4 ms·
> Why dont we have high-speed trains in Europe which can load cars and go 250-300km/h and the trip would be done in 6-8h at most? We kind of do, it's just not
by lm28469 7y ago
> Why dont we have high-speed trains in Europe which can load cars and go 250-300km/h and the trip would be done in 6-8h at most?
We kind of do, it's just not very common. You can take the train from hamburg to vienna with your car for example, and I know there are a few other lines.
You can also simply take the train and rent an electric car when you get to your destination, seems easier and more convenient to me. I don't think the future of "solving climate change" involves owning private cars, even electric, and carrying it around in trains, there is no way this would be scalable to the amount of people traveling by plane.
> Why has train travel been so undeveloped for past 20 years in all of EU?
The real problem is that plane tickets are so subsidised than it's nearly impossible to make the other means of transportation competitive, and in the end that's all people care about, money.
If you want to travel inside France or Germany (for example) you're good, but as soon as you cross borders and don't want to go your destination country's capital you're doomed. Taking the train from Berlin to a major TGV station next to my hometown takes 9 hours and cost 150 euros. By plane it takes 3 hours total and cost <35 euros. I'd take the train if it was half of its current price.
The only way to "solve climate change" is to simply not travel as much, no more romantic weekends in Rome or 4 days trips to mallorca, &c ...
- milsebg 7y ago> The only way to "solve climate change" is to simply not travel as much, no more romantic weekends in Rome or 4 days trips to mallorca, &c ... That's exactly what I talked about in other comments. To you, these 4 day trips are the most wasteful usage of resources. To others, it may be the over-consumption of fashion. To a single person, a weekend in Paris could mean the world, maybe because it saved their relationship and prevented a burn-out or.... If you extrapolate that argument (and if you don't, you'd need to explain where to stop why), you would end up in a carbon-free pre-industrial world and yet would still have a huge environmental debt of the co2 we've already blown out. Not to mention 8 billion human beings which produce co2 and methane per their bare existence. Humans, in general, react to immediate rewards (which is why addictions are a thing at all). So it would be nearly impossible to build climate policy upon abdications without risking revolts. All human (civilizing) action is aimed at enlarging the space of possibilities. The solution to car accidents was not less traffic, but better cars. The solution to food shortage was not caloric restrictions but better agricultural tech (also worldwide, humans are suffering less and less from hunger), the solution to IPv4 shortage was not restriction, but a better protocol. The solution to handicaps in humans was not euthanasia, but development of medical devices. All that aimed at enlarging the space of possibilities. Why should it be different for emissions?
- antocv 7y agoI agree with you. We cant ask to return to middle ages. Emissions from transportation is different, since the true costs of air and fossil-burning-car travel compared to train travel is not reflected on the price.
- milsebg 7y ago> I agree with you. We cant ask to return to middle ages. True. So, maybe high-speed trains are not the solution, yet. It might be that they're missing a technological pinch, yet. In the same way battery technology was a pinch to electrical cars (which are around at least as long as fossil burning cars, just not usable, because... battery...). As long as a solution is dependent on politics or taxation, it is a sign that there is still some pinch to tweak, some idea to discover or some detail to improve. > fossil-burning-car travel compared to train travel is not reflected on the price. Partly agreed. It's difficult to find a price. What does the emission of one metric ton of CO2 cost? The sum of the actuarial costs of damages to property attributed to climate change divided by the total number of tonnes produced? Is it the sum of the costs of the effort to save such tonne? Then, is a tonne a tonne? What if you emit CO2 to produce a material which reduces the damages to houses from thunderstorms? Will you get credited the part which led to lower costs of damages? And even, if you found the right price. Who is the beneficiary whom this price is paid to? Is it the people? So, what if democracy decides to use (a chunk of?) these taxes to rise pensions? Or to support young families? Or to rescue people from drowning in the Mediterranean on their escape from violations of their human rights? Or to improve the healthcare system? There is no such thing as earmarked taxes.
- antocv 7y ago> Who is the beneficiary whom this price is paid to? Is it the people? So, what if democracy decides to use (a chunk of?) these taxes to rise pensions? Or to support young families? Or to rescue people from drowning in the Mediterranean on their escape from violations of their human rights? Or to improve the healthcare system? Yes to all of those. If you said "to pay Microsoft licenses" I qould squirm and say yes. Taxation, then democratically elected representatives get to decide what to spend the money on, even if I personally dont agree.
- antocv 7y ago> I don't think the future of "solving climate change" involves owning private cars, even electric, and carrying it around in trains, there is no way this would be scalable to the amount of people traveling by plane. Of course, it would not scale, it would only be an incentive to bring more passangers to trains in the beginning. Well, as a tech enthusiast, I really doubt the "return to live as in middle ages" will work to solve anything, and that is not necessary. Technological solutions exist, and we will be able to travel without destroying for future generations, high speed trains are such a solution.