4 ms·
"Why is your phone different?" Because most people don't have 32 gigs of personal data written on scraps of paper.
by Alex3917 16y ago
"Why is your phone different?"
Because most people don't have 32 gigs of personal data written on scraps of paper.
- tptacek 16y agoNeither did this guy. What are we arguing about? I agree: encrypt your drug dealing receipts; they grey area over obstructing search warrant is vastly preferable to the high-fidelity dump of your transactions they'd automatically get. Are you suggesting that the plainly visible SMS logs on your phone are in some special digital domain that, in stark contrast to the notebook in your bag, the police should not have access to in an incident-to-arrest search for evidence? That seems pretty silly to me, but that doesn't make you wrong.
- Alex3917 16y ago"Are you suggesting that the plainly visible SMS logs on your phone are in some special digital domain that, in stark contrast to the notebook in your bag, the police should not have access to in an incident-to-arrest search for evidence?" It's one thing to say that the last 48 hours of SMS messages are fair game. But most people have the last several years worth of SMS conversations on their phone. And considering the average teenager sends 3339 texts a month, I don't buy that police should be able to read your 80,000+ most-recent text messages on the grounds that this is similar to a pocket notebook.
- imajes 16y agoAlso, if LEOs are required to obtain a court order to read these from the network provider's archives and logs, why should that not also be true for your phone?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- imajes 16y agoRight. I understand the legality of it, however I was more referring to the moral case. Since a court order has to be argued for, it should also hold true that a search of an electronic data store would also require more than just plain-sight standards, especially given a scrap of paper in my pocket feels to me not 'plain sight' equivalent to a text message on a phone, or an email on my computer. I think this is just one more instance of our collective false understanding in the legal system as to how data, electronics and the like truly work - and we're going to have to wait it out longer before this stuff is all better represented.
- fleitz 16y agoBecause most people don't have their network provider with them upon arrest. For instance if when arrested you had 1kg of contraband on you it would be admissible, for instance if when arrested you had 1kg of contraband at your network provider's NOC then they'd need a warrant to search it.
- fleitz 16y agoI'll admit that when I was arrested I had notice but I'll tell you what I brought with me on my person. A piece of ID (so I didnt get held longer while they 'established' my identity), and enough cash for a pack of smokes and a cab for when I got out. I didn't even bring a number for a lawyer as my friends were going to take care of it. My blackberry, cell phone, other electronic records, keys to my car, my ATM card, credit card, etc, were left with friends. When they arrested me I gave them my ID confirmed my self as being the person on the ID and remained silent. Even the guy in my cell who was 'charged' with something errily similar I said nothing to in regards to what I was doing there. He kept asking me for advice of what I would do in his situation and all I could tell him was remain silent and speak to a lawyer. I think he was a cop as I never saw him again, where as most of the other people I ran into I saw the next morning, and I was never formally interrogated. If you think the police should be able to search 80000 of your SMS records then by all means bring them to your arrest. If you don't then take the steps you feel are appropriate to prevent this from happening. There is no law requiring the average person to retain their SMS records for police inspection upon arrest.
- pyre 16y ago> then by all means bring them to your arrest. Most people are not given notice of their arrest.
- tptacek 16y agoThey're pretty sure it's at least a possibility when they're doing hand-to-hand drug deals.
- pixelbath 16y agoWhat? Most arrests don't go down that way, and the accused frequently don't have time to: 1. Drop off their car and keys, two phones, laptop ("other electronic records?"), wallet at home or with friends; 2. Stop by the ATM to ensure they have post-jail money 3. Casually dispose of any other incriminating evidence. If you have the luxury though, I agree with everything you said. Don't bring child pornography or other incriminating evidence to the police station for your arrest.
- gorm 16y agoHow about starting apps like your Facebook App, IM App or Google Mail App on iPhone/Smartphones. Does this require a warrant?