5 ms·
I agree on WeWork, but Uber is clearly not a taxi company. They're closer to being a mobile app developer, though that still feels like it falls short of an ac
by rootusrootus 7y ago
I agree on WeWork, but Uber is clearly not a taxi company. They're closer to being a mobile app developer, though that still feels like it falls short of an accurate description.
- btown 7y agoUber made the right call in that it's asset-light; they don't long-term lease medallions or have long-term contracts with landlords (any more than a similarly sized technology company would). The We subsidiaries, on the other hand, are dreadfully asset-heavy. They can't just pack up and move out of a city that's underperforming. And as we all know, agile is as much about knowing when/how to stop doing something as it is about moving fast in doing new things. My only sadness is that this is so apparent that it will be immediately reflected in We's price, and there's likely not much opportunity to short these guys.
- browningstreet 7y agoI mostly agree with you, but I think what's happening here is reminiscent of the e-commerce vs brick&mortar debates from years ago. Ultimately, Amazon started as an e-commerce business that has a whole ton of brick and mortar capital and infrastructure. For a long time, tech companies wanted to do everything virtually (apps, cloud, etc) and people NOT from the tech industry had an understanding of the brick & mortar world and harnessed tech to create a boom of some kind. I think Uber is like that, in that the level of tech needed -- not just an app, but a global infrastructure that has to stay up and takes payments in a lot of countries -- when married with the real world, created a kind of behemoth. They're also financial structure jockeys, and We is more contracts & funding and not really all that much tech.
- OJFord 7y ago> but a global infrastructure that has to stay up and takes payments in a lot of countries To play devil's advocate though, that's just the 'back office' updated to replace manual book keeping with automatic software. (Well, 'just'.) I think we can usefully describe companies as both 'tech-heavy company in the <domain>' and '<domain> company that uses tech' depending where the emphasis should be for a particular sentence. It just doesn't really mean anything to me alone.
- novok 7y agoGoogle is 'just' replacing library card catalogs with software :p
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoThey provide a service that lets you summon a car and driver to take you somewhere for money. From the user's point of view, the only structural differences are that you use an app instead of your voice and payment is easier. It's dramatically different on the back end than a traditional taxi company, but the service is the same.
- wolco 7y agoUber was ride sharing company with some tech. They are a little bit different than a taxi company
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoUber is a taxi company with creative outsourcing of taxis and drivers.
- rhizome 7y agoUber is a taxi company that replaced the taxi industry's global pain point: dispatchers, with an app. Secondary: medallions (which are eventually coming back via regulation). How they populate their inventory of drivers is not particularly special. You used to be able to drive a hack for a few hours and lose money doing it, too. That part hasn't changed, you can just lose that money driving your own car now.
- alkonaut 7y agoBecause they develop their app in house they are an app dev and not a taxi co? Are all taxi companies that have apps and develop them in-house app companies and not taxi companies? Are their revenue coming from apps or from rides? That's the clue.