4 ms·
> That's partly because the market boom is itself a self-fulfilling prophecy. Stock markets go up because other people think they're going up. I'm really curio
by paganel 7y ago
> That's partly because the market boom is itself a self-fulfilling prophecy. Stock markets go up because other people think they're going up.
I'm really curious how the index funds will behave in the upcoming recession, afaik that was one of their main mantras and selling points, so to speak, i.e. that the market only goes up (or a certain part of the market, the most important part of the market) and that you'd be a fool not riding the wave by investing in said index funds which were in turn investing in that part of the market "assured" to always go up.
In other words, what will people do when they'll see their index funds go down 10 or 20% yoy? Will they take their money out of said index funds? Will they wait for the next uptick?
- raincom 7y agoWhen a market crashes, we will see 20% drop becoming 40%--its all exponential drop offs, as people pull out money, when not many buyers around.
- neogodless 7y agoIndex funds will do exactly as well as the aggregate of the individual stocks that they track (whether equities, bonds, treasuries, real estate, metals or something else.) The selling point is that investing (as opposed to trading) is a long-term method of increasing wealth. And, historically over any reasonably long period of time, broad index funds grow (between dividends and selling price) more than inflation, and do so without requiring the individual investor to "bet right" on individual companies, or to time when they buy and sell. Of course, some people panic when index funds see massive drops (which are often much worse than 20%) and sell when the price is much lower. They lock in the losses thinking they can perfectly time the "low point" and buy back in at just the right moment. (A few are right. Most are not!) Investing does include personal tolerances for risk, an ability to be patient, etc so you have to figure that out for yourself. But the most successful investment plans are a combination of diversification and sticking to your plan through the bad times as well as the good. You shouldn't be reacting to the market (as a long-term investor.) You should have a solid plan in place. If you have a firm asset allocation of 80% stocks and 20% bonds with a line item in your investment policy statement that says "Re-balance when there is 5% or greater drift" then you wait until you cross that drift threshold, sell and buy what you need to get back to your target asset allocation, and you go on with your daily life.
- Anon1096 7y agoWe've already seen this in 2008. The funds will go down, then once the recession passes will return to normal. Long term holders have little to fear.
- turk73 7y agoThat's a pretty naive assessment. The reason stocks came roaring back was because of Quantitative Easing. There is no guarantee that further new easing could have the same effect. Governments worldwide basically bailed everything out by adding mountains (TRILLIONS) of new debt to replace the debt that vanished by write-offs. It was all highly unethical to bail out Wall Street at the cost of Main St. Regular people got fucked big time.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoPulling out of an index fund after you've been hit by a market crash is a really bad strategy. Either pull out now and put your money in a savings account, or stay in the index fund for the long run.
- hammock 7y agoAre you in index funds? Take a look at what they did in 2008. The selling point is not "they only go up." It's "you can't beat the market."
- xwdv 7y agoIt is a myth that the market can’t be beaten. You can beat the market if you take more risk and it works out for you. I’m beating the market right now, I’m up 33% this year still in my portfolio even with all the bullshit that’s happened. And recently, I’ve dumped all the extra margin I was holding so now I’m holding 100% equity in my stocks and paying no interest. Beating this market since 2010. That’s why my net worth is well above a million with little to no effort. I took a risk yes, but it’s not greater than the risk of building a startup and trying to make it successful which people seem to have no problem doing around here.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoIts easy to beat the market. Just say you did! But seriously, there are always outliers who got lucky. For every one that gambles on a dark horse, there are 1000 who lost that way. And the winner is always, always certain that they knew what they were doing and luck wasn't involved.
- xwdv 7y agoFrankly, with the market we’ve had the last 10 years practically anyone can beat the market as long as they invest in decent tech stocks. That’s why there’s so many millionaires running around here these days.
- fwip 7y agoLottery winners will tell you that playing the lottery was the smartest decision they ever made.
- turk73 7y agoSays every arrogant trader ever, right before their killer strategy took a big shit on them. Anyone beating the market year after year is trading on insider information. Prove me wrong. As far as your boast of "being up 33% this year" some Vanguard funds are up 23, 24, 25% and those are no-brainer buy and hold mutual funds. So regardless if your additional ~10%, you aren't going to win this race in one year and you are discussing "unrealized gains" which are simply not real. If you're trading on margin, I hope you can handle the leverage on the downside because I watched A LOT of people lose not only all their money in '08 and '09 but also their homes, marriages, etc.