9 ms·
A Novel Concept: Silent Book Clubs Offer Introverts a Space to Socialize
- carvink 7y agoThere are silent writing meetups too. https://shutupwrite.com/ https://shutupwrite.com/
- gravelc 7y agoThat's a fantastic idea. Just to escape from kids/work and have a good read sounds kind of magical. For some reason it seems more appealing than just going to a park or library and doing it. The socialising would be kind of reliant on reading roughly the same genre I suspect - don't think a romance and sci-fi would lead to a lot of conversation starters, but you never know.
- layoutIfNeeded 7y agoAh, the Diogenes Club!
- lwhalen 7y ago"If only hunger could be satisfied by such vigorous rubbing!"
- nstart 7y agoI for one, appreciate the reference. Thank you for the laugh :)
- GeorgeRichard 7y agoFirst thought: The club is described by Sherlock Holmes in the story "The Adventure of the Greek Interpreter" as follows: There are many men in London, you know, who, some from shyness, some from misanthropy, have no wish for the company of their fellows. Yet they are not averse to comfortable chairs and the latest periodicals. It is for the convenience of these that the Diogenes Club was started, and it now contains the most unsociable and unclubbable men in town. No member is permitted to take the least notice of any other one. Save in the Stranger's Room, no talking is, under any circumstances, allowed, and three offences, if brought to the notice of the committee, render the talker liable to expulsion. My brother was one of the founders, and I have myself found it a very soothing atmosphere. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diogenes_Club https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diogenes_Club) Second thought prompted by lwhalen: According to the Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers by the third-century AD biographer Diogenes Laërtius, Diogenes of Sinope, the fourth-century BC Cynic philosopher, often masturbated in public, which was considered scandalous.[7][8][9] When people confronted him over this, he would say, "If only it were as easy to banish hunger by rubbing my belly."[7][8][9] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_masturbation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_masturbation)
- ddtaylor 7y agoPeople often equate introvert to mean "doesn't prefer to be around people" and extroverts to mean "loves to be around people", but that's essentially a myth. The best layman explanation I have heard is that extroverts are "recharged" by being around others whereas introverts recharge by being alone. For example, I really like being around people, but the idea of not having time to myself to recharge can be exhausting.
- iraldir 7y agoyep, that's correct. Me and my fiancée are both text-books introverts, but I'm not shy at all, have no fear of public speaking etc. while she is the opposite. But for both of us, even having a drink after work with people is super exhausting and we just want to go home and relax, while an extrovert would be depressed staying alone and needs to recharge by having fun with people.
- limteary 7y agoI must be the opposite. After and during socializing I often feel manic but I terribly shy initially and spend all my time alone. Drat.
- tonyarkles 7y agoSome good news though! Shyness, social anxiety, etc, can be overcome with effort, if desired. I've definitely witnessed a number of people "coming out of their shell" so to speak over the years.
- non-entity 7y agoSame here. I was invited to a party late last year and it was the first time really getting out in a long time. It was enjoyable, but I didn't do much socializing till the end. Haven't had an opportunity to get out since tho
- nicoburns 7y ago> The best layman explanation I have heard is that extroverts are "recharged" by being around others whereas introverts recharge by being alone That's a good step 1. Step 2 is realising that introverts often do get energised by one-on-one or small group socialising, or socialising in a more meaningful way around a real shared interest. Step 3 is realising that the concept of introversion/extraversion generalises past social interaction to preferences for levels of external interaction / stimulation in general. So for example, some people may not be super-sociable, but may love lot's of external physical stimulation (music/lights/exercise, etc), others may love to be exposed external ideas (or alternatively have a preference to only be exposed to small amounts of these things). ^ This is the notion of introversion/extroversion captured by the MBTI / Jungian Type Theories, where Extraverted Feeling (Fe) roughly function corresponds to the popular notion of extraversion, but there are also Extraverted Sensing (Se), Extraverted Intuition (Ne) and Extraverted Thinking (Te) functions which present differently.
- nkozyra 7y agoI don't have much discernible social anxiety when it comes to going somewhere and meeting and talking to strangers. This idea would make me far more anxious than just talking to people.
- hos234 7y agoSimilar to HN in some ways. There is not much small talk happening here. And no obligation for anyone to talk about some preassigned subject.
- lonelappde 7y agoHN is nearly all small talk about the news. We aren't posting and critiquing each other's research papers. And we get a list of preassigning topics every day.
- mLuby 7y agoAs a way for people to talk about unimportant topics, small talk serves a few vital functions: 1. it allows politeness without deepening the relationship. 2. it can be a breadth-first search of mutually-stimulating topics for in-depth conversation (which may lead to a deeper relationship if desired). 3. it can avoid accidentally offending someone with controversial topics or opinions. 4. is quick to disengage from, unlike a story or debate, so is useful as a conversational holding pattern. HN doesn't really fit any of those. Sure, some comments will say "my kid does this", but I find they're rare on HN (and usually downvoted); in general, comments are adding new data or engaging in debate.
- quickthrower2 7y agoA hacking club could be set up around the same idea: 1 hour of coding in silence and no rules outside of that. Pizza and beer provided!
- charliepark 7y agoIf you're in one of the cities where it meets, the Homebrew Website Club is great for that. If you aren't, think about starting one yourself. They're great. https://indieweb.org/Homebrew_Website_Club https://indieweb.org/Homebrew_Website_Club
- lonelappde 7y agoHow is it social if it's silent? Do you use instant messaging?
- michaelt 7y agoIn the article, "Once the bell rings, silent reading time commences. After an hour, the bell rings again. [...] [Participants] chat about anything, before and after the designated reading time." So presumably the 1 hour of coding in silence would be followed by as much time as you liked for pizza and socialising.
- sunsetSamurai 7y agoIt seems like everybody is an introvert these days, or is it just me that thinks that?
- lgeorget 7y agoWell... Introverts are more likely to let you know they exist via a blog post than by telling you directly.
- interactivecode 7y agowell, in the last couple years people actually realize that not everyone is an extrovert. So introverts are more vocal because they now exist/ get recongized
- tonyarkles 7y agoHonestly, it seems to me more that, in some circles, it's just become more acceptable to talk about. Plus, over the last decade or so, there's been enough talk about it in popular media that it's become somewhat more normalized. It's cool for me. I'm not shy. I love standing in front of a room and teaching. I'll happy go do social things. And if I do too many in a row, I get completely exhausted. First comes an overwhelming urge to sleep, followed by a strong desire to stay home with my dogs and a book and just read in silence. 15 years ago, living in University dorms, it was the same thing, but instead of having a framework to describe it, I had to make excuses to have alone time. Sunday was perfect for that... Sometimes there was a real hangover, and sometimes there wasn't, but it was always a good reason to chill out solo.
- Baeocystin 7y agoI no longer feel the need to apologize for it. I have no social anxiety, and I genuinely enjoy meeting new people, or talking to small groups of friends. but I need my alone time, and that isn't up for debate- it's a genuine need. Took me longer than I'd like to admit to realize that. Whether this is the natural result of just getting older, or a sea change in general society as the less-social of us find ways to connect anyway, I am not sure. I do think it's a little of both.
- matfil 7y ago
- thomasfromcdnjs 7y agoAn unpopular opinion that I'm sure will garner negative reactions because everyone likes to self diagnose themselves, but I find the introvert/extrovert dichotomy quite weak. Most people who I meet who proclaim they are "introverted" have just not invested any time into building their social skills. Most people who I meet who proclaim they are "extroverted" are people who are not comfortable with being alone for whatever reasons. It is seemingly obvious to me that both social skills and being with one self are both equally important. Deciding which one you are by taking a shallow survey with surface level questions seems unintelligent. Choosing one to identify with seems irrationally limiting to who you could be.
- tonyarkles 7y agoYeah, that's one of the most painful parts of, for example, the r/Introvert subreddit. There's a mix of people who just need alone time to recharge (per the current popular description), and people who seem to have terrible social skills or absolutely crippling social anxiety. At least the community is sort of good at distinguishing between the two and sometimes encouraging people to find help.
- lonelappde 7y agoThis doesn't make sense. You've defines the terms in approximately the usual way noted that you have observed them, and then declared they don't exist. Yes, you can learn to change much of your behavior. That doesn't mean you don't have strong preferences. Would you say that someone who says they aren't athletic based on a shallow survey of behaviors and inclinations is unintelligent? Someone who answers a shallow survey on their sexual orientation is unintelligent?
- m-watson 7y agoI think that there is for sure an aspect of underdeveloped skills. That could come from lack of interest, background/culture/environment, or any other number of reasons sure. But I think a bigger aspect is how psychologists often phrase it (sure it is wishy washy) but where do you get your energy. Some people are going to be more comfortable with people around and others feel more relaxed alone. That can and most likely will change over any individuals life but it is important to recognize what environments to go to when you need a recharge. And yes, people love to self-diagnose and take surface level quizzes, but this also does seem to be a real phenomenon different personalities have and understanding your own and others personalities will improve everyone's social interactions. So I agree, we should all work on being with ourselves as well as how to interact with others. But we also need to know, when feeling stressed, if we should retreat to a quiet room or a crowed get together. And just a last point is that it seems like this silent book club is doing what you suggest, it is an introvert going to a place they feel more comfortable which will in time develop their social skills.
- willis936 7y agoThe use of the word “novel” in contexts like these is a pet peeve of mine. It seems to be used solely for making an idea sound good regardless of merit. Yes, there is value in signaling originality, but the tone feels self congratulatory. Perhaps this is just a product of my experiences in academia, where the use of the word “novel” seemed like a goal.
- scandinavegan 7y agoIn this case it's also a pun, because they're talking about a book club.
- brianmcc 7y agoExactly - novel meaning "new" is perfectly valid usage but it's the dual meaning that's the intention here, the "I am reading a novel" one. This got me wondering why books are called novels - apparently from the Italian "novella": https://penandthepad.com/history-novel-6305937.html https://penandthepad.com/history-novel-6305937.html
- bloak 7y agoI sympathise with your allergy to the word "novel". When I see that word in the title of a paper I tend to assume that the author is a desperate PhD student describing some method that is slightly different from the normal and obvious way of doing things and which works only slightly less well. The first sentence of the abstract SHALL contain the word "ubiquitous".
- VLM 7y agoI read it as sarcasm, in the sense that the organizers seem to be putting a lot of effort into pretending they're not merely appropriating college age "study in commons" lifestyle. So you take your psych 101 textbook to the commons and read mostly quietly for a half hour and then party all night with whoever else shows up to "study" and the only difference is you're older and not paying $50K/yr for the privilege to do so.
- bootsz 7y ago> I would say that I'm an introvert who's really good at pretending to be an extrovert for small amounts of time In other words: an introvert. There seems to be a widespread misconception that introversion means being "shy" and not talking to people, when in reality it is more about where you draw energy from. The result is tons of people self-identifying as "extroverted introverts"[1], presumably in an attempt to signal that they are not totally devoid of social skills, when in reality introversion has nothing to do with that. [1] When I was single I saw this surprisingly often in online dating profiles. Interestingly, for all the many people I've seen identify this way, I've never seen a single person self-identify as the opposite: an "introverted extrovert".
- nkrisc 7y agoIt's a very common misconception. One I even held myself until recently. The more I thought about it, I realized that while I am introverted, I do like being around people. I'm perfectly happy to be with and socialize with people - as long as I don't have to be the center of attention or life of the party. Interestingly it was a 3 month stint doing full-time remote work that made me realize this. Luckily when socializing with other introverts, they're generally OK with silence and gaps in the conversation, it's not awkward. And when socializing with extroverts they're happy to dominate the conversation and I'm happy to let them and just listen.
- cedex12 7y agoI don't see how being OK with silences and gaps matches this "introvert" trait mentioned in the parent. To my ears, this usual "introverts are not made uncomfortable by silences" refrain sounds condescending.
- brokenmachine 7y agoI'd call myself an introvert, but I definitely get a bit awkward with silences in conversation, except when I'm with good friends. When there's an extrovert dominating and thus no silence at all, I just get tired of listening.
- izzydata 7y agoI am skeptical that this really gets at the heart of what makes socializing as an introvert different than for an extrovert. Being in a social situation brings some level of anxiety to the table even if everyone is silent and that eventually becomes taxing enough to need to be alone for awhile. Maybe it would take longer to reach that point, but there is nothing wrong with the way interacting with people currently works for an introverted individual.
- odyssey7 7y agoHuh, I (and many others) kind of used to do this in undergrad. We’d get a study room, read things from our different classes to ourselves, and schedule breaks every 20 or so minutes to talk, and repeat. It was very effective and enjoyable studying.
- tw1010 7y agoI can't for the life of me figure out how to read around other people (even in silence). Is there something wrong with me? I bet I could learn but I'm not sure how.
- tictoc 7y agoDesensitization
- logfromblammo 7y agoYou just have to try to read around other people, until you can. You can't literally shut off your sensory inputs, but you can learn to hear without listening, and see without observing. Eventually, you may reach the point where you won't realize that someone is trying to get your attention until they actually poke you with a sharp stick. Or maybe just tap your shoulder.
- WhompingWindows 7y agoForget the introvert/extrovert trap that so many comments/articles fall into. I don't join book clubs precisely because I don't want to commit to reading that material on that schedule. The idea of simply meeting up with friends for an hour to silently read whatever we feel, hey, I like that. I can read LotR or HP again, someone else can read sci-fi or mysteries, and we can chat about that or whatever else. It's a great alternative to reading one and only one book.
- ccmonnett 7y agoIndeed! I have had similar... hesitation? when it comes to getting in a book club. I love reading, I have several friends that love reading, but I couldn't possibly imagine regularly reading something that we all agree upon in order to talk about on a regular basis. We'd all rather read our own stuff. It's not even about not wanting to read something - I just want to feel engaged with what I'm reading and my friends seem to agree. It's how you can let a book sit on a shelf for 6 months then pick it up and read it in 3 days - sometimes it just 'grabs' you.
- noisy_boy 7y agoI remember my college library being sort of a refuge and doorway to the world of knowledge without any attached expectation of socialization. I spent my time reading on everything that I found interesting/new (excluding the subjects I was studying for getting my degree). This knowledge didn't directly add to my grades (I think) but really opened my mind to the (pre-internet) world and its past, present and possible future, more so since I never had exposure to this amount of concentrated source of knowledge before. The difference between that and what we do on internet now is that these were books by authors who spend a good chunk of their lives being authorities on the topics instead of someone dumping their musings on the internet (admittedly not all of which is substandard). I think this kind of focused consumption (because you have to be physically there) of high quality content in an "aimless" manner is underrated and happening less.
- anoplus 7y agoI have a vague idea that maybe some people need "framework" for socializing. Making it clearer task like framework for developing applications. I still don't know how that "framework" should look like. I am a person who can't "just call and talk to him/her aimlessly" or "just ask friends to go out" as some relatives recommended me to do. I can spend hours trying to crack the task of "socializing" as if it is some hard puzzle.
- cafard 7y ago"Classic rock is blaring from the speakers, but at this table, silence rings out." Just what I want: classic rock while I'm trying to read something of moderate complexity. If I want to be around people all reading their own books in silence, I can catch the Metrobus. (Actually, most days I catch the Metrobus willy-nilly; what with cell phones, the reading isn't as silent as it could be, but the bus gets me to and from work.)
- hellbanner 7y ago> The idea began with two friends reading together at a bar in San Francisco, annoyed by the assigned reading of a demanding book club. Because everything was invented in San Francisco in the last 20 years.
- fencepost 7y agoI call this "sociable vs social." I'm regularly out and doing things in public locations where I may end up interacting with people beyond basic greetings/nods/"tall Pike," but that doesn't mean I'm there to socialize so much as to get some undemanding human contact.
- jvagner 7y agoReminded of the conversation a couple of days ago about "third places" that are gone... indie coffee shops were great for this.