4 ms·
> enforcing contempt citations is a referral to the DOJ, which is part of the administration Weird, seems like a flaw in the checks-n-balances, a lot like the
by bediger4000 7y ago
> enforcing contempt citations is a referral to the DOJ, which is part of the administration
Weird, seems like a flaw in the checks-n-balances, a lot like the "American Rule" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_rule_(attorney%27s_fees) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_rule_(attorney%27s_fe...) for paying attorney's fees.
- henryfjordan 7y agoThat rule, justified in the wikipedia article, is a double edged sword. It allows me to sue a large corporation without the fear that I'm going to run up a million dollar bill because they insist on the best lawyers. Under a system where I have to pay if I lose, I'm not going to want to sue unless I'm 100% sure I'll win, as opposed to just 51% likely under the american rule. Sure, it sometimes leaves people footing the bill for the defense of frivolous lawsuits but it also enables more people to seek justice. What it is not is a flaw on checks and balances between the branches of government.
- Tomte 7y ago> It allows me to sue a large corporation without the fear that I'm going to run up a million dollar bill because they insist on the best lawyers. That does not follow. In Germany, for example, the winner is entitled to costs up to the statutory hourly rate. Which is the minimum rate lawyers may bill. If you choose a lawyer that bills twenty times as much, your opponent pays only a twentieth.
- mreome 7y agoOut of curiosity, the statutory hourly rate times what? Is there a limit on the number of billable hours that can entail? The cost of the "best lawyers" doesn't (always/just) mean paying one lawyer an exorbitant amount, it means paying a large team of in-house lawyers, or large legal firm, to spend thousands or tens of thousands of man hours on a case.
- sarcasmatwork 7y agoThe problem here that I see, is when one party hires a lawyer to start the lawsuit and the other party some how gets a pro bono lawyer to defend them in federal court. Defense with a pro bono lawyer dont care as much as time/costs when they are not footing the bill, thus they take every chance to delay, or increase court costs to try and force plaintiff to stop the lawsuit etc. Rule 11 exists for this reason, but its rare to get pushed. (Real issue, dont ask)
- tptacek 7y agoIt would be if direct referral to DOJ was the only avenue Congress had to enforce contempt, but it's not; disputes between Article I and Article II entities are what Article III exists, in part, to resolve.
- pvg 7y agoArticle III resolution would still require enforcement by the executive, as Andrew Jackson famously didn't actually say. So if someone sees this as a 'flaw in checks and balances', it seems it would always be a 'flaw', short of independently arming each branch of government.
- tptacek 7y agoI get that that's true, but it would be unprecedented and I think is a little unrealistic. Like, without getting too far into current events politics, I'm not bullish on impeachment, but I think if the executive blows off the federal courts, you find the 67 Senate votes you need. Whereas, just blowing off a House subpoena is actually not that big a thing; like, they can still go to court and argue that they shouldn't have had to honor it in the first place. It's a whole different level of plausible deniability.
- pvg 7y agoOh, of course - I just mean that if someone effectively thinks the fact one branch of government holds all of the ultimate enforcement power is some unanticipated flaw in the American system, it boils down to not believing in any kind of constitutional order. You can't article-of-the-constitution it away, it's roundheads and cavaliers. I did end up in a small clickhole looking for regular schmoes (i.e. not high-level government officials or political operatives) who've been held in contempt of congress and taken it to court. There apparently hasn't been one in decades (so presumably people just comply), except very recently, one of your favourite litigants - backpage.com!
- tptacek 7y ago