9 ms·
>> When will people wake up and realize that AI today is just capable of "curve fitting"? You are (possibly inadvertently) misquoting Judea Pearl and he was ta
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> When will people wake up and realize that AI today is just capable of "curve fitting"?
You are (possibly inadvertently) misquoting Judea Pearl and he was talking specifically about deep learning, not "AI":
“All the impressive achievements of deep learning amount to just curve fitting,” he said recently. [1]
"AI today" still means many more techniques and algorithms than deep learning. For example, SAT Solvers, logic programming and theorem provers, classical planning, classical search, adversarial search (MCTS) etc are alll AI techniques that have nothing to do with "curve fitting".
So could we please all not throw about big proclamations about what "AI today" is ("just" or not), without first making sure that we have a thorough understanding of what we are saying?
I thank us all in advance.
____________________
[1] https://www.quantamagazine.org/to-build-truly-intelligent-machines-teach-them-cause-and-effect-20180515/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/to-build-truly-intelligent-ma...
- codesushi42 7y agoFor example, SAT Solvers, logic programming and theorem provers, classical planning, classical search, adversarial search (MCTS) etc are alll AI techniques that have nothing to do with "curve fitting". None of those techniques are new, nor are they fueling the AI hype cycle. I purposely conflated AI with "deep learning" because it is the source of the hype. And in reality, what most AI startups claim to be using.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoDeep learning is not new either. LSTMs are from the 1990s. CNNs are from the 1980's (and note well that most recent successes of deep learning are basically tweaks of these two architectures). What is new is the hype around deep learning that took off after 2012, and because Google and Facebook decided to champion it. In any case, as far as I can tell "AI today" is anything that is "AI" and that exists "today". How do you mean "AI today"? >> I purposely conflated AI with "deep learning" because it is the source of the hype. I don't understand why you would do that. You are aware that there is hype and that it is increased by misuse of the term AI. And you purposefully misuse the term AI in a way that increases the hype? Why?
- codesushi42 7y agoWhere did I ever claim that deep learning is new? I am fully aware of its history. Before deep learning, research on neural networks dates all the way back to the 1950s. You are completely missing the point: "deep learning" and AI are mostly synonymous in the current hype cycle, and it began with breakthroughs in deep learning. How do you mean "AI today" The AI industry that I work in.
- dang 7y ago> You are completely missing the point Can you please edit swipes like that out of your comments here? They tend to degrade discussion. If you simply provide correct information, your comments will be stronger and their effect on the thread at large more salutary. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- corodra 7y agoThat's a weird thing to tell someone. A person can't say that they're being misunderstood because that degrades a discussion? Degrades how? Are you putting yourself as supreme judge of the situation? Reading through the back and forth, I agree that OP had some of their statements made into strawmen. Does it degrade to mention that I think they may be in the right? Maybe miss worded a bit, yes. But the general point made throughout, I think is valid. Is me disagreeing with you degrading your sensibilities?
- dang 7y agoOf course not, but there's a long road between "disagreeing" (which is no problem) to "saying you're being misunderstood" (may be fine, but usually is already a step down in discussion quality) to "you're completely missing the point" (outright swipe). Commenters here should stay in the former zone and avoid the latter. That's not hard to do.
- kranner 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y ago"AI" today isn't well defined. Many people mean deep learning. Others mean ML. Others mean even more. More than anything, "AI" is a marketing term, where vague buzzwords thrive.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoYes, I am aware that there is a gigantic feeding frenzy right now and people who have no idea what they are talking about are falling over each other to write "expert" articles where they make a complete mess of what is AI, what is machine learning and what is deep learning. But, that there are people who don't know what they're talking about is no reason to copy them, or to perpetuate their mistakes. Do you disagree?
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoYes, I disagree. It's not (just) that those people don't know what they're talking about. The term doesn't have a standard usage/definition. Or at least not standard enough to decide whether the traveling salesman problem, linear regression, or a SAT solver are AI.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThat AI doesn't have an agreed upon definition doesn't mean that we can say it is whatever we want to say it is! For example, you may perhaps argue (at a very big stretch) that travelling salesman is an AI problem- that's arguing on the details. But to claim that all of AI is reducible to one sub-sub-field of AI, deep learning? That's just ignoring the fact that there is an entire research field that is commonly called "AI", with conferences and journals that have "AI" in their name, that are not about deep learning, with many thousands of researchers who consider their work "AI" and who do not work with deep learning, not to mention the 50 or so years and the mountain of work that this field considers its own, that also is not about deep learning.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hitekker 7y ago> without first making sure that we have a thorough understanding of what we are saying? > I thank us all in advance. Off topic: I've seen this line a few times before, and somehow it always drips with condescension. As though the speaker assumes the understanding of everyone else is borne from laziness and not background.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]