7 ms·
I know of your personal experience, and thank you for your response. I actually hadn't realized that the surveillance bureaus had regulatory-captured general le
by mindslight 7y ago
I know of your personal experience, and thank you for your response. I actually hadn't realized that the surveillance bureaus had regulatory-captured general legal immunity so openly. So yes, I was overstating the legal situation thinking they would be better on the hook for libel. Frankly this overbearing immunity should be a talking point of every "identity theft" article, but unfortunately those articles are written from a perspective that is still wed to the primacy of this system.
> I think HNers might be surprised to learn that the state machine pretty routinely achieves the objectives
None of these stories really focus on irreversible damages (besides eg SIM swapping stealing cryptocurrency), but rather the time taken dealing with that "state machine". Diligently checking your own dossier is doing the surveillance bureau's work for them - adding to this perverse incentive where they don't bother doing the diligence of verifying loan applicants hoping that consumers will be responsible for guarding use of public identifiers associated with them.
A quick reading of the FCRA still doesn't show any statutory timeline within which surveillance subjects ("consumers") are required to verify the dossiers on themselves - compared to say regulation E which requires that you verify your legitimate account ledgers at least every month and a half (please correct me if I missed something). I'm not the type to be continually applying for new credit cards for whatever incentive they're offering, so dealing with any backscatter from identity fraud is purely a cost to me. The less I involve myself with their system, the more I can handle its involuntarily burden in "batch mode".