4 ms·
I must be too cynical for this. Seems like the sort of slogan MLM people could have.
by SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
I must be too cynical for this. Seems like the sort of slogan MLM people could have.
- toxik 7y agoI like to imagine a tribal villages before civilization went into overdrive. That’s the lifestyle humans originally adapted to. I imagine that in the village, there are niched personalities. One guy is way spiritual and offers guidance and spiritual support. Another is a warrior spirit, always eager to conquer and to gain more resources for his village. A third is the carpenter. Society today must accommodate these same people types, or they’ll feel out of place. It’s okay if you (like me) don’t respond to the Don Quixote type narrative; I think it sounds naive, but it’s always easy to be a critic.
- goldfeld 7y agoTribal villages like constant strife and either going all-in Spartan with daily military drill or else getting swallowed and seeing all you love die and get savagely raped? The ancients had it hard and we have it really, really easy with our peaceful freedoms.
- chillwaves 7y agoIs this comment historically accurate? How often are lands conquered? I think not, to what you say. Also, this only accomodates the last ~3000 years of human history. Before the agricultural revolution, humans lived a very different life as apex predators. It was not until we can grow and store crops that armies could exist.
- messick 7y agoIt’s not. Even in their own time, the Spartan bullshit was a myth pushed by themselves. Some civilizations such as the Chumash in what is now Los Angeles worked as little as 8 hours per week in order to survive.
- rumanator 7y ago> Some civilizations such as the Chumash in what is now Los Angeles worked as little as 8 hours per week in order to survive. What was their life expectancy?
- fwsgonzo 7y agoIt makes more sense to me to calculate how much total free time they had compared to now. So even if they lived to be only 40-50 years old they would still have more freedom in hours/days than the modern worker. I worked remotely for a whole year and it was 100x better than working in an office. I can only imagine what only working 8 hours a week is like.
- rumanator 7y ago> It makes more sense to me to calculate how much total free time they had compared to now. You won't have much free time if you and your family can only aspire to reach the ripe old age of 30, if you manage to be the lucky ones who are lucky on the infant mortality lotto.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> You won't have much free time if you and your family can only aspire to reach the ripe old age of 30 That was never the case though; ancient societies had much lower life expectancy at birth because they were very likely to die in early childhood. People who made it to adulthood, sure, didn't live as long as today on average, but the difference is much smaller than life expectancy at birth numbers would suggest. You seem to recognize the high infant mortality, but not understand how it affects the other stats like life expectancy at birth.
- Fricken 7y agoTheir mortality rates were 100%, as are ours. Their life expectancy was infinitesimally small relative to the eternity they'll be dead for, as are ours.
- watwut 7y agoDidn't Sparta lost quite a few fights? For all the myths,they were not succesfull at creating imperium.
- coldtea 7y agoOr not sufficiently cynical. What you describe sounds run of the mill caution
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoIt’s the old spiritual argument repackaged. Go in the woods for years and you will emerge an enlightened man. But if you want to remain sane and participate in society, this type of philosophy is incompatible. I agree with the sentiment, though. If you want to become “financially independent”, might as well directly give away all your belongings and lounge around near Santa Monica pier. Instead of slaving away for years as a wagecuck, and then trying to enjoy life when you can no longer maintain an erection.
- chillwaves 7y agoIs this a serious comment? Wagecuck? Really? What is your criticism? Working for someone else? Not everyone can own a business. A person who makes a good wage and carves out a life for themselves is successful by any metric. As far as erections, I hope when you reach the twilight years you will have more on your mind than getting hard.
- coldtea 7y ago>A person who makes a good wage and carves out a life for themselves is successful by any metric. Just not by the metrics discussed in TFA, which is the whole point. It's not like everybody agrees that "a good wage" is success.
- asveikau 7y agoSome suggested edits to your comment: wagecuck -> working stiff when you can no longer maintain an erection -> when you are past the prime of your life With these simple substitutions you can once again sound like a reasonable human being who is not overly fixated on unnecessary crude sexual imagery.
- 7y ago
- new2628 7y ago"too cynical for Bukowski", that's a good motto :)