6 ms·
Russian Physicists Solve Radio Black-Out Problem for Re-Entering Spacecraft
- haribilalic 16y agoIt reminds me of the Navy's sea water antenna system (http://www.public.navy.mil/spawar/Pacific/TechTransfer/ProductsServices/Pages/SeaWaterAntennaSystem.aspx http://www.public.navy.mil/spawar/Pacific/TechTransfer/Produ...). I know nothing about this thing, but I would have thought the plasma would be on the underside of the craft, allowing any antennae on the top to communicate with a satellite that could relay everything to/from the ground station.
- radu_floricica 16y agoI'm guessing it's not going straight down, and most of the speed is actually on the x axis. The atmosphere is how much? 50 km? While the descent path is most likely counted in thousands.
- jared314 16y agoWouldn't the plasma flow around the craft from bottom to top like a bubble?
- lutorm 16y agoYeah, it does.
- igravious 16y agoThat should read Theoretically Solve but I admire the ingenuity nonetheless and hope that the road from theory to practice is short and uneventful. A shame this hack has military applications, it would be nice if every now and again scientists patented their discoveries and precluded military use in doing so. [ Please don't downvote me for expressing this sentiment :) ]
- viraptor 16y agoI thought there was a clause making all technology available for national defence, regardless of patents... but can't find the source. Anyone?
- vyrotek 16y agoI've heard this too. A quick search found a book briefly covering the topic. I couldn't find an official source. As a matter of public policy - national defense trumps patents - http://bit.ly/faNGT3 http://bit.ly/faNGT3
- igravious 16y agoThat may be true in the US but what about in other jurisdictions? I mean doctor's have the Hippocrates oath of do no harm to the patient but (and not to come over all tree-hugging peacenik like) why do chemists/bioengineers/physicists not have a similar oath with respect to the our species or other species in general or the planet in its entirety? But I guess the scientists do the theorizing and the engineers and coders build weaponize or apply the theoretical results in military applications so what good would it do ... Hmm, maybe the New Year is making me come over all compassionate and fuzzy :)
- nolok 16y agoBecause if we disallowed research that could lead to military applications, we wouldn't do much research at all. Look at all the tech stuff you use everyday and you will realise that most if not all of it have their origin somewhere in a defense lab or contractor.
- bdonlan 16y agoOther jurisdictions can certainly make similar exceptions for themselves.
- sp332 16y agoIn Canada, there is a Ritual Calling of the Engineer, which has an "Obligation" which is not exactly an oath. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ritual_of_the_Calling_of_an_Engineer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ritual_of_the_Calling_of_an... I'll paste the text here if I can find it.
- iwwr 16y agoI stumbled onto this a while ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_antenna http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_antenna
- eps 16y agoThis might be a completely dumb idea and it must've been explored before, but how about attaching the antenna to a string and trailing it behind the ship at a considerable distance to clear the extent of the plasma shield. Is it that no string is strong or plasma-resistant enough?
- elwin 16y agoWhen re-entering, spacecraft are being decelerated, so anything towed behind the spacecraft will catch up with it. A rigid pole might work.
- disponsible 16y agoI think the plasma forms a complete enclosure, i.e. there is no "break" in its surface at the tail of the spacecraft. The pole will need to cross the surface of the plasma shield meaning an exposure to very high temperatures. OTOH the pole can be insulated the same way the front of the craft is. It looks doable in principle, so I wonder what other problems are there. Could it be that extending the pole during the descent makes the design of the hull more complex and through that more fragile?
- dstorrs 16y agoThey mention this in the article, where they talk about extending an aerial out past the plasma sheath. They then say "this allows communication until the aerial ablates."
- ortusdux 16y agoIt would seem to me that any antenna that extends outside the 'plasma bubble' would still be traveling at the same speeds and subject to the same problems as the shuttle.
- pavel_lishin 16y agoAnyone else see a weird font used for double-F's? http://i.imgur.com/EpolQ.png http://i.imgur.com/EpolQ.png
- chronomex 16y agoThe document uses a ligature ( http://www.fileformat.info/info/unicode/char/fb00/index.htm http://www.fileformat.info/info/unicode/char/fb00/index.htm ) for ff. Apparently the font your browser uses by default doesn't have it. Some font replacement algorithm decided that the script font you're seeing is the closest! :-)
- dstorrs 16y agoOne thing they did not mention is that this solves the primary problem with orbital crowbars (fictionally called "Rods from God", "Thor", KEWs, and various other things). You could drop a kinetic warhead (basically a crowbar) from orbit to kill a tank / bunker / whatever, but you could also use them for a variety of peactime missions such as mining, emergency flood control (digging drainage ditches, causing controlled landslides), etc. Each crowbar would need some sort of minimal steering system to account for atmospheric turbulence. This steering can't be locally controlled because the device can't see past the plasma sheath. It can't be remote controlled because the plasma sheath stops transmissions. With this new "plasma aerial" technology, you could steer each crowbar individually from the launcher platform.
- borism 16y agointeresting! what kind of materials need to be used so that crowbar doesn't burn-up on reentry? isn't it a little bit more expensive than using traditional explosives?
- dstorrs 16y agoIf you made it out of steel, it would survive just fine -- there would be some ablation, but it would still get to the ground. As to the "more expensive"...no, not really. Basically, it's just a crowbar with a simple camera and some fins on it. Using this technology it would trade in the camera for a radio back to the launch vehicle. You'd need all the same bits on a missile, plus more besides, and the missile would need to be larger.
- borism 16y agoyes, but you don't need a missile to build a dam :) sure, it will be less expensive to kill a lot of people with this. those are not cost savings I had in mind.
- gvb 16y agoTrivia: the space shuttle avoids the blackout by its shape, which allows it to communicate upward to the TDRSS satellites. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_blackout#Reentry_communications_blackouts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_blackout#Reentry... "[T]he Shuttle can communicate with a Tracking and Data Relay Satellite during re-entry. This is because the shape of the Shuttle creates a "hole" in the ionized air envelope, at the tail end of the craft, through which it can communicate upwards to a satellite in orbit and thence to a ground station."
- electromagnetic 16y agoI sincerely thank you, it's something I've always wondered about but never put in the time to actually look it up.
- TGJ 16y agoOne thing that has always seemed to rub me wrong in space exploration is the giant need to stay in touch with Earth. Supposedly the space shuttles are crewed by the great explorers of our time, but it always seems that everything is governed by people on the ground and not in the air.
- Nick_C 16y agoBasically it's resource management, both human and materials. I'll leave the human side out, but recommend Gene Kranz book Failure Is Not an Option for more info on why ground controllers are important. It costs a huge amount of money (in fuel) to lift anything up, even just a kilo or two. You're better off lifting only a telemetry system and putting all the processing, display and engineering on the ground. That means having ground controllers to manage it. Of course, in the early days, you couldn't physically fit computers in the capsule. Now we can, but it is still more economical to have most of it on the ground and just use radio to let the systems communicate.