6 ms·
I'm a bit confused about House committee subpoenas. It seems like they're really not all that important. Some folks, notably Attorney General William Barr, and
by bediger4000 7y ago
I'm a bit confused about House committee subpoenas. It seems like they're really not all that important. Some folks, notably Attorney General William Barr, and ex-White house lawyer Don McGahn. Former White House staffers Hope Hicks and Annie Donaldson (McGahn's aide) were told not to comply by the White House.
But clearly some people do have to comply, otherwise the subpoenas would be invitations, right? I'm confused about who has to comply, and for who a subpoena is optional.
- tptacek 7y agoRefusal to respond to a subpoena will result in you being found in contempt of Congress. Congress then has several options, ranging from referring you to the DOJ for prosecution to referring the citation to a federal court, effectively converting the subpoena/contempt into contempt of court, or literally imprisoning you in the House basement, which will never happen but it's amusing to note that they technically have that authority. Subpoenas of administration officials complicate this because the primary vehicle Congress has for enforcing contempt citations is a referral to the DOJ, which is part of the administration; a civil referral is, I think? its own kind of civil suit, which is time-consuming and complicated, and it's likely that the House majority will keep their powder dry on referrals about administration officials until they have a really good case. But random civilians aren't so fortunate, and can effectively be compelled to testify, and it's likely that Congress would not have much trouble getting their subpoena enforced.
- schoen 7y ago> or literally imprisoning you in the House basement, which will never happen but it's amusing to note that they technically have that authority Surely someone needs to feature this possibility in a movie somehow!
- tptacek 7y agoThat movie definitely needs to feature the Mace of the US House Of Representatives, which is A Thing You Should Definitely Go Look Up.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoOver in the UK parliament, grabbing the mace has almost become a trope of renegade MPs. It's a big emergency stop button on proceedings as it represents the monarch's authority and without it parliament has no power. Most famous are Michael Heseltine, or Oliver Cromwell a couple of years before the UK's brief experiment with republican dictatorship. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/dec/10/day-of-brexit-drama-ends-with-mp-grabbing-the-ceremonial-mace https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/dec/10/day-of-brex...
- shawndrost 7y ago:D "Disciplinary usage" "In accordance with the House Rules, on the rare occasion that a member becomes unruly, the Sergeant at Arms, upon order of the Speaker, lifts the mace from its pedestal and presents it before the offenders, thereby restoring order. There have been at least six instances where the Mace was used to quell disorder." "During President Donald Trump's 2019 State of the Union speech, Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi wore a brooch styled after the Mace, presumably as a symbol of her authority as speaker." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mace_of_the_United_States_House_of_Representatives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mace_of_the_United_States_Hous...
- caf 7y agoThe last time the UK House of Commons used their equivalent power to imprison someone in Big Ben was Charles Bradlaugh in 1880. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Bradlaugh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Bradlaugh
- bediger4000 7y ago> enforcing contempt citations is a referral to the DOJ, which is part of the administration Weird, seems like a flaw in the checks-n-balances, a lot like the "American Rule" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_rule_(attorney%27s_fees) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_rule_(attorney%27s_fe...) for paying attorney's fees.
- henryfjordan 7y agoThat rule, justified in the wikipedia article, is a double edged sword. It allows me to sue a large corporation without the fear that I'm going to run up a million dollar bill because they insist on the best lawyers. Under a system where I have to pay if I lose, I'm not going to want to sue unless I'm 100% sure I'll win, as opposed to just 51% likely under the american rule. Sure, it sometimes leaves people footing the bill for the defense of frivolous lawsuits but it also enables more people to seek justice. What it is not is a flaw on checks and balances between the branches of government.
- Tomte 7y ago> It allows me to sue a large corporation without the fear that I'm going to run up a million dollar bill because they insist on the best lawyers. That does not follow. In Germany, for example, the winner is entitled to costs up to the statutory hourly rate. Which is the minimum rate lawyers may bill. If you choose a lawyer that bills twenty times as much, your opponent pays only a twentieth.
- mreome 7y agoOut of curiosity, the statutory hourly rate times what? Is there a limit on the number of billable hours that can entail? The cost of the "best lawyers" doesn't (always/just) mean paying one lawyer an exorbitant amount, it means paying a large team of in-house lawyers, or large legal firm, to spend thousands or tens of thousands of man hours on a case.
- sarcasmatwork 7y agoThe problem here that I see, is when one party hires a lawyer to start the lawsuit and the other party some how gets a pro bono lawyer to defend them in federal court. Defense with a pro bono lawyer dont care as much as time/costs when they are not footing the bill, thus they take every chance to delay, or increase court costs to try and force plaintiff to stop the lawsuit etc. Rule 11 exists for this reason, but its rare to get pushed. (Real issue, dont ask)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- onewhonknocks 7y ago> or literally imprisoning you in the House basement, which will never happen but it's amusing to note that they technically have that authority. I believe that is not true. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2019/05/14/capitol-jail-trump-officials-locked-up-if-contempt-congress/1154047001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2019/05/14/capi...
- klyrs 7y agoWhat's true is that they can and have imprisoned people. What's not true is that the basement features a jail cell.
- dsl 7y agoAny such order would fall to the Sargent at Arms of the House. The Sgt. at Arms sits on the board of the US Capitol Police (USCP) and has the authority to request mutual aid from the USCP chief of police. The USCP does arrest individuals on a semi-frequent basis and places them in holding cells at its headquarters building on D Street Northeast. They can also be held at the DC Department of Corrections' Central Detention Facility on D Street Southeast under USCP authority, just as if they were arrested by any other law enforcement agency in DC. tl;dr: The House has approximately 2,200 officers and at least a hundred beds at its disposal.
- stevetodd 7y agoRefusal is illegal, however, in the last two administrations, the DOJ just doesn’t enforce it.
- bediger4000 7y agoSo, we come back to the "it's no a problem for certain people to refuse to comply". How do I get to be one of "those people"?
- tptacek 7y agoGet elected President so that your refusal implicates a constitutional controversy rather than a fit of pique.
- intoonesunder 7y ago.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- LinuxBender 7y agoJim is from the Philippines. I don't know if he has U.S. citizenship. Perhaps he is just responding as a courtesy to help diffuse some political tensions around his site / business in the same way that Moot did regarding 4chan.