8 ms·
In Germany, couples with more than €5160/month belong to the upper class
- esotericn 7y agoNo, they don't. The upper class live off investments. I'm not even going to look but just guess that 60K EUR/year isn't even enough to buy a house near Frankfurt or another decent sized city. They might be in a high percentile. That only means that most people are very poor.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y ago60k euro puts you in the top 0.11%[0] globally in terms of income. "It would take the average labourer in Zimbabwe 71 years to earn the same amount." [0]http://www.globalrichlist.com/ http://www.globalrichlist.com/
- danharaj 7y agoGP already told you: living off ownership of capital.
- benj111 7y agoThat also includes pensioners, some of whom may not be that well off.
- marvin 7y agoTreating pensions as capital is an interesting twist. Relatively accurate in one economical sense, but it's a bit of an edge case and not accurate in others. Pensions are usually a part of the "social contract", and usually pensioners have only a few years of expected healthy life left. So in most cases, a pension is more akin to having decent savings than having enough capital to live off investment income perpetually. Also, crucially, pensions rarely pass on money to inheritors, and almost never enough that the inheritors can live indefinitely from the income.
- benj111 7y agoIt depends on what country you live in, in the UK at least you have a small state pension and private pensions can be saved on top. These can optionally be used to buy an annuity. 'A few years' seems an understatement for what is reasonably expected to be 20+ years, I'm not sure what difference the healthy modifier brings. But yes, an annuity wouldn't generally allow you to pass on family wealth. That isn't the dividing line that was being discussed though.
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoRedefine: their earning from capital investments alone are enough to put them in the top 10% of the population.
- benj111 7y agoTop 10% of assets? This [1] suggests that $1,180,000 would put you in the top 10% in the US, which if you're living off (and in) it won't stretch that far. If top 10% of income earners, that's quite a movable feast. If I have $1,000,000 in shares earning 10% and taking all as income, am I rich, if I've got $10,000,000 in less risky investments, and after reinvesting to account for inflation, earning 1% the same amount of rich? One advantage of taking an income from assets is that you can choose how and when. I suspect the latter approach notionally invested in some prudent fashion would give a figure comparable to a wage, I misses out on some big differences though, no having to work, worry about getting sick, having the money there if you need is a major psychological boost, and if you want to buy a house, you can, plus you can pass on assets, which you can't do with a job. [1] https://dqydj.com/net-worth-percentile-calculator-united-states/ https://dqydj.com/net-worth-percentile-calculator-united-sta...
- alexgmcm 7y agoBut the variance in the cost of living globally is also huge - so just comparing income doesn't really make sense.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoIt costs pretty much the same to live in a tin shack with no running water or electricity and eat rice and beans for every meal everywhere. This whole "cost of living" thing is a rationalization to make westerners feel better.
- asutekku 7y agoI’m pretty sure a bag of rice is way more cheaper in the countries where it is produced versus the countries where it’s exported. In some countries it’s more expensive to be poor than in others.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y ago$8.43 gets you 20 pounds of rice in the west, 42 cents a pound. How much cheaper could it be? Put it this way, India is a relatively wealthy nation and a large proportion of middle class Indians don't have flush toilets. How can you compare that to a middle class European with a straight face? It's not that the cost of living is lower it's that standards of living are. https://www.walmart.com/ip/Great-Value-Long-Grain-Enriched-Rice-20-lb https://www.walmart.com/ip/Great-Value-Long-Grain-Enriched-R...
- Aaargh20318 7y ago> It costs pretty much the same to live in a tin shack with no running water or electricity and eat rice and beans for every meal everywhere. No it doesn't. First of all, the price of land can vary wildly. One square meter in the middle of Amsterdam will be a bit more than a square meter in Bumfuck, Alabama. IF you can buy land at all, in some places you can only lease it (you could own a home, but not the ground it sits on). Then there's all kinds of taxes you'd have to pay, just for owning that piece of land. A 19.5ft by 8ft parking spot in London was on the market a few years back for £350,000, and you won't even be allowed to build a shed on it, just park your car. An empty lot without even a tin shack can cost more than a mansion, depending on location.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> If that isn't upper class what is 0.01%? A statistical threshold. Europe has a landed aristocracy with political power, tax and social advantages and investments to last generations. The upper class lives off investment income. The middle class requires income to achieve its goals (if not survive). The practical effect of this distinction is people over whom employers have power versus those over whom employment, if it exists, is electively pursues.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Sharlin 7y ago"Class" is intrinsically culture-specific. I'm not sure whether "global upper class" is a meaningful concept.
- romanovcode 7y ago60k NET EUR is a lot of money tho
- asutekku 7y agoYes, globally, but that’s a completely different story in Europe where this story is based in. The global upper class is not the same as upper class in germany or in italy or in finland.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- esotericn 7y agoYes, it's a high income globally. "Class" in the European sense is not an income based thing. It falls apart a bit at the extremes (what is Jeff Bezos?) but it'd be incorrect to categorise e.g. a CEO as being upper-class despite them being in the 99th percentile by income in their country. The term really describes nobility, inheritance, large land ownership. Existing in a different 'class'.
- rexgallorum2 7y agoFor the German bourgeoisie, it's education and cultivation. (Education and profession are probably more important class markers than actual income or wealth.) The genuine upper class may or may not care about either because their status is drawn from other things.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dtech 7y agoNote that it is €5.160 net income, so that's about €100-110K/year gross income in germany ($110-120K). Gross income in Europe is also after pension contributions and employer taxes.
- Retric 7y agoInvestments are not limited to physical things. People making 100+K per year pretax are making money off of investments in education etc. PS: For more physical examples, a stripper can deduct cosmetic surgery from their taxes. http://backalleytaxes.com/is-cosmetic-surgery-tax-deductible/ http://backalleytaxes.com/is-cosmetic-surgery-tax-deductible...
- danharaj 7y agoThat's obviously not the same thing and I'm pretty sure you understand that.
- sabertoothed 7y ago> No, they don't. Yes, they do. Because it is defined in relative terms -- as the top 10% by (net) income. EDIT: Why do I get downvoted for a non-emotional, purely factual comment that provides additional information?
- lazyjones 7y ago> defined in relative terms -- as the top 10% by (net) income. A ridiculously stupid definition only some economists can come up with. A family with a huge mansion and its own multi-billion trust (living expenses paid by the trust) is not upper class, a graduate who owns nothing but debt and has just landed a well-paid job is, according to this definition.
- FabHK 7y agoNot quite. The study includes a rent imputation on owned property in income, and I saw no indication that Kapitalerträge (interest, dividends, capital gains) are excluded from the income. Furthermore, university in Germany is basically free and there is government support for poor students (BAföG) [1], so graduate debt is not that much of an issue. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundesausbildungsförderungsgesetz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundesausbildungsförderungsges...
- lazyjones 7y ago> I saw no indication that Kapitalerträge (interest, dividends, capital gains) are excluded from the income. A trust (Stiftung) owns itself. Its capital gains are not the beneficiaries' capital gains. It may also own the mansion in my example, so good luck taking imputed rents into account. > Furthermore, university in Germany is basically free and there is government support for poor students (BAföG) [1], so graduate debt is not that much of an issue. This doesn't change the point that someone who just started a well-paying job and owns nothing but debt is considered "upper class" by this so-called study.
- FabHK 7y ago
- fanzhang 7y agoIs this a critique of the article's definition of upper class (which they define as top 10%tile, and you define as non-working class). Or are you saying even given their calculation, their result is wrong?
- mattnewton 7y agoThe definition I have always used is credited here[0] as “Brooksmith’s Law of Class Distinction”, but I don’t know if this is where I heard it first. “Name on building: upper class. Name on desk: middle class. Name on shirt: working class” It’s not perfect, but the idea is that class as most people conceptualize it is determined by workplace and lifestyle affordances and isn’t a neat percentile cutoff but flexes and wanes in size. [0] https://www.just-one-liners.com/name-on-building-upper-class-name-on-desk-middle-class-name-on-shirt-working-class/ https://www.just-one-liners.com/name-on-building-upper-class...
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> It’s not perfect But it captures the essence of the upper-middle split. The upper class earns income from assets. The middle and lower classes from employment. This isn’t an economic conversation, but a political one. The upper classes are economically sovereign. The middle and lower classes are beholden to their employers, at least during the savings stage of their careers. Put another way, a child born to an upper-middle class family gets a leg up in educational opportunities and connections. A child born to an upper-class family may never have to work at all. Their principal challenge is retaining familial relationships. Referring to the upper middle class as “upper class” papers over the exorbitant privilege the latter retains.
- lmkg 7y agoThere's an essay on social class breakdowns in the US, which used the term "Working Rich" to describe people like doctors, lawyers, engineers. I thought that was a much more useful term than "middle" vs "upper" vs "upper-middle." Many such people are in the top 10% (depending on educational debt), but the label succinctly describes their relationship with money beyond simply deciding an arbitrary dollar amount.
- dogma1138 7y agoThe Great British Class Survey has a very good definition of various classes imo: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_British_Class_Survey https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_British_Class_Survey
- draugadrotten 7y agoDefining wealth in Germany, where even millionaires claim to be middle class ... Sociologist Wolfgang Lauterbach says: “All in all, the German upper classes are characterized by relatively old money.” https://www.handelsblatt.com/today/finance/who-is-rich-defining-wealth-in-germany-where-even-millionaires-claim-to-be-middle-class-/23710684.html?ticket=ST-7879695-sd5LjvyvwIAhZl1XiWXc-ap2 https://www.handelsblatt.com/today/finance/who-is-rich-defin...
- arethuza 7y agoThat's the "traditional" class view here in the UK where pretty much everyone is middle class these days (real aristocratic members of the upper class being rather rare and hardly anyone claims to be working class) - even Eton educated David Cameron claimed to be middle class: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-25744526 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-25744526
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- FabHK 7y agoThe study defines upper class as the top 10% of net income (after tax and mandatory insurances, after transfers such as pension and child benefits, and including a rent imputation for home owners). The study [1] does not explicitly mention capital income (capital gains, interest, dividends), but I have no reason to believe that they were excluded (insofar as they are also liable to taxation at 25%). [1] https://www.iwkoeln.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Studien/Kurzberichte/PDF/2019/IW-Kurzbericht_2019_Einkommensverteilung.pdf https://www.iwkoeln.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Studien/Kurzber...
- marvin 7y agoDepending on the tax system, a wealthy person may have a lot of leeway in choosing the amount of investment income they’ll realize for tax purposes. So someone with $10 million in stock market investments may choose to withdraw none, or only a small part of the returns generated, placing them in the low income category.
- matteuan 7y agoAn example, near Frankfurt outside the centre the property price is around 5000€ per m^2. 100m^2 for a couple is considered quite confortable, costing around €400k. This means a 25 years mortgage at 1,5% interest rate (atm it could get even better) -> 1600€ monthly repayment, definitely affordable with 5160€. Anyway, I'm not sure property price is a very good metric for this. Renting in Germany is still relatively cheaper than buying.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Udo 7y agoOf note is that "upper class" in this context is questionably defined as being in the top 10 percent of earners. I think this is misleading because I don't see someone making 3.5k as a single or 5.1k as a couple necessarily enjoying an upper class lifestyle. It's enough for a mortgage in a middle-class neighborhood and maybe a lease on one nice car (or two middle-tier cars). I have no idea what percent of the population is actually upper class, but they usually outright own multiple houses and luxury cars, and most importantly, a significant stack of wealth that is not necessarily bound in everyday living.
- esotericn 7y agoAs was discussed on a previous post, the top 10% by wealth is a far more interesting definition. If you have a 40-hour earned income job you are almost certainly not upper class.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoStatistically 90-th percentile is more interesting. Practically calling 90-th percentile the "upper class" is whitewashing the extreme difference between the lifestyle historically associated with the upper class and the middle class.
- esotericn 7y agoAgreed. It strikes me that people like to deny the fact that the upper class is actually a very small group indeed. It's not about just having a slightly bigger house or car or whatever, the entire lifestyle is fundamentally different.
- zaarn 7y agoThe 5.1k is after taxes and insurances, equates to about 100k per year in US terms.
- otabdeveloper4 7y agoClass isn't about wealth or consumption. "Upper class" means those who are rentiers, as opposed to those who have to sell their labor or body to others. Some CEO's are quite rich but still not "upper class", because at the end of the day they're still employers who sell their time to the highest bidder.
- lqet 7y agoPlease note that in Germany and many other European countries, the net income is usually after taxes and mandatory insurances like health insurance, pension insurance, unemployment insurance or long term care insurance. For a married couple without children, 5160 EUR net income per month then equates an income of over 100,000 EUR per year.
- Insanity 7y agoyeah, this number seems high. It might not look high to the overseas visitors to HN, but in Europe that's well paid!
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> in Europe that's well paid Well paid but not upper class. Give Germany has a bona fide upper class, this is a meaningful point to snuffle about. The couple with €5,160/mo. in net income is still, in all likelihood, beholden to their employer.
- FabHK 7y agoThe study defines upper class as top 10% of net income.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> The study defines upper class as top 10% of net income And the comments in this thread are disagreeing with that terminology. (The term of art has been “high earners” when I’ve seen income statistics in America.)
- FabHK 7y agoThe study itself actually distinguishes upper class (Oberschicht) from the top income decile (which is what the research is about). At any rate, that's really a semantic issue and should not distract from the substance.
- turbinerneiter 7y agoGiven that you spend the recommended one third of your net income (€5160) on housing, this means that in 45 years (~roughly a worklife) you can spend €919.512 on a house/flat (ignoring renovations, assuming 0 interest financing). In Munich, this is what a flat like that can look like: https://www.immobilienscout24.de/Suche/S-T/Wohnung-Kauf/Bayern/Muenchen/-/-/-/EURO--919512,00?enteredFrom=result_list#/ https://www.immobilienscout24.de/Suche/S-T/Wohnung-Kauf/Baye... Also, this is _net_ income. In Germany that means healthcare is covered and you don't have to pay off large student debt. To reach this net income, both partners have to make about 54.000 a year pre-tax. Most important point: the data is based on surveys, which means the super-rich don't really show up.
- wil421 7y agoIs that apartment considered nice and in a good area? It looks a little dated but certainly not bad. Not sure about the price compared to hr states. Here’s a comparable listing from Atlanta in a nice urban area. Atlanta is a lot bigger than Munich. https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/867-Peachtree-St-NE-UNIT-203-Atlanta-GA-30308/2086809212_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/867-Peachtree-St-NE-UNIT-...
- turbinerneiter 7y agoIf your are talking about the first one in the list - that is a very good location in Germanys most expensive city. Your link is a new building, so it immediately looks quite a bit fancier. The Munich place would probably get a new kitchen by whomever spends 800k on it. I think you have to click through a couple of places to get a better feeling. It's also insanely different between countryside and cities. Back home where my parents live, you could build a really, really nice house for that money. That's probably triple of what my friends back there spend on their homes, and those are really nice already.
- lazyjones 7y ago> net income (€5160) on housing, this means that in 45 years (~roughly a worklife) Because everybody starts their worklife with a huge salary? I don't see the point of this calculation. > Most important point: the data is based on surveys, which means the super-rich don't really show up. The rich and super-rich don't show up whenever only income is considered. Any class definition based on income and not wealth is pointless.
- sjbase 7y agoIs it really worth our time to be debating the semantics and connotation of the word "upper"? That's essentially what this post is.
- FabHK 7y agoExactly. The substantive contribution is to peg a number to the top income decile. It doesn't matter what you call it (and the study itself is careful about that, distinguishing Oberschicht from top income decile).
- dgellow 7y agoI submitted the article because I found the provided data interesting, I didn’t expect the discussion to focus on the definition of “upper class”... I just translated the original title, that was maybe a mistake
- rexgallorum2 7y agoRead it. They're using the wrong expression. 'Oberschicht' might be accurate in some statistical way, but it really means 'upper middle class' in this case. The measure is flawed though because it is based on monthly (presumably earned) income without taking into account net worth. Someone could own millions in property or other investments in Germany and have a relatively low net income, yet have the option of cashing out for a vast amount of money.
- k__ 7y agoSounds about right to me. Sure, you won't get a house in Starnberg for that, but they don't say you're rich with that money, just upper class. The middle class isn't as rich as most people here think.
- WengerPen 7y agoMost people don't realize how well-off they are since in most cases, their income move at a similar pace to their expenses. A person making $500k may feel poor and complain to their peers simply on the basis that they are living in an area that is more expensive, eating an assortment of foods at a higher premium, buying a car 15x the average used car, etc.
- RonaldSchleifer 7y agoI guess there must be a lot of German speakers here, but for those who are not German speakers, it may be worth clarifying a couple things. 1) the €5,160/month (€69,120 per year and only €2,580 each) which is all net ... so, after the massive amounts of taxes, fees, and costs that are taken out of people's paycheck every month for all the "free" things people in the USA gush over so much. Although it is difficult to reverse calculate the gross income amount, not only will anything above €56,000 be taxed at 42% (yes, 42% of the work and value you produce over €55,000 will be taken from you ... and that's just the start, but which would take too much to explain here), it is reasonable to say that a couple, i.e., two people taking home €69,000 (or €34,000 each) every year, will be making a gross of about €110,000 (or €55,000 each) before taxes. On top of those costs, you have to also realize that in Germany, as well as most European countries, you are paying what is effectively a ~20% sales tax that is hidden/obscured in the form of a Value Added Tax (VAT) on most purchases you make. What that amounts to is that not only are wages in Germany (Europe) roughly 70% (40-60%) of what they are in, e.g., the USA, but you are paying effective tax rates of about 30%-38% if you are making anything like a median income, and when you add up all the other labor costs and fees for the "free" healthcare that is taken out (the employer portion of which is a heavy contributing factor for the lower wages, btw.) then you are left with, as outlined about 55% of your salary, which then, when you spend it on anything, you are then, e.g., paying the ~20% VAT/sales tax, or, e.g., the 100% gasoline tax (yes, it's ~100% in most European countries and they are trying to drive it up). Maybe that will provide some perspective to people who not only laud the "free"ness of what Europeans have when they get back from freeloading off European tax payers who funded the "cheap" public transportation that is heavily, wildly, and corruptly subsidized by taxes; which American tourists experience as "cheap" because they get to keep more of their money and they are not paying the full cost Europeans pay with the significantly lower net income they have. To most europeans, public transportation is not cheap at all (hence all the bike riding), let alone even convenient, but to an American who gets to keep thousands of dollars more of his income, it's "cheap", because it's an illusion that is rather fraudulent actually. This all will, without doubt be an increasingly challenging reality Europe (that is the ruling class) will have to face and will do whatever it can to suppress. As Merkel has already stated and has essentially been the de facto governing policy as if it were the bedrock of the German constitution "read my lips, no taxes will be lowered"; it will invariably collide with the reality of the consequences of importing masses of people from abroad in order to sop up and absorb the excesses of the Hosing "Bubble", aka, Fraud, which was just shoved into "bad bank" closets and brushed under "toxic asset" rugs where they are all still festering and rotting out the whole world's economies. This will all come to another greater head possibly, as the ruse, the facade of "social democracy" starts cracking and crumbling when, e.g., people really start getting upset that, e.g., their own citizens, many of which who are now pensioners, who rebuilt the country after the war, are receiving less pension than foreign nationals who violated laws and social compacts at the behest of the ruling classes as they are set up in free housing and provided free money that belonged to citizens and was taken from them against their will through taxes. The reality of the matter is that we are facing a threshold of a new kind of serfdom/slavery, one not of physical restraint or restriction or even total physical control, but one of shackles and slavery of taxes, a business model of slavery more like that which slavery is named after, one, once the whole world has been subjugated and brought under the thumb of the ruling class, will have no escape from even if you were so inclined to flee and leave everything behind you and your ancestors contributed to creating.
- em500 7y agoSelf-referencing my post in another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20695115 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20695115 Summary: - €5160/month is the German 90-percentile monthly net household income - The US 90-percentile monthly household net is probably around $9k - $10k - Major contributors to the differences in the gross are in my guesstimate (1) overvalued USD, (2) more hours worked in the US - differences in the net are clearly mostly due to different taxation/collective spending
- ctw 7y agoI'm reading a book called Capital in the Twenty-First Century right now, which is all about this stuff. I'm only about halfway through right now, but here are some points from the book I find interesting (all of them iirc since I don't have access to the book right now): * the author chooses not to use the terms lower, middle, and upper class because doing so just leads to arguments about where to draw the lines. Interesting that so many comments on this thread are just people arguing about what "upper class" means because it's a personal term. He instead splits the distributions of income into three parts, the bottom 50%, the 40% above that, and the top 10% and simply refers to them by centile and decile. The "top decile" has an unambiguous meaning, whereas "upper class" could mean anything. * there are three distributions: income from labour, income from capital, and combined total income. The people at the top of one distribution aren't necessarily the ones at the top of the other. The book analyzes inequality across different countries across the past two hundred years or so, super interesting stuff * only when you get into the top 0.1% are you earning more income from capital than income from labour * inequality of income from labour is far lower than inequality of income from capital and always has been in every society in every period * inequality from income from labour is _easier_ to morally justify than inequality from capital, but still not necessarily just in any absolute sense * the bottom 50% owns only about 5% of the total capital
- amai 7y agoThe real problem is that in East Germany with more than €2839/month you belong to the upper class. In West Germany you need €3431/month showing that people from East Germany on average only have 80% of the income in the West even 30 years after reunification.