6 ms·
No, more people don't click, because they've taken the answer from your website and displayed it right in their search results. It's for this reason that's I'v
by reaperducer 7y ago
No, more people don't click, because they've taken the answer from your website and displayed it right in their search results.
It's for this reason that's I've stopped embedding micro data in the HTML I write.
Micro data only serves Google. Not my clients. Not my sites. Just Google.
Every month or so I get an e-mail from a Google bot warning me that my site's micro data is incomplete. Tough. If Google wants to use my content, then Google can pay me.
If Google wants to go back to being a search engine instead of a content thief and aggregator, then I'm on board.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- henryfjordan 7y agoI just got one of those emails for the first time about my personal site that's basically my resume. Apparently my text is small on mobile (it's not...) and some other crap I don't get why google thinks it's acceptable to critique my site without prompting. It honestly just feels rude. They want me to do a whole bunch of micro-optimizations on a site that already works fine because it doesn't fit their standard of "high quality". I think I've gotten exactly 0 clicks from Google search results ever and I don't really ever want any. If it were possible to get a human's attention at Google I'd start sending my own criticism their way but of course it doesn't work like that...
- grogenaut 7y agoYeah it's amazing how rapidly and rabidly they show up when the complaint is on one of their paid features like a Google cloud (GCE) post for them or a competitor, but nada on the other products. Well no it's actually not surprising.
- londons_explore 7y agoGoogle cloud employees are encouraged to go on social media to get a feel for issues users are having and to make the product better. The rest of Google has a policy of "Engineers will probably say the wrong thing if we let them talk in public"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jefftk 7y agoI was curious what it was complaining about, since https://henryfjordan.com https://henryfjordan.com looks great to me. I tried to run it through Google's "Mobile Friendly Test" but fetching failed [1] because your robots.txt has: User-agent: * Disallow: / This would explain why you've gotten zero clicks from Google (or I would guess anyone else's) search results! On the other hand, it's surprising that you would get a notification if you had crawling disabled. Did you set this robots.txt up recently? [1] https://search.google.com/test/mobile-friendly?id=97_WUiIxx-inLfwyqmbHuQ https://search.google.com/test/mobile-friendly?id=97_WUiIxx-... (Disclosure: I work at Google, commenting only for myself)
- SahAssar 7y agoGoogle seems to see robots.txt as "more what you call guidelines, than actual rules". Sites that block googlebot or all bots with robots.txt still turn up in google searches, just without a description, and are obviously still indexed.
- dorgo 7y ago>"more what you call guidelines, than actual rules" they can index without scraping. It is enough that other websites have links to you site. So the google bot follows the rules in robots.txt to the letter. "no-index" is the way to stay away from google.
- SahAssar 7y agoThey can't read my no-index if they obey my robots.txt. Do they break the robots.txt to be able to read my no-index or do they assume my "Disallow: /" means I'm fine with them indexing/linking? Without the noindex part of robots.txt (which google decided to ignore not so long ago) this is not solvable.
- jefftk 7y agorobots.txt is a tool to control crawling, not to specify how you would like your site to be displayed (or not) in search results. If you don't want search engines to include your site, set: <meta name="robots" content="noindex"> while to block just Google do: <meta name="googlebot" content="noindex"> See https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/93710 https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/93710 If Googlebot is not respecting robots.txt, and is crawling something it's been instructed not to crawl, let me know and I can file a bug? (Disclosure: I work for Google but not on Search, speaking only for myself)
- dingo_bat 7y agoYou should mark it spam, because that's what it is.
- kaolti 7y agoGoogle has grown into a cancerous middleman.
- LowLevelHacker 7y agoThe transition from search to content delivery was deliberate and not necessary. Google has every right to pivot in any direction but it's when spread too thin that missteps like this are bound to happen.
- michaelmior 7y ago> If Google wants to go back to being a search engine While I understand the problems with Google scraping content, as a user these snippets help me find what I'm searching for faster. If that's all you're optimizing for, Google is fantastic. There are certainly good arguments to be made for other models, but for search, stealing content helps. I'm not advocating stealing content, I'm just saying that it produces more useful results.
- DollarGuru 7y agoIf it undermines the websites producing the content Google is scraping by not sending through traffic then those sites may not continue to exist.
- londons_explore 7y agoThis is already happening. Very few new blogs and content websites are being set up. All content is moving into apps and walled gardens. Part of the reason for that is that running a well researched blog will never pay for your time, so becomes a hobby thing, and most people are fine to use Facebook for that.
- elorant 7y agoHow do you know that the content Google features is the best there is? If we stop clicking on sites and just rely on Google to provide us the content we'll go down a very slippery slope.
- BigJono 7y agoI don't really see how this problem is any different to 'how do we know the #1 search result is the best content there is?', if it provides you the information you want, then great, otherwise you load #2.
- millstone 7y agoGoogle lends the weight of its authority to the answers it presents. It's one thing if Infowars says that Obama is planning a coup against Donald Trump, it's another if Google says so.
- throwawayjava 7y agoIt does help your clients. I mean, maybe not yours specifically. But snippets are great for users in the typical case.
- pyrale 7y agoThese users are no longer his clients.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> If Google wants to go back to being a search engine instead of a content thief and aggregator A search engine is inherently a content aggregator; the functions are inseperable.
- antonvs 7y agoNot necessarily. Google used to be more of a link aggregator. There's a difference, as the OP proves.
- dragonwriter 7y agoGoogle (and virtually every other search engine) has always included content with links, what's different now (but not unique to Google, though they are perhaps the most advanced at it) is that now it algorithmically synthesizes content instead of merely aggregating it.
- wutbrodo 7y ago> Micro data only serves Google. Not my clients. Not my sites. Just Google. Well it also serves Google's users, to be clear. Though I should also be clear that I don't think that justifies it, since I think it's bad for the ecosystem in more subtle ways than are expressed in immediate user satisfaction.
- tremon 7y agoThat depends on how you define "users". If you define a website creator also as a Google user (by virtue of wanting to be found through Google), then Google is serving part of its users to the detriment of their other users. And if you view Google instead as a connection broker, e.g. a middle-man between publisher and consumer, then Google is destroying their own business by snubbing publishers. Assuming that Google is still making rational, intelligent decisions, it follows that Google no longer sees itself like that.
- dyarosla 7y agoDid Google ever see itself as prioritizing publishers and consumers equally? I think that’s a false premise and the parent is right; Google’s priority has always been consumer first.