3 ms·
No need to wait until they are decommissioned with vehicle to grid. Charge at night at cheap rates, use during peak demand.
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
No need to wait until they are decommissioned with vehicle to grid. Charge at night at cheap rates, use during peak demand.
- michaelt 7y agoYou know how cell phone batteries wear out after a few years, because many li-ion batteries will lose 20% of their capacity after ~500† charge-discharge cycles - and users often have to throw away their phone in response? Vehicle-to-grid would have to pay me a lot if it means I have to scrap my EV after 5 years instead of 10. And if the power network is going to use half of my EV's battery's cycle-life and pay half my battery's cost, why wouldn't they just buy their own battery? And if they're only going to activate V2G for a few hours a year, it'll have to pay high hourly rate to cover the cost of the extra car components. On the other hand, just limiting charge rates in times of high demand doesn't degrade cars' batteries at all. Makes much more sense IMHO. †Yes, it depends on the battery model, the temperature, the current - but we all know from phones that battery degradation is a real thing.
- NullPrefix 7y ago>And if the power network is going to use half of my EV's battery's cycle-life and pay half my battery's cost, why wouldn't they just buy their own battery? Same reason why they wouldn't just buy their own solar panels.
- zaroth 7y agoOf course! The idea would be you would provide your battery service at a price that made sense to you! At $9/kWh (which is a truly absurd rate) the battery pays for itself in roughly 12 cycles. At a less insane but still hefty $1/kWh margin, it would pay for itself in roughly 100 cycles. Of course you wouldn’t scrap your whole EV, you would buy a new battery for your EV with the profits, and ideally end up with both excess income, and a longer overall vehicle lifespan, with longer effective ranges over time. I’m sure someone has done all the math on this and knows exactly how good and cheap the EV battery has to be in order for this to be worth doing, and it seems like we’re nearly there. Plus, with the same hardware plus a safety switch in the house, the EV becomes your house battery backup as well.
- fencepost 7y agoCell phone batteries are actually a terrible example here though, because they're not designed for longevity. Pretty sure most of the deterioration happens at the extremes, so if being designed for longevity they'd probably only have half the available capacity because it'd be capped at both the top and bottom of the range so they never went above 80-85% and never below 35-40%.
- Buraksr 7y agoYou are very correct in your points, but I would like to highlight that we push our phone and laptop batteries very hard. They are normally pushed to full charge and discharge and not properly cooled (In the case of phones they are sometimes even more of a heatsink for the cpu) and this causes them to die faster [0 for relation of use to decay] [1 for impact of thermals]. Discharging and charging your cars battery will cause wear, but I don't think It would be so fair to compare it to the degradation you see in other devices. Tesla has seen some success in getting more from its batteries by managing thermals [2] as well as limiting max and minimum charges to more healthy levels [3, we saw tesla give more capacity to units implying there is a reserve] [4, we know these cars will still drive even after there range is 'exhausted' for some time] Considering the expense of batteries for cars maybe I wouldn't do it, but It is likely not so bad if you have a car with good power and thermal management -0, https://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/capacity_loss https://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/capacity_loss -1,https://cleantechnica.com/2018/12/05/60-kwh-nissan-leaf-still-no-liquid-cooled-battery/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/12/05/60-kwh-nissan-leaf-stil... -2,https://www.teslarati.com/watch-tesla-battery-thermal-management-action-supercharging/ https://www.teslarati.com/watch-tesla-battery-thermal-manage... -3,https://cleantechnica.com/2017/09/09/tesla-unlocks-extra-battery-capacity-owners-fleeing-hurricanes/ https://cleantechnica.com/2017/09/09/tesla-unlocks-extra-bat... -4, https://forums.tesla.com/forum/forums/reserve-power-when-state-charge-shows-0-miles https://forums.tesla.com/forum/forums/reserve-power-when-sta...