3 ms·
> I honestly don't get all the hate AMP gets around here. From a consumer standpoint AMP provides nothing but benefits compared to what we had before. Two main
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
> I honestly don't get all the hate AMP gets around here. From a consumer standpoint AMP provides nothing but benefits compared to what we had before.
Two main reasons:
1. The obfuscation of AMP source URLs in Google search results is usually the biggest reason for the hate.
2. The "AMP Carousel" in Google search results is designed to keep people on Google and makes it much less likely people will leave to explore other pages on the publisher site (I can't find the article now but I recall reading a report from one publisher that showed a HUGE dropoff in users viewing an article and then going to view other articles on the site).
So it's less about the technology of AMP per se and more that, the way it's currently implemented, is about Google dictating more and more the way the web works.
- monkpit 7y ago> ... showed a HUGE dropoff in users viewing an article and then going to view other articles on the site ... Just speaking from personal experience, lots of AMP pages are totally broken for me aside from the actual content. I have encountered pages multiple times where visiting links to other content was broken. I would (personally) take findings like this with a grain of salt.
- gregable 7y agoIf you encounter this again in the future, I'd love to take your bug report with the specific page in question. You can email me directly. My email is pretty easy to find from my profile.
- gregable 7y ago#1 is being fixed for supporting browsers (Chrome so far). https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2019/04/instant-loading-amp-pages-from-your-own.html https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2019/04/instant-loading-am... You can see it for a number of sites already. For example, search for an AMP result from collins dictionary.
- zaarn 7y agoSo essentially yet another standard pushed out by google via Chrome with 0 feedback from other browser vendors.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoNo, the other vendors gave feedback and objected to it: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/05/30/mozilla_web_packaging/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/05/30/mozilla_web_packagi...
- zaarn 7y agoThat sound even more like Google's modus operandi when it comes to browser development!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]