3 ms·
> Since then, the entire eastern half of the country has been brought into the fold of Western liberal capitalism—but not entirely successfully. Unemployment is
by ekianjo 7y ago
> Since then, the entire eastern half of the country has been brought into the fold of Western liberal capitalism—but not entirely successfully. Unemployment is still higher in the east, and brain drain to the west remains common.
Not sure how to understand this. I have traveled to the DDR and to East Germany after the reunification many times, and by far and large life is much better than it ever was. People can actually buy cars instead of Trabants. Of course an economic gap has long lasting consequences (the long tail of economic policies) but what you should point out is how much better it is now than it was during the DDR era.
- Kaiyou 7y agoDepends how you measure. Some people like to think things were better when they had money, but there was nothing to buy, instead of the current state of affairs, where they have things to buy, but no money. Add to that that lots of things not measured in money were better, like education, social cohesion etc. and you get lots of people looking back with fond memories conveniently forgetting all the bad things.
- dgellow 7y agoSuccessful industries and top universities are in majority in the Western side of the country, thus people looking for higher salaries or more job opportunities leave the Eastern side. Over time that results in important disparities. I don’t believe that the article is saying that the situation was better during DDR time.
- ekianjo 7y agoMy point is simply that this kind of adjustment is likely to take a century or even more. Look at the long lasting impact of economic disparities in the US between the South and the North as another example. Also, we would need to check in the economic History of Germany if the Eastern Lander of Germany were not always poorer compared to the Western Lander. The large economic output of the Rhur should already have tipped the economic scale way before the DDR.
- freeflight 7y agoThere's also the fact that the Berlin split forced a whole lot of rather successful German companies to relocate from East to somewhere else in the West. Siemens was originally started and HQ'ed in Berlin, until the wall split happened, making them relocate to the south. Afaik this is the case for a couple of other rather successfull Western German companies.
- freeflight 7y ago> I don’t believe that the article is saying that the situation was better during DDR time. It was actually way better during DDR time, a whole lot of stuff was manufactured there was then sold in the West trough catalog order. Didn't happen out of anywhere that even companies like IKEA had stuff manufactured there [0], back then the DDR was a bit what China is nowadays to the Western world. Sadly a lot of those industries were simply sold off and liquidated, sending millions of people into unemployment, by the Treuhandanstalt [1]. With nobody really investing much to replace these lost jobs, only plenty of money for infrastructure trough the Soli. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2012/nov/16/ikea-regrets-forced-labour-germany https://www.theguardian.com/business/2012/nov/16/ikea-regret... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treuhandanstalt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treuhandanstalt
- watwut 7y agoThe quote continues: > It is in these eastern Länder where the AfD has gained the most ground. Fear-mongering arguments against immigration and an Islamic takeover continue to attract scores of German citizens whose future economic prospects are less than rosy. Not everyone is happy. You can have some people unhappy while others are being better off.
- mxfh 7y agoThe populist right AfD is doing also very well among gainers after the reunification. This is about perceived current inequality, not about a much needed compensation of double de-industrialization and de-capitalization of the east (post WWII and Post 1990-Treuhand). In saxony the local candidates are well off business men with a tendency to war lord like attiude to local power grabs and corruption. AfD is not thematizing any of this but is currently on a well funded campaign run to retcon and ursurp the civil movement of 89/90 as a nationalist movement and branding itself of it's heir. All this while having no problems of having high ranking Stasi-Officers in the party itself. East Germany's larger cities with significant university clusters (Leipzig, Dresden, Halle, Rostock, Potsdam, Jena-Weimar-Erfurt) are doing well, the rest is aging away on well paved streets. That populist reigns there is no suprise if educated post reunifcation youth works in those cities or elsewhere and might return some day. But wouldn't write off the east yet, since a populist right with maximum 1/3 support of electorate is not too uncommon and it's all about how conservative CDU positions itself in relation to that.
- freeflight 7y agoOstalgie [0] is a very real thing, particularly for older generations who actually lived and worked in the GDR, without ever conflicting with the government. Because not everything East was bad, and not everything in the West was perfect either. There was actually quite a bit of economic symbiosis [1] going on between both sides back then. That's why for many, the GDR also meant stability and progress. I can still remember my grandmother living in a house with wood ovens for heating, no running warm water, and a literal drop toilet on the second floor where you had to manually rinse with a big water pitcher. She then got moved to an apartment inside a newly built Plattenbau [2], offering quite some comforts that were previously reserved to only very few households. After the wall fell, she moved out to another flat, but by now is back to living in one of those Plattenbau apartments. Guess how negative her opinions on the GDR time are? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostalgie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ostalgie [1] https://www.dw.com/de/ddr-als-billiglohnland-f%C3%BCr-den-westen/a-15931955 https://www.dw.com/de/ddr-als-billiglohnland-f%C3%BCr-den-we... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plattenbau https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plattenbau