4 ms·
I'd be interested to know if folks here with dyslexia agree with the sentiment that dyslexia affects their visual ingestion of words, and that visual aids (like
by gnicholas 7y ago
I'd be interested to know if folks here with dyslexia agree with the sentiment that dyslexia affects their visual ingestion of words, and that visual aids (like the colored filters he discusses) can improve their reading ability.
I ask this because many dyslexia experts in the US (and some outside the US) insist that dyslexia is purely phonological, and therefore non-visual.
As someone who works in the field but does not have dyslexia, I have to reconcile these academic's edicts with the personal descriptions I hear from individuals with dyslexia, which clearly indicate that dyslexia can have visual causes and aids.
- mikekchar 7y agoI'm with the phonological camp. In fact, one of the things that surprised me greatly is that I can read Japanese dramatically more comfortably than English. I can read the symbolic characters very easily and since almost all of the phonetic characters in Japanese are grammar, I tend to gloss over it. However the grammar is very regular, so you can usually figure out what's going on without having to read every character. In fact, I get very frustrated when I read children's books because they often omit the Chinese characters for words and replace them with phonetic characters. I just can't read it without a massive struggle. It's also interesting that I vastly prefer computer programming languages that use symbols rather than words. One of the common "coding practices" in Ruby is to replace "if !whatever" with "unless whatever". I literally can't understand the latter and I'm always rewriting it in my editor to "if !whatever" so that I can understand the code. You might think I'm just used to it, but if I write "if not whatever" -- bam! I can't understand it. Weird, isn't it!
- yummypaint 7y agoI had the same experience with chinese characters being easier
- dasmoth 7y agoHave you ever tried an APL-family programming language? If so, I’d be curious how you found it.
- mikekchar 7y agoI have, indeed. I studied APL at school (which shows you how old I am!) I enjoyed reading it and hated typing it :-) I tend to prefer things that are a little bit in between. APL has quite a lot of unusual features, though (some of which were intuitive for me, having been a FORTH programmer, and some of which were not -- having a pretty poor math background). I've been thinking of playing with one of the modern APL variants. I think I would really enjoy it these days.
- chrismatheson 7y agoI can say that I read a lot. And comprehend what I read very well. Writing on the other hand is definitely the most difficult but. The best way I can describe it is if I were to write a short essay by typing myself & then the same essay with the same exact words by dictation. The results would be hugely different. As soon as I have to actually put the words on the paper myself something goes wrong. It’s usually still legible English, but the meaning / structure of what I’m trying to get across seems to get lost. If someone reads it back to me I can tell this and realise it. It’s a weird one :)
- ck425 7y agoI'm the same. I never had too much issue reading, though I do avoid anything overly literally as the language just gets in the way of story. But writing has always been impossible for me, even with keyboards. The whole idea of 'padding' out essays did my head in at uni. Interestingly on the speaking vs writing point I naturally use a lot of tone and body language to convey my meaning. That might be my acting background but I also wonder if it's a compensating mechanism for struggling with words.
- yummypaint 7y agoAs the article says, everyone's experience is different because it isnt diagnosed physiologically. When i was diagnosed i had a reading tutor who focused on building connections between visual symbols and vocalization, which i think was the right approach for me. Personally, i dont have the level of spelling difficulty as the author, but i will sometimes miss-identify and mis-pronounce words in a self consistent way for months or years before noticing some additional characters. When reading prose in my head without sounding out words, i can manage 500 wpm with good comprehension. Reading text aloud at a normal narration speed is extremely taxing and difficult. As a result I never attempt read verbatim from slides when giving talks.