3 ms·
The island was in fact one of the original suspects when Earhart's plane first went missing but by the time the US Navy arrived several weeks later, storms and
by gamblor956 7y ago
The island was in fact one of the original suspects when Earhart's plane first went missing but by the time the US Navy arrived several weeks later, storms and natural wave action would have washed most of the plane away.
The point of the analysis was to see if there was photographic evidence to suggest that it might have been the correct island all along.
Yes, it could be a tree trump or some other debris--but it also looks exactly like the wreckage of a particular part of her plane, which is enough to justify a more detailed search.
Like the Bismark's final resting spot, this island has a significant underwater seamount. If the plane landed on the beach and sunk, if could have slid thousands of feet into crevices in the seamount or even all the way down to the abyssal plain surrounding the island.
- mannykannot 7y agoI agree that there are other factors that make Nikumaroro a candidate for Earhart's final resting place. Calling the image exactly like an Electra undercarriage leg is quite a stretch, IMHO - even that interpretation's proponents merely called it "consistent".
- gamblor956 7y agoIt does look exactly like a blurry, distant photo of an Electra leg... That's why they're launching another search. It could be other things, but it could also be debris from the exact same type of plane she was flying.
- mannykannot 7y ago> It does look exactly like a blurry, distant photo of an Electra leg. At least for the sake of argument, I will grant that a blurry, distant photo of an Electra leg might look exactly like this one, but in such a case, the exactitude would be in the correspondence of two blurred, small images, and that exactitude does not transfer to the identification of the imaged object as an Electra leg. You have to ask what else could produce a matching photograph, and if it is sufficiently distant and blurred, just about anything of approximately the right reflectivity would work.
- unreal37 7y agoI hope you're right and they find it. But let's also be honest here... the blurry spec smaller than a grain of rice in the original photo doesn't look like anything, specifically. [1] It doesn't look like an aircraft landing gear at all. Now you can make an aircraft landing gear look like it if you make it blurry, but that blurry grain of rice looks like nothing. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20190812112844im_/https://tighar.org/Projects/Earhart/Archives/Research/Bulletins/82_BevingtonAnalysis2/BevObj.png https://web.archive.org/web/20190812112844im_/https://tighar...