2 ms·
> We only had 3% capacity left in the system, yet out in the Permian Basin operators are flaring off excess gas. That has nothing to do with the problem (excep
by amluto 7y ago
> We only had 3% capacity left in the system, yet out in the Permian Basin operators are flaring off excess gas.
That has nothing to do with the problem (except extremely indirectly via global warming). There isn’t a shortage of fuels — there’s a shortage of generation capacity. No amount of extra natural gas would make the slightest difference.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThere isn’t a shortage of fuels — there’s a shortage of generation capacity. Or an excess of demand, there are plenty of ways to build houses that lower the need for air conditioning.
- dillonmckay 7y agoOr retrofit existing houses with supplemental geothermal cooling.
- adrianN 7y agoOr add some insulation.
- benj111 7y ago"except extremely indirectly" Not really that indirectly, if there weren't scorching temperatures there wouldn't be a need for extra air con. I'm aware though we can't definitively attribute this heat wave to global warming.
- mikeash 7y agoMore fuel would mean lower prices would mean more generators built to take advantage of that.
- amluto 7y agoAt the price of peak electricity on a peak day, the cost of fuel is irrelevant. That $9k/MWh peak was about $300/therm. A therm of natural gas, retail, from PG&E is less than $2. The problem here is that the grid more or less guarantees that each customer can draw as much power as they want whenever they want, so there needs to be generation capacity to cover the maximum demand, but that means that, under normal conditions, a good fraction of the capacity is unused. A plant that only runs for a few hours a year needs to charge a lot for those few hours. In theory, demand response can help — the grid can pay certain customers to stop using power at times. Aluminum refineries are the classic example — an aluminum refinery can, in principle, be configured to turn off on demand without much loss other than the production at that time period. So an aluminum refinery that shuts off for eight hours a year generates nearly as much revenue as a refinery that operates continuously, but those eight hours can help the grid during peak load. Actually making this work requires some fancy communication with the grid operator, and this is rather new.
- mikeash 7y agoThanks for providing concrete numbers! Looks like the effect would be too small to notice even if gas were free.