5 ms·
> Why should it be different for emissions? Because we clearly don't know how to do it properly. And individual wishes are not important when we talk about the
by lm28469 7y ago
> Why should it be different for emissions?
Because we clearly don't know how to do it properly. And individual wishes are not important when we talk about the future of mankind.
It's all fun and games when we talk about one dude, multiply that by 8b and you're doomed, there is just no way to make it work.
> you would end up in a carbon-free pre-industrial world
Cut off the worst causes of pollution, what's hard to understand ? We don't have to go back to a pre industrial world, we simply need to adjust the balance, we're clearly fucking it up right now. Just don't spend 4 weekends a year 1000km away from your home, stop shipping fruits from the other side of the world, don't drive a V8 when you can drive a small 3 cyl car, don't eat meat at every meal / every day, don't buy the next iGadget as soon as it's released. Are any of these going to seriously impact your well being ? nope.
It's not like getting shitfaced on a beach in Ibiza or taking pictures of the Eiffel tower is going to deeply change your life (because let's be honest 5 min, the majority of travel is for leisure). If you put personal needs above everything else we're toast, 8b people living like the average American would destroy the world in a few years. Travel is a luxury, not a right, people need to understand that, it might be cheap money wise but you're selling away the future of mankind.
> All human (civilizing) action is aimed at enlarging the space of possibilities.
Remember all the ancient civilisations that expanded too quickly or were not able to sustain their lifestyles ? I'm sure they were thinking just like that.
- sebst 7y ago> Remember all the ancient civilisations that expanded too quickly or were not able to sustain their lifestyles ? I'm sure they were thinking just like that. What makes you think, this civilisation is collectively going to behave more sensible? We (broadly) accept the idea of evolution in biology. I'm pretty sure this works well on sociology, too. Or, put differently: We _will_ fuck it up. If it's not the climate crisis, it will be something else. Or: In a world where one nation alone has enough weapons to literally nuke the whole world, it is a strong bet to say that we'll be doomed on pollution. > multiply that by 8b and you're doomed, there is just no way to make it work. I believe the the 8bn are a problem on its own.
- lm28469 7y agoYes we will fuck it up no matter what, that's why we have laws, you can't run straight pipes on a car, you can't burn the furnitures you don't need anymore, you can't kill someone, you can't throw mining byproducts into rivers &c. Why couldn't we limit the amount of plane travel people are allowed for leisure ? Ban imports of unnecessary goods ? limit product cycles (Do we need 200 new models of phones per year ?) ? Prevent subsidisation schemes ? Nobody expects the individual to care for the planet or to even to be interested in the topic, that's why we rely on higher authorities to enforce laws. 8bn isn't a problem in itself, the hard cap is at least 50% more. The problem is that we live like there is no problem and that we deify "technology" as if progress just happens by itself and will save us if we continue in that direction. It's a textbook definition of wishful thinking. Somehow anything short of the status quo became "getting back to the middle ages" ...
- sebst 7y ago> Why couldn't we ... Steps involved: - Convince people that it's necessary ("do we really need it?") - Find a commonly accepted measure ("how much can I personally still travel") - Prevent loop holes ("But my neighbour has been to Mallorca recently") - Put laws into power. Globally (And one small country won't join the stuff and you'll end up full of envy at the point before, but on a higher scale). - Enforce the law. Globally. Fight corruption. Sure, we could... But try to limit gun posession in the US, or speed limits in Germany. Whatever people feel will reduce their freedom will make them oppose. If your idea is to implement all this democratically, it's a very weak selling point for politicians. If you pitch it, you're even missing the pain point. Most people do care way more about their next weekend than about the "future of mankind". > 8bn isn't a problem in itself, the hard cap is at least 50% more. Also a strong claim. What is it based upon? If we cannot scale the western life style for any of the 8bn, even if we could technologically, we're already behind the hard cap. It's not just "feed" them all, it's making them all "happy", reducing "envy" etc. More people, more conflicts. 8bn is a number this planet has never seen before (like it has never seen before this amount of pollution), and yet you claim that this "experiment" can be enlarged by 50%? > Somehow anything short of the status quo became "getting back to the middle ages" According to climate science, ~0.6t - 1.2t is the annual budget per person, if you want to stop climate change[0]. Now, look at this map[1]: Below 1 tonne per person is the lightest colour on this map. Compare the living standard of these countries to the middle ages and you'll come close. [0]: https://www.quora.com/What-should-be-a-persons-average-carbon-footprint-per-year-if-we-want-to-reduce-and-stop-global-warming https://www.quora.com/What-should-be-a-persons-average-carbo... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions_per_capita#/media/File:Co2_emissions_per_capita_our_world_in_data.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...