4 ms·
I recently wrote two blog posts that touch on this. I honestly think many people cannot tell real automation from "a box full of little elves with a tech interf
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I recently wrote two blog posts that touch on this. I honestly think many people cannot tell real automation from "a box full of little elves with a tech interface." (I often compare it to the MIB2 scene where Will Smith opens the automatic mail sorting machine and reveals a multi-armed alien rapidly flinging mail, not robotic parts.)
It's made me less aggravated with certain things to realize that. It also makes me wonder if founders are genuinely being intentionally deceptive or just unclear where to draw that line themselves.
How much AI inside the box do you need to qualify as an AI company when advertising what you do and wooing VC money? I bet some people honestly don't know and some of those people may be in decision-making positions at such companies.
Serious tech people may be clear on that, but most companies involve more than just tech people. If your PR people don't really get it and your tech people don't have adequate power to insist "You cannot market the company this way," then it will get sorted out in ugly headlines and court cases and the like.
- rland 7y agoI think people come up with the idea of marketing things as having AI behind them, before the implementation is fully realized. Once they have funding and employees, they can't exactly back down. So they have to put humans behind the solution as a stopgap. In their minds, it's temporary: they're just gathering more data, they have real paying customers that they want to keep until their solution is ready, etc. The little lie becomes a big lie and sooner or later it will blow up for a lot of companies. Uber's house of cards is a very transparent example, but there are many others who don't even disclose that humans are at the wheel.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoOn the upside, it means that dystopian dreams of automation taking all our jobs and creating an 80% permanent unemployment rate are laughable. There will be plenty of paid tasks for people. They will just be online, remote and we will need to sort out how to make this make financial sense for all involved parties so it doesn't turn into a permanent underclass.