3 ms·
France being a net exporter isn't a positive of nuclear, it's one of its drawbacks. Every country can't be a net exporter, so Nuclear in France is subsidized by
by ZeroGravitas 7y ago
France being a net exporter isn't a positive of nuclear, it's one of its drawbacks. Every country can't be a net exporter, so Nuclear in France is subsidized by sales to countries who do not have their own nuclear.
If those countries built their own nuclear then neither they nor France would be economic since everyone would have the excess power at the same time. We can't export power to other planets, so nuclear is not an economic solution for the whole globe, it only works at small scale when the rest of the system can absorb the inflexible power.
Note that wind and solar have similar issues, which require geographic spread, oversupply and storage to meet. They can do that and still be cheaper than nuclear in an apple to apples comparison.
- bboygravity 7y agoThe reality is that France is the only country in Europe who converts most of it's energy through nuclear. So in that reality it's definitely an advantage to be a net exporter. This advantage becomes even more pronounced as other countries switch to non-continuous power sources such as wind and solar. Those sources have production drops around the same times (at nights and cloudy days with little wind), where France can charge a nice premium to produce nuclear for them. "and storage to meet" --> There is currently no economically viable way to store electric energy from "sustainable" non-continuous sources at a large scale. If there was, we wouldn't be having this discussion right now.
- pharke 7y agoPerhaps a larger electric grid would solve the issue? Power consumption varies greatly by time of day and even greater by local climate. Or perhaps we should put the excess to good use, desalination and pumping of water is very power intensive but would allow us to green the Sahara. Where there is abundance there is innovation, I'm sure we could find a use for it.
- dsq 7y agoPutting off peak nuclear power to work generating hydrogen fuel is an option. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_economy
- littlestymaar 7y ago> everyone would have the excess power at the same time […] it only works at small scale when the rest of the system can absorb the inflexible power. You know that nuclear power is pretty flexible right ? France actually pilot most of the load variations through its nuclear plants. You can see it here: [1]. The only thing you can't really do at scale is turning on and off a reactor every once in a while, but you can easily go from 100% to 50% power in a few hours. You can even go further (down to 25% with recent fuel) but then you'll start burning the fuel in a sub-obtimal way, so they limit the number of times they go bellow 50% power. [1] https://rte-france.com/fr/eco2mix/eco2mix-mix-energetique https://rte-france.com/fr/eco2mix/eco2mix-mix-energetique
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoYes I know. It doesn't change the economics as there's no fuel savings. It's the same as overbuilding solar or wind and dumping the excess, you still pay the full price for the hardware and running costs so there's no real benefit to turning it down. You might as well find a cheap productive use for it (like making hydrogen as suggested by another commenter). But you'd be able to make that electricity that you're throwing away or using for hydrogen production cheaper with a non nuclear source.
- littlestymaar 7y agoWhile this is partly true (but not 100% accurate, you do save fuel when you reduce power) that doesn't change the fact that EDF does indeed use nuclear to pilot the power supply and that would work even with no European network to buy the surplus (they would make a little less money indeed, but that wouldn't change their business model at all).