live north of 59th st, but lets be real here. Anyway, NYC software engineers do not need to compromise on their living situation. Google alone has bought two billion dollar blocks of Manhattan pays just as much as in the bay area.
- perl4ever 7y ago$120K? Here's an ad from someone looking to hire a programmer in Nassau county: VOIP company looking for a technician to assist with programming back end systems. Should be knowledgeable with various database programs and voice services and applications. Primary experience: Windows Environment - IIS / ASP.Net, VB.Net, MS-SQL, XML, Json. Primary helpful: PHP, MySQL Secondary helpful: Google SDK, ffmpeg / sox, SIP Voip , basic CentOS / Debian navigation Job Type: Full-time Salary: $35,000.00 to $45,000.00 /year
- perl4ever 7y agoPeople are advertising for "Data Science & Python Instructors" in NYC starting at $15/hr. Requirements are "in-depth knowledge in big data, data science, Python programming, object-oriented programming, machine learning, or natural language processing (NLP)." Responsibilities are: "Lead technical workshops and training sessions in different areas of data science and Python programming Help clients and students understand the immense career options for Python programmers and data science knowledge Motivate clients about the career change and career boost that upskilling with Python, data science, and blockchain can provide." I think it stands to reason that if big data, etc. generally paid much more in the NYC area, nobody would take such a position, so this must be representative of the job market.
- perl4ever 7y agoI see ads for IT jobs in NYC in the $50K per year range. It boggles my mind, from the perspective of a couple of hours north.
- grp000 7y agoI've had very similar experiences like this; the most similar was a supposed '2 to 3 hour' problem that had no time limit and no language restriction. I rushed through it (had an offer for another position with a decision deadline coming up), and it still took 12 hours. I made an error where I didn't capture all cases, which I was fine to be rejected on those grounds, but I got the exact same feedback for more modularity, and when the interviewer pointed out my 'mistake', it was clear they had no idea what the code was doing.
- NeverFade 7y agoLet's think about it for a second: reading code is hard. We all know that. Reading code in "whatever language" that you may not know at all is nigh impossible. These companies get a ton of candidates and tell them all to submit homework assignments that take at least 5 hours (in your case 12). Reading 12 hours worth of coding work is intense effort even when you know the language well. If you don't, it can take a multiple of that number of hours. Some programmer got 10-20+ of these completed tasks dumped in their lap. I can pretty much guarantee they never really took the time to read and review the code with anything close to sufficient care or attention. Doubly so if it's in a language they didn't know very well.