6 ms·
Anyone have insight on whether this is Microsoft gunning at mobile platforms, or loosing faith in the dominance of x86?
by sliverstorm 16y ago
Anyone have insight on whether this is Microsoft gunning at mobile platforms, or loosing faith in the dominance of x86?
- mycroftiv 16y agoYou pose the question as if those two things were contradictory, but aren't they really synonymous? I think everyone expects that the majority of computers sold in the next few years will be sold in the form of smartphones and tablets, and ARM dominates those markets.
- rbanffy 16y agoYou can smell their fear. As long as I can buy an ARM-based netbook subsidized by crapware/adware on Windows 8 and replace the thing with a decent OS, I'll be happy. Sadly, I won't be able to brag about using a Windows-proof computer anymore... Now, seriously, Windows failed once on RISC platforms because software vendors were not interested in supporting them. Can an ARM-based Windows desktop function when the only software it runs is Windows? And, perhaps, Office? Would a Windows user live without 3rd-party software? Would all 3rd-parties rush to support Windows on ARM? I doubt it. And, of course, it reminds me of FUD maneuvers of the past, like Windows for Pen Computing. It may well be designed to prevent people from seriously considering moving to Android (or classic Linux) on ARM-based platforms "because Windows 8 will support ARM and is just around the corner". Seen it before. And it worked, BTW.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 16y ago> Windows failed on RISC because when x86 proved too competitive I remember distinctly how much faster Alpha-based workstations were in comparison to its Pentium Pro cousins. Unfortunately, I couldn't run many programs I had to (Office, for instance, ran under emulation, at Pentium-like speeds). I could run SQL Server and pretty much that was it. And notepad. And Minesweeper. I can imagine a niche for high-density ARM-based servers running IIS, but, unless licensing is very cheap, I cannot imagine someone paying for Windows on four ARM blades when the same Windows on one x86 blade could do the same work. When licensing is a big part of the whole stack, the hardware evolves in weird, sometimes unpractical, ways. That happened before too. When the most common Windows version (because it could run lots of popular software), was the 9x series, x86 processors were under specific evolutionary pressures and ended up with deep pipelines and insanely high clocks to remain acceptably fast until past 2000 (and entered an evolutionary dead-end). At the same time, RISC-based boxes that ran Unix routinely had more than one processor since the low 90's. I always thought it interesting that by the time AMD64 was announced, I was retiring our 5-year-old 64-bit mail server.
- kenjackson 16y agoBut there is the Cortex A-15 which puts ARM in the Intel perf ballgame. Not surprisingly, I've heard grumblings for nearly the past decade of an ARM version of Windows in various states of stability. It will be interesting to see how far along this is. The issue with x86 and clocks had little do with Windows, and more with the Blue Crystal effect (MHz sell CPUs not perf). There's a great insider book about this called "The Pentium Chronicles" by the chief architect of the P6.
- rbanffy 16y agoAnd yet, the most popular Windows version couldn't do anything with the dual and quad-processor boxes being sold. Clock number marketing had its share, but the lack of an OS that could run most games or support a lot of the hardware already out (I had a couple gizmos that didn't work under NT) certainly didn't help the evolution of multi-processor x86s. As late as XP-time, most of my friends who were serious about gaming dual booted their boxes between 2000/XP for work and 98 for gaming. For them, a multi-processor workstation would be useless half the time. For most of 1999/2000, I worked on an IBM PC Server 320 with two Pentium 200 processors and found it was wonderfully "smoother" than the 400MHz P2 (or 3, can't remember that) users who didn't run NT had. I cannot picture myself being happy on a single threaded machine anymore.
- masklinn 16y ago> But there is the Cortex A-15 which puts ARM in the Intel perf ballgame Where "Intel perf ballgame" might mean "within an order of magnitude of Intel's currently shipping ULC chips". A9-based hardware has barely started shipping (as in, hours ago), by the time A15s ship Ivy Bridge will be out. If not Haswell.
- sliverstorm 16y agoCan an ARM-based Windows desktop function when the only software it runs is Windows? They've done a half-decent enough job with Windows 7 to get people to move from XP, even when app support is patchy. Offer some compatibility, so that people don't rule out switching, but not enough compatibility to allow the software makers to remain complacent... That's the trick. They have a ton of resources, and some half-decent developers, maybe they'll introduce an x86 compatibility layer.
- rbanffy 16y ago> introduce an x86 compatibility layer. On ARM?! ARM is not so fast. I can imagine ARM reaching Atom on single-thread performance, but nothing near Sandy Bridge. That said, DEC had it for the Alpha, but only because the Alpha made the Pentium look like a toy. And it was not fun to run Pentium software at Pentium speeds on what was supposedly a very fast computer.
- gpjt 16y agoNow, seriously, Windows failed once on RISC platforms because software vendors were not interested in supporting them. Can an ARM-based Windows desktop function when the only software it runs is Windows? I guess a lot depends on how much developers embrace .NET; .NET apps are compiled to CLR bytecode which presumably could run on ARM devices just as easily as on Intel.
- rbanffy 16y ago> CLR bytecode which presumably could run on ARM devices just as easily as on Intel. It's doubtful if performance would not degrade so much as to make desktop software made to run on the x86 .NET runtime unacceptably slow on ARM.
- teyc 16y agoThe most CPU demanding work on a mobile phone is actually the user interface, and on WP7 this is offloaded to hardware. I see no reason why ARM tablets running Windows would be necessarily slower.
- ot 16y agoWindows phone 7 is based on .NET, so they already have an ARM backend for the runtime.
- rbanffy 16y ago
- harshpotatoes 16y agoBe fair now, these hypothetical arm devices can't both be filled with bloat/crapware and not be supported by 3rd party app developers.
- rbanffy 16y agoGood point. So, they probably won't have subsidies. That'll make the Linux versions cheaper.
- celoyd 16y agoIf they expect mobile platforms keep growing and to keep not using x86, they can expect both of those by the same token.
- yason 16y agoThey've probably seen that: - ARM chiops are soon at desktop speeds; further, there are dual-core and quad-core ARM chips in the near future - Laptops have been fast enough for years that customers can trade off some speed in favor of much longer battery life - They see synergetic advances in gluing together mainline Windows and Windows Phone with ARM platforms: ARM is certainly going to be a player, they're certain that ARM based minilaptops, netbooks, and tablets, when they become closer to mainstream, are going to eat away market share from Windows/x86
- masklinn 16y ago> ARM chiops are soon at desktop speeds Frequencies, not speeds.
- regularfry 16y agoThat depends what you mean by "speeds." I used an ARM3-based desktop machine for a while 15 years ago. Personally I think it's a meaningless comparison, but there you go.
- masklinn 16y ago> That depends what you mean by "speeds." Same as everybody else, the ratio between an amount of stuff S and the time T it takes to execute a set of operations P on it > I used an ARM3-based desktop machine for a while 15 years ago. So? > Personally I think it's a meaningless comparison, but there you go. It's not so much meaningless as irrelevant. I interpreted "ARM chiops are soon at desktop speeds" to mean "ARM speeds are soon at [processing] speeds corresponding to x86 desktop machines at equivalent prices" which definitely isn't the case, not by a long shot. Soon at desktop frequencies yes (the A15 is advertised at up to 2.5GHz while retail desktop CPUs have been stuck under the 4GHz barrier for more than 5 years), performance per watt definitely (ARM has blown x86 away forever there) but actual, raw computational speed not really.
- regularfry 16y ago