10 ms·
Tumblr
- tryitnow 7y agoShould we start entertaining the admittedly simple-minded notion that it is not tumblr that is under-valued, but everything else is over-valued?
- Mirioron 7y agoI think this is very likely. The only way I can see companies like Twitter being worth as much as they are is their potential political power. A company like Twitter has a lot of influence over that, but I don't think they create such an enormous amount of value.
- lowdose 7y agoIt's still pretty cool everyone can engage with the United States president or with an Elon Musk. Every user is aware of that reach.
- FussyZeus 7y agoI'd add that social media, done well, cannot and should not be monetized. There is simply no overlap between what makes a service engaging to use to the degrees needed to make advertising profitable, and the priorities set forth to grow a community that is a net addition to the lives of its members. Call me starry eyed if you want, but I think while we do absolutely need a Facebook, that it shouldn't be a private business. It should be a public good, funded by the public, for the public and its interests.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI've long been a bit troubled by the valuation of newspapers during the dead tree era vs the valuation of their electron based replacements.
- elbac 7y agoWe DDOS'd Fred.
- cwmma 7y agoif he still hosted his blog on tumblr he wouldn't have this problem
- csbartus 7y agoI’m still using it since 2009 everyday. For design inspiration. As a moodboard. And still works as in the good old days. Tumblr made me a better designer. By catching up with the latest in print and graphic design and porting thse trends to web I had a work featured very early in Brutalist Websites. I use no other social network. It’s simply too much. And yes a heart is good enough.
- rolltiide 7y agoDiversity of decision making would still help Tumblr. You know in which ways.
- tene 7y agoI actually have no idea what you're alluding to here; can you be a bit more explicit for us oblivious readers?
- rolltiide 7y agoSure, The CEO of Tumblr David Karp made unilateral decisions which stifled its growth and utility. Any additional decision making input would have helped here, but qualified women, minorities and people accompanying David, Fred (the author of this article) and Marco (1st engineer) would have greatly helped so the winds here. Be more in tune with the audience that grew. After the second sale to Verizon, after David left, different leadership could have understood how the erotic content community was flourishing on Tumblr in ways that the erotic industry has failed to attract. Many women liked tumblr for porn sharing, browsing, and curating because other porn-specific sites have unclean interfaces and distracting ads. There were people that could have told them that in the decision making process, and helped navigate the issues encountered since that is what was driving engagement. Automattic also seems to fail to understand this, with CEO Matt Mullenweg's explanation seeming to complete miss the point, and looks more like a pet project than any interest in engagement.
- aylmao 7y ago> But it is also true that Tumblr was bypassed by native mobile applications like Instagram and Snapchat where it was even easier to post about your life. This. It's understated how much Tumblr's clunky composing hurt it as a platform. I know people connected to Tumblr, and from what I hear there was a lot of ideas but little direction. There was a time when Tumblr was bigger than Instagram— Tumblr could've focused more on making it an amazing photo-sharing service. Snapchat was/is loved by its anonymity and ephemerality, but Tumblr was already an anonymous social network well before it. They could've added features for ephemerality and explored that market. I used tumblr for consuming a lot of content, and it was great for that, but I always thought it had potential to be better for sharing too.
- bitwize 7y ago> This. It's understated how much Tumblr's clunky composing hurt it as a platform. Indeed. I called it Fumblr for a reason -- I was always fumbling with its UI.
- markandrewj 7y agoI think you are talking about current developments, but it is worth mentioning that when Twitter launched it was just as flip phones started to be replaced by smartphones. Most people were interacting with the service through SMS. To me, it felt like the progress with further developing tumblr slowed after Marco Arment moved onto other projects. From a historic perspective, this may an interesting article to some people. https://marco.org/2013/05/20/one-person-product?utm_source=feedly https://marco.org/2013/05/20/one-person-product?utm_source=f...
- scarface74 7y agoTumblr has given my family a strong safety net and given me the freedom to work on whatever I want. And that’s exactly what I plan to do. Rumors are that he made $5-$7 million. But he definitely made enough to have f%%#-you money.
- danso 7y agoAnd this is ironic in how much Tumblr itself simplified the blogging experience, by having several pre-built formats (e.g. photo, text, video). I had a regular Wordpress blog but found it so much easier to casually post photos to my Tumblr.
- galfarragem 7y agoTumblr is an hidden secret and totally underrated. I run two niche blogs on tumblr since 2011 with full control of themes and content, https, social sharing, without compulsory ads and using my own domain. SEO was a negative point but nowadays is good enough. All of this for free. Wordpress offer, AFAIK, is not nearly as good. Thank you Tumblr.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoI agree, I use it to look at paintings and to blog about painters I am researching and it’s wonderful the depth and breadth of content available on so many subjects. My feed is overflowing and I’ve only skimmed the surface.
- tnorthcutt 7y agoThe news hit yesterday that WordPress has purchased Tumblr WordPress != Automattic. More context here: https://poststatus.com/resources/wordpress-versus-automattic/ https://poststatus.com/resources/wordpress-versus-automattic...
- codesushi42 7y agoNow we are stuck with Facebook, a closed platform. Or Reddit, which masquerades as an open platform, but is really closed shut. There's only Twitter now. And Twitter kind of sucks.
- mooreds 7y agoHate to say it, but what do you mean by "stuck"? Stuck in what way?
- codesushi42 7y agoThere are no good, open alternatives that are widely used.
- navigatesol 7y ago"Stuck" is a slight exaggeration. I can still punch whatever I want into my address bar. Why is "widely used" required? Do you search/discover through Tumblr?
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoBefore a bunch of artists were driven off tumblr due to the overly strict adult policy (the appeals process etc. was too much of a pain) Tumblr was my go-to for a lot of artists in the niches I followed. Through this, I found a ton of communities- fandoms for the characters created by the artists, collective worldbuilding, etc. Also, within niche fandoms I followed I also found artists that produced wonderful works. There's still an ongoing webcomic (A Tale of Two Rulers) that's a world where Zelda and Gannon choose to marry instead of war on tumblr. It's incredibly awesome and part of what I'm on tumblr for.
- zanny 7y agoThere are plenty of Mastodon instances revolving around almost any topic out there to join. Having a successful social space does not necessitate, and I'd argue precludes, having a universal audience of everyone. Also, you are currently on what would qualify as a social network, and between HN, Mastodon, and choice tech subreddits like I find myself well inundated with social forums to talk about stuff on. Thats even precluding how Github and Gitlab have turned into faux social networks around projects, how IRC and Matrix exist as real time chat options, etc.
- laser 7y agoI had heard the "well below 20m" figure and couldn't believe it—and now Fred is saying they dumped it for $3 million? I suppose if Verizon is taking the tax deduction on an original $1.1 billion purchase by Yahoo, the value of the deduction so much dwarfs the sale price that the difference to Yahoo between a $3 million sale price and a $50 million sale price is pretty minimal—they just want to close the deal to take the deduction and stop the losses. Still, considering the fact that Tumblr still does over 2.5 billion page views per month [1], not even counting their mobile usage, I can't help but gawk at what a steal Automattic got. Really drives home what their CEO Matt Mullenweg said on here the other day about adopting a "Berkshire model"—although he was referring to independent management, what he's really talking about is buying companies grossly undervalued for dirt-cheap. Just monetizing the web traffic 2.5 billions monthly hits at a $1 CPM alone would generate $2.5 million a month in revenue, $30 million annually. What kind of business, let alone web business, sells for 1/10th annual revenue? For reference, Reddit does 6x the page views, but is valued at $3 billion. Reddit's prospects are obviously better, but are they 1000/6 = 166x times better per current page view? Mind-boggling. [1] https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com https://www.similarweb.com/website/tumblr.com
- jartelt 7y agoAssuming you want to keep Tumblr running, you are also buying the ~200 employees and the costs of running the site. Assuming the 200 employees cost $100k each (salary + benefits) and you are already at $20M in costs.
- laser 7y agoIf I bought Tumblr in a $3 million fire sale, I don't think I'd keep 200 employees on the payroll, but yes, it combined with the tax write-off and infrastructure costs it's reasonable for Yahoo to want to dump it as fast as possible—they could easily be losing $5M a month on it. I'm just shocked there aren't more opportunists in the market that would have bid the price up to at least something resembling reasonable. That being said, even an extremely well-executed turn-around could be 6 months until break-even, which would require potentially upfront $30 million in losses, in which context the sale price is insignificant, and so the question becomes who has web business expertise + $30 million in cash to burn and desire to confidently make a $15-20 million annual profit business a year or two out. Apparently, not many people/companies.
- szczepano 7y agoTheir next place is 404.
- SanchoPanda 7y agoI saw the headline about the sale without the buyer in it and was sure that it had to be pinboard. That would have been something.
- chx 7y agoThat's not what Maciej does. He is laser focused on bookmarking. That's why his company thrives.
- raihansaputra 7y agoHe said on Twitter he wish he had the money to do it, but alas he doesn't.
- par 7y ago"Tumblr was an example of how to do social media right and we can learn a lot from it." I mean... maybe. Tumblr was also an example of maybe not pivoting the product to cater to the community properly, as there was a lot of other usage of Tumblr besides a strictly 'social media' use case. There was a lot of conversation around deeper feelings, and a community around self-discovery and self-awareness. I'm not 100% sure if Tumblr was able to properly capture that market and position itself there.
- azinman2 7y ago“Tumblr was an example of how to do social media right and we can learn a lot from it.“ Except it lost, so by definition it can’t be right. Update: there are clearly many definitions of right. Here I’m using right in the sense that it gets mass adoption (right in that people prefer it), and right in the sense that it also simultaneously does net positive for the world. Achieving both is difficult.
- pmlnr 7y ago"Lost". It did not lose in term of being a better social experience. People after pale fame and instant gratification left to chase the "i wanna be famous", Total Drama Island style, but this has nothing to do with socially or morally better.
- derefr 7y agoThe best product for users can also inherently have no business model. Doesn't mean it's not the best product. (Example: BitTorrent.)
- causality0 7y ago>Tumblr was a happy place and using it made people feel good about themselves. Uh, what? Just off the top of my head I can think of people who've been bullied on Tumblr into attempted suicide.
- aussieguy1234 7y agoAs a long time Tumblr user, it's sad to see it's downfall. I had hope that Automattic would change the content policies that brought the site down, but it seems that won't be the case. But the fun isn't over just yet. I've launched Libr (https://librapp.com https://librapp.com) to replace Tumblr. It's an installable Progressive Web App, getting around app store rules (recall when the Apple app store banned Tumblr). There's a few hundred users on there that have given me good feedback on improving Libr and it's starting to slowly take off, although I'm not in any hurry and I'm taking my time to make it awesome before turning on the floodgates.
- zrobotics 7y agoPlease fix your site- it breaks the back button. This looked interesting, but I immediately hate any site that breaks back-button functionality; and once I notice that I instantly assume either malicious intent or incompetence. I get that it's a PWA, but can't the welcome page just be a regular page?
- skrebbel 7y ago> turning on the floodgates You make it sound like it's easy.
- phreack 7y agoQuick tip, the sign up doesn't trim emails and validates them against some rule that fails on 'blah@blah.com '. I strongly suggest not validating emails except by simply trying to send one, it's the worst case to lose an user that's willing to register due to a corner case your regex missed.
- ptest1 7y agoIn 2017, Tumblr had ~400 employees. If each employee had a modest $50k retention bonus, that’s at least an additional $20M. So I’m not sure the total cost for the purchase as $3M- maybe that was just for the corporate assets.
- avip 7y agoMr. Wilson's understanding of Tumblr is flawed [0]. There's a simple objective test (now irrelevant) to tell if a platform is largely about porn or not: [required ingredients: 1 searchable user-content platform, 1 keyboard, 1 daughter (optional)] 0. Go to thing 1. Open search bar 2. Open your hand 3. Hit keyboard with an open flat hand 4. Enter 5. Browse results - count how many you feel comfortable with your daughter being portrayed in 6. 50% is your thresh. Tumblr was a successful porn platform. Take that off the equation and you're left with nothing. [0] https://avc.com/2016/07/trashing-tumblr/ https://avc.com/2016/07/trashing-tumblr/
- NoahTheDuke 7y ago> 5. Browse results - count how many you feel comfortable with your daughter being portrayed in My daughter can do whatever she wants. Why are you shaming sex workers?
- jpm_sd 7y agoWhy did they even buy it? It's been on life support for years: https://mashable.com/2016/06/15/how-yahoo-derailed-tumblr/ https://mashable.com/2016/06/15/how-yahoo-derailed-tumblr/
- shagie 7y agoYahoo bought tumblr. Verizon bought Yahoo - they weren't likely specifically after tumblr, it just game as part of the package.
- AlexDragusin 7y ago> It is absolutely true that Yahoo! never figured out how to turn Tumblr into a business and ending up losing its shirt on the investment. Given that Yahoo never figured out how to turn search into a business, that speaks volumes of their ability to connect dots.
- philwelch 7y agoIt’s easy to be sentimental about Tumblr now, but as we grow increasingly aware of the ability for social media to create echo chambers that radicalize people, it shouldn’t be forgotten that Tumblr is in many ways one of the worst examples of this phenomenon. And this was no more abundantly clear than during its porn heyday. I don’t regret the downfall of Tumblr one bit.
- hoseja 7y agoTumblr was one of the first platforms I felt had actively hostile UI/UX The ephemeral nature of the reblog, the dashboard awfulness, the impossibility of navigating thousands of likes/"comments"/... under a popular post. No way to, e.g. sort followed blogs by latest post time. I felt these things could have been easily fixed but deliberately weren't.