4 ms·
> we don't have a suitable replacement That is your opinion. I've been lucky enough to taste plenty of other banana strains and there are definitely better ban
by latchkey 7y ago
> we don't have a suitable replacement
That is your opinion. I've been lucky enough to taste plenty of other banana strains and there are definitely better banana's than Cavendish. The smaller ones that you generally get in this region, that are really ugly on the outside, taste so much better.
> you've seen a few big banana plantations
More than 'a few'... literally 3 whole countries worth. There is absolutely no shortage of trees and farms. Just to give you an idea of how much I've seen and I didn't even tag all of it... https://imgur.com/a/olSoTXe https://imgur.com/a/olSoTXe
I'm not saying that this disease isn't a problem, but I have hard time believing it is a catastrophic problem for all bananas.
If you're going to go into big problems, I'd say that African Swine flu is a much larger issue for this region. I drove through countless 'checkpoints' all over northern VN/Laos where they sprayed down my motorbike wheels with some unknown chemicals. There are literally signs everywhere talking about the issue. Millions of swine have been slaughtered. Usually you see pigs running around freely on the roads, but once you get to a certain point in northern vn, you stop seeing them entirely.
- onion2k 7y agoThat is your opinion. It's not my opinion. It's the opinion of every banana industry analyst who says losing the Cavendish would be the end of the banana export industry, which is pretty much all of them. There's a reason why we get articles catastrophising about the impact of Panama Disease posted to HN on a semi-regular basis.
- latchkey 7y ago> It's the opinion of every banana industry analyst who says losing the Cavendish would be the end of the banana export industry, which is pretty much all of them. What a great title for a business card. Of course they have every motivation to say that the sky is falling. It attracts attention, doesn't it? > There's a reason why we get articles catastrophising about the impact of Panama Disease posted to HN on a semi-regular basis. I'm sure there is a reason, but it may not be what you think it is.
- chasil 7y agoThe original article indicates that most banana strains cannot be mass-marketed: "Although thousands of banana varieties grow around the world, only a few have the precise characteristics necessary to withstand the rigors of large-scale commercial cultivation, long-distance transport, and international marketing. A banana with those characteristics, a taste and appearance similar to the beloved Cavendish, and resistance to TR4 does not exist."
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I'm not saying that this disease isn't a problem, but I have hard time believing it is a catastrophic problem for all bananas. It's a catastrophic problem for the existing commercial banana industry, not for “all bananas”.
- latchkey 7y ago> the existing commercial banana industry You mean in the US or elsewhere? The US is only 25% of the total market. While a big number, there are far larger consumers of bananas. 'it is important to note that only 15 percent of banana production is traded in the international market'. It sounds like people might have to learn to eat another type of banana. It has already happened when the market switched from Gros Michael to Cavendish. Given that there is 1000 varieties of bananas out there, that is a marketing problem, not a catastrophic problem. http://www.fao.org/economic/est/est-commodities/bananas/bananafacts/en/ http://www.fao.org/economic/est/est-commodities/bananas/bana...
- bipson 7y agoYou didn't listen it seems: There is no commercially exploitable banana for export that we know of yet. Going from Gros Michel to Cavendish required rethinking how we farm, harvest, ship, ripen, sell bananas. Cavendish could simply not be shipped like Gros Michel before. You said yourself that Cavendish is a "boring" banana. This might be true. But all the great, tasty, small bananas you are talking about cannot be shipped anywhere by the means we know of today. That is, every market outside of the banana growing regions cannot have these, they will be mush, rotten or inedible once they reach the shelves. Apart from that, I agree, we will (hopefully) eventually find a replacement and adjust our methods and taste. I'm all open for new banana tastes. But the problem is real, the economy as a system (farmers, logistics, consumer) does not know of an alternative so far. Even if you think different. But I guess you could be very rich if you have an alternative ready and are willing to transport it and selling it in EU/US/Canada.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> But all the great, tasty, small bananas you are talking about cannot be shipped anywhere by the means we know of today I'm fairly sure I've seen labelled-as-imported dwarf red and apple bananas in California, but certainly the transport properties of most plausible replacements by taste are inferior to Cavendish (and I don't even know if any of them are Panama disease resistant, and if they aren't, they aren't plausible replacements.)