20 ms·
What I'm getting tired of is Hollywood films, documentaries, awards, etc. preaching to me. Specifically nature documentaries, when I watch recent productions I
by colechristensen 7y ago
What I'm getting tired of is Hollywood films, documentaries, awards, etc. preaching to me.
Specifically nature documentaries, when I watch recent productions I get the feeling that they aren't trying to show the results of studying nature, to educate about this or that: I get the feeling that they are packaged environmentalist manifestos (look at all these cute little animals that are going to die because you don't recycle) either made to shame/enlighten people who don't do the right thing or to boost the egos of people who do good.
It bothers me because it so often feels shoehorned in and off topic. I wouldn't mind at all if it were the topic, but injecting it into every topic is the problem.
Using art as a tool is complicated. When overdone it is unambiguously wrong, when done correctly it can be a powerful good force, and somewhere in the middle is a wide grey area which is difficult to navigate.
- busterarm 7y agoIt's all about ego-stroking. Don't forget that we just switched all our plastic straws to paper straws that are 1) less recyclable than plastic (or straight-up non-recyclable), 2) cost more in energy and carbon to produce, 3) cost more, and 4) are less effective. All because some 9 year old conducted a survey...
- genericone 7y agoless effective: functionally miserable after 15 minutes, unusable after 30...
- busterarm 7y agoMore like "functionally miserable after 3, unusable after 5".
- TehCorwiz 7y agoThey’re not recyclable because they biodegrade instead.
- busterarm 7y agoThat's not really desirable if they're significantly worse, environmentally, to produce. Think about it.
- slg 7y agoCarbon pollution is not the only type of pollution that environmentalists care about. I'm not a fan of the paper straws either, but it is entirely possible that a switch from plastic to paper straws increases carbon usage but decreases plastic pollution to the extent that it is an overall net positive for the environment.
- busterarm 7y agoThere are plastics that biodegrade completely in 6 months. Look at Nodax PHA.
- moultano 7y agoThe feeling of everyone studying the natural world now is one of overwhelming loss, that everything they've devoted their lives to is disappearing before their eyes. There isn't any way to make an honest nature documentary and not include that. To do otherwise would be to pretend that the careful selection they do to show a pristine wilderness and healthy animals is reflective of reality.
- apocalypstyx 7y agoSometimes it seems all nature documentaries are implicitly becoming (unintentional) sequels to Last Chance to See. Maybe they should just start opening with the line: we're recording this so we'll know what it was like after it's gone.
- colechristensen 7y ago> The feeling of everyone studying the natural world now is one of overwhelming loss I am beginning to have my doubts about the reasoning behind these feelings. It is not that I deny that there are problems which have happened, are happening, and certainly will happen. I'm starting to think most people thinking, talking, and feeling about it are being driven and biased by a shared sort of doomsday cult not in major but only subtle ways. "Everyone" just "knows" it. There is loss, there is reason for concern, there is change in progress, and lots of reasons to feel about it. The feelings though don't seem like they are driven by fact, reason, analysis, and – well – science, but driven by shared feelings and ambiguous knowledge that things are bad.
- moultano 7y agoYou should read a bit more about it. The changes are so visceral as to be unignorable. https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2019/07/weight-of-the-world-climate-change-scientist-grief/ https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2019/07/weight-of-th... >She had been taking these sorts of research trips for two decades, and over recent years she had witnessed about 85 percent of the island’s reef system perish due to rising ocean temperatures. “I was diving with tears in my eyes,” she recalls. http://theconversation.com/sadness-disgust-anger-fear-for-the-great-barrier-reef-made-climate-change-feel-urgent-119232 http://theconversation.com/sadness-disgust-anger-fear-for-th... > We found a large proportion of respondents, including Australians and overseas visitors, expressed forms of grief in response to loss and damage to the iconic ecosystem. Negative emotions associated with words given in short statements about “what the Great Barrier Reef means to you”, included sadness, disgust, anger and fear. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/12/greenland-residents-traumatised-by-climate-emergency https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/12/greenland-resi... > 76% claiming to have personally experienced global heating in their daily lives, from coping with dangerous sea ice journeys to having sled dogs euthanised for economic reasons tied to shorter winters.
- hndamien 7y agoIt sure does suck when we see reality assert itself in documentaries.
- RickJWagner 7y agoI find individual glory-seeker's behavior even worse. Example: The recent mega-A-lister junket to Italy, where there was something like a 1-to-3 ratio of attendees to private jets. I will readily listen to earnest spokespeople for almost any cause. I'd listen to Ralph Nader today. But a bunch of Hollywood Limosine liberals, flying in by private jet to hobnob about how to preach to the unwashed masses about climate change? Total turnoff.