5 ms·
The problem with hiring in our industry is the lack of licensing/certification that everyone trusts. When a doctor interviews for a job, they don't ask the doc
by jedberg 7y ago
The problem with hiring in our industry is the lack of licensing/certification that everyone trusts. When a doctor interviews for a job, they don't ask the doctor to perform six surgeries in a day for free and then say, "we'll get back to you". That's because they know that if the doctor holds a license and a degree, they have the necessary skills.
We don't have that in our industry. I interviewed countless "senior engineers" with degrees from well regarded universities who couldn't write a simple loop. Therefore I must now conclude that a degree from that university means nothing.
There are some folks like Tripplebyte who are trying to solve this by pre-qualifying candidates, but I don't think the problem will really be solved until we form a software engineering licensing board. Take a test once, and then take a refresher course every couple of years to maintain your license.
- jorblumesea 7y agoBe careful what you wish for. I have friends that are lawyers and they talk about how terrible the bar is for assessing real world skill. You need to be fairly well versed in 20+ forms of law (admin, criminal, civil etc) independent of what form of law you practice. Most of the test is irrelevant to what you do, but you need to know it anyways. I guess the advantage is once you pass you don't need to re-certify. Which also seems incorrect.
- quadrifoliate 7y ago> When a doctor interviews for a job, they don't ask the doctor to perform six surgeries in a day for free and then say, "we'll get back to you"...have interviewed countless "senior engineers" with degrees from well regarded universities who couldn't write a simple loop. I think this is fundamental to the discussion. Are we really sure they couldn't write a simple loop, or were there other factors that prevented them from doing so? For comparison with your other analogy, keep in mind that even surgeons who have amputated the wrong limb are defended by their colleagues, saying “Well, it should have been amputated anyway.” (https://www.nytimes.com/1995/09/17/us/doctor-who-cut-off-wrong-leg-is-defended-by-colleagues.html https://www.nytimes.com/1995/09/17/us/doctor-who-cut-off-wro...) I understand that you specifically might not have used that as your only filter, but a lot of people do – and I think a more holistic approach that takes into account education, training so far, and overall experience with tech. Certifications might be one part of this too.
- pbalau 7y ago> Are we really sure they couldn't write a simple loop, or were there other factors that prevented them from doing so? what's the difference? I believe that getting hired by a company is the easiest thing you will have to do for that company. I believe that if you can't perform a basic task at interview time, you should not be working there. Either because you can't perform. Or The mood is not right for you. If this is the case, why would you want to work there anyway? I see so many people that thing getting hired is the end goal. Mate, you still have to work for them. Those people that can bullshit their way through a job, have no issues getting hired to begin with.
- perl4ever 7y ago"I believe that getting hired by a company is the easiest thing you will have to do for that company." That doesn't describe any of the five job offers I've taken since college. Well, maybe the case where I was rehired.
- jedberg 7y ago> Are we really sure they couldn't write a simple loop I mean I suppose the stress under pressure could have made them forget the loop syntax in their favorite language, but that is unlikely. I literally asked them to implement FizzBuzz in their favorite language during a phone screen where they even had internet access to look up syntax. But since I was interviewing them for an SRE job, coding under pressure is actually part of the job anyway. Regardless, I'd expect someone who claims to have 3+ years of Python experience to be able to write a python loop.
- sixothree 7y agoI am a developer, not HR. But I do play a role in hiring. We already have an "aptitude" style test, and an SQL test. So I wanted to make my addition to be limited to 15 minutes. I ask candidates to write Fizz Buzz but with the addition writing at the end the average of Fizz, average of Buzz, and average of FizzBuzz. Pretty much every candidate has "failed" the test. More than half have something incorrect or not quite matching the instructions. But we have hired some of those people and they are great programmers. It actually does give a surprising insight into the developer's style. It's not pleasant to see all of their code stuffed into main(). It's not pleasant to see every single line of code commented. But it is refreshing to see Enumerable.Range(1, 100) instead of C style for loop.
- alchemism 7y agoI think there are additional subjectivities at play in the marketplace. A "senior software engineer" at a cardboard box factory might not be the same role as one with the same name at an aerospace firm doing government contracts.
- commandlinefan 7y agoI’m shocked at how important software development is to the 21st century economy while we still don’t have anything even remotely resembling a licensing exam. I’d honestly welcome one, if for no other reason than to be able to make some assumptions about what my co-workers already know vs. what I’m going to have to explain: do they know what a socket is? Do they know how public key cryptography works? Do they know the difference between a unit test and an integration test? It might not be perfect, but it would be a heck of a lot better than what we have now.
- dudul 7y ago> Do they know the difference between a unit test and an integration test? Funny when you think of how many blog posts, flame wars, SO questions exist on the internet just to debate what is indeed a unit test, and what is an integration test :) Who would have the legitimacy to design such an exam?
- analog31 7y ago>>> Who would have the legitimacy to design such an exam? If it's like civil engineering, it would be the regulatory body that determines the approved technologies and design formulas for your field. The exam would be based on those standards. I'm not sure most governments would even approve public key cryptography. Better watch what you ask for. ;-)
- socialist_coder 7y agoyou'd just have people who learn how to pass the licensing exam by rote memory who still can't actually program
- jedberg 7y agoYou can make an exam that can't be passed this way. It just takes work to both create and grade.
- mrfredward 7y agoHow do you propose making the licensing exam harder to game than a well respected university's degree program? I would think anyone who can game four years of exams and projects at a good university would also be able to game a single-session licensing exam.
- ben509 7y ago> There are some folks like Tripplebyte who are trying to solve this by pre-qualifying candidates, but I don't think the problem will really be solved until we form a software engineering licensing board. Take a test once, and then take a refresher course every couple of years to maintain your license. It's risky. Licensure often becomes a wage-protection cartel, and if so, does little to guarantee the quality of licensees. Another problem is that there are many levels of skill demanded by the industry, though maybe you can have a bevy of licenses that qualify a person for various roles. That's my principle issue with the OP: they don't attempt to control for the possibility that people who hate technical interviews are most likely the people who didn't get the job they wanted. If you're working at company X and think, "I hate this shitty IT job, I'm smart enough to get a real developer position" and interview at company Y and learn that, no, you aren't, that's a hard pill to swallow. Yes, we all ought to find our zen and accept that no one has all the talent they wish they had. But people are human, so we're liable to blame the messenger, which is the technical interview.
- hysan 7y agoI’ll play a bit of devil’s advocate. It’s a hard pill to swallow because you don’t get feedback from rejections. It doesn’t matter what stage of the interview process you reached, companies very very very rarely give feedback when asked. Because of this, those people never get to hear why they aren’t good enough. Instead, it’s all left up to their imagination which creates the scenario you describe.
- jayd16 7y agoDo you realize how intensive the interview process for a doctor is? You work as an intern and essentially "perform surgeries" over the course of a year. >Therefore I must now conclude that a degree from that university means nothing. Degrees always mean nothing but the educations might still be useful, depending on what the individual took advantage of.
- gamblor956 7y agoDo you realize how intensive the interview process for a doctor is? You work as an intern and essentially "perform surgeries" over the course of a year. For the first job as a licensed physician. After the internship period, it's generally one or two in-person interviews (possibly more if you're joining a private practice), followed by a period of weeks to months where they check on your licensure and credentials.
- Madmallard 7y ago"We don't have that in our industry. I interviewed countless "senior engineers" with degrees from well regarded universities who couldn't write a simple loop. Therefore I must now conclude that a degree from that university means nothing." Seems like baloney
- imroot 7y agoThe hiring timeline for Doctors is in the months -- almost six months to a year -- because of all of the due diligence that is involved: it is sometimes more so for specialties like OB/GYN. Even to be brought on as a "Doc in a box" type of situation, you're still looking at a minimum of 90 days. Folks want to "move fast and break things," and "hire fast, fire faster," but those two are not conducive for doctors.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Legogris 7y agoThe reason that's not going to work is how diverse and specific skillsets there are, and how fast the progression is (at least so far) in what's in demand. Imagine the resources needed to maintain tests that should work for low-level embedded developers, data engineers, video game coders, smart contract programmers, AI implementors, etc..? Yes, there are fundamentals and Computer Science, but most of us agree that you can have the greatest craftspeople perform poorly there. Though, I guess the certifications from private companies like Microsoft in Cisco actually work as some kind of license
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bmn__ 7y agoDon't you have programming apprenticeships in your country?