6 ms·
I've put a line in the sand that I won't do take-home projects anymore for anything short of a "dream job". They can be extremely time-consuming, and it's enti
by tombert 7y ago
I've put a line in the sand that I won't do take-home projects anymore for anything short of a "dream job". They can be extremely time-consuming, and it's entirely possible that they'll decide that they don't like you anyway. If the project doesn't result in an offer, and if I don't really have a need for another "Roman Numeral to Arabic Number" converter, then the time is completely wasted.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TrackerFF 7y agoI mean, they can be time consuming - yes - but so can "grinding leetcode" for 3 months be too. Have you seen some of the study guides / roadmaps people make for FAANG interviews? I've seen people claim they've coded hackerrank / leetcode / CTCI questions for multiple hours a day, for months.
- tombert 7y agoWell, I actually work for a FAANG company (not going to say which one), and I didn't have to spend hours a day for months to do so; granted, I'm a bit of a math/theory junky. EDIT: Also, at least with the Hackerrank for hours a day, it's not for any specific company. Getting good at these problems is useful for getting a job at virtually any big company. Contrast this to the take-home project, where (in order to make sure you don't just copypaste someone else's from the internet), they make these things kind of specific, making the transferability to other things substantially less likely.
- NeverFade 7y agoEven if you do have to "grind leetcode", at least that gives you the skills to get almost any tech job with very small marginal investment. Once you get very good at leetcode-style questions, just apply anywhere and get an onsite with a one-hour interactive technical screen, that will also tell you about the sort of people and culture that employer has. Conversely, homework assignments can easily take 5-10 hours. There's a lot of desperate unemployed people out there taking 10+ hours for these tasks, and setting the bar really high. A busy professional can be hard pressed to invest 5 hours they can ill-afford coding this task after a full day at work, then get rejected because some unemployed applicants dedicated 20+ hours for the same task. There are also services that solve these tasks for you, so now you - a busy professional - are competing against hordes of people who do these tasks all day every day for a living. So you hard-scramble 4-5 hours to finish a take home assignment to apply to just one place (!), and then you send it in and get a meaningless rejection note. Sometimes you don't get anything at all. These are some of the reasons I'm never completing a homework assignment again.
- tombert 7y agoI agree; in NYC, it's not uncommon for a software engineer to make $50+/hour; if you value your time at that rate, that means that some of these take home tests are effectively costing you $250-$500, when there's no guarantee that it will even result in a job. What also frustrates me the most is when they say "use whatever language you want", I use Scheme or Haskell, and I get feedback to make it more "modular" by making it more object-oriented. The reviewers of the take-home assignment will be too afraid to admit that they don't understand Haskell, too afraid to admit that they made a mistake making the language a wildcard, and automatically assume that it's less scalable because it's not Java.
- mrfusion 7y agoI hope they’re making way more than $50/hour in NYC.
- NeverFade 7y agoYeah, $50/hr * 200 hrs/month = 10k/month = $120k/yr = $80k post tax. Not a great income at a place where a half decent 1br can easily cost you over $40k/yr.
- tombert 7y agoIf you're willing to go uptown to Washington Heights or Inwood, you can get a decent two-bedroom for around $2,000-$2,500 a month, at least I was able to without too much effort. I survived for about a year with a wife (who wasn't working at the time) at $90,000/year (I was working for a university). Definitely became about a million times easier to live when I left academia and started making six figures.
- NeverFade 7y agoI guess, but then your commute will become a nightmare. Either way, let's get real for a second: a software engineer is a highly trained professional working in an high-demand field. There's no reason for them to be earning $120k/yr, which is a pretty low salary in a very high CoL area like NYC.
- Tade0 7y agoI just use those previously written projects whenever someone asks me to provide samples of my work. There's no contract nor payment for these and I write them from scratch, so it's still my IP.
- shivawu 7y agoMany people like me don't have a project to show...
- pertminus 7y agoI've done one take-home project for a job and it was a terrible experience. They gave me an overnight challenge that in their words was meant to confuse you and was impossible to complete. They informed me I should have realized this and focused on one specific area of the challenge. I spent all night trying to complete it, focusing on a "pace over perfection" approach and then was torn about by their dev team. Of course I explained there would be a difference between a DB, Server, & UI I implemented overnight and what I would do at work. They informed me I was too defensive, attempted more of the challenge than anyone, and that I wouldn't get the job. tl;dr: I feel you completely and will never waste my time like this again.
- pertminus 7y ago*torn apart
- cableshaft 7y agoThey give you impossible requirements and expect you to come to conclusion that these are impossible requirements AND zero in one specific part of the impossible requirements and implement that bit? Come on. It's not completely unheard of to be given confusing or impossible requirements while working for some companies and while in those situations I would probably just communicate back to the Business Analysts what's broken about the ask, you aren't given that opportunity in a take-home with a new company. Presumably a bunch of other people have been given the task and successfully completed it, so I would probably try to power through it. I'm sorry, but that's an asshole thing to do to someone. In an interview setting it's more okay, because you have a chance to mention it after a few minutes and talk it out and get feedback on it or they can stop you if it's clear you're not pointing that out and you waste a bunch of time, but with a take-home you won't get that quick feedback, even if you send them an email, and can waste hours and hours on that thing. Interviewers reading this, don't do this, please. It would leave a very bad impression on me and probably a bunch of other people about your company.
- HiJon89 7y agoEngineers: coding exotic data structures on a whiteboard in a time-crunched interview is high-pressure and unrealistic! ...how about we give you a project that more closely reflects problems we solve here day-to-day that you can solve in the comfort of your home on your own hardware in whatever IDE makes you comfortable? Engineers: That's absurd! I've drawn a line in the sand!
- zifnab06 7y agoMy favorite so far was the take home followed by a 3 hour non-coding interview (design/architecture).
- palisade 7y agoAh well the hash table wasn't exotic. But, software engineering interviews are pretty rough. It is a uniquely miserable experience. Since I'm a temp worker I have a lot of them. They don't get easier. I don't know of anyone who likes high pressure time crunch interrogations except maybe the ones getting to do the interrogating part. A take home test isn't so bad. But, ya if you asked me today if I'd be willing to do one like that again I'd say probably not unless I was desperate. The reality is, it is a lot of effort to put in for it to all come crashing down with a rejection anyway. When you're applying at dozens of companies if they're all requiring that level of time and mental commitment from you, you can't swing it really and it's stressful. Interviewing and being under financial pressure at the same time is already a stressful position to be in, let alone being mentally and emotionally flogged for it. All the jobs I was ever hired onto the hiring manager just had a good gut feeling about me and the tests never mattered. And, they were happy with my work. The ones that never hire me usually rely on all the employees to vote on you, if even one says no you're out. Or, the ones that are very fixated on your GPA or whether you can invert a binary tree on the whiteboard while they yell at you "Wrong!" along the way.
- kazinator 7y ago> All the jobs I was ever hired onto the hiring manager just had a good gut feeling about me and the tests never mattered. At one, the resume didn't matter! When through the interviews, got the offer, and then "oh, can you send me your resume, so we have it on file?"