5 ms·
Pretty simple solution: infrastructure investment is handled at the State-level. If there are infrastructure investments that go beyond a state's borders, you
by dragontamer 7y ago
Pretty simple solution: infrastructure investment is handled at the State-level.
If there are infrastructure investments that go beyond a state's borders, you rely upon National-level government to debate and allocate infrastructure investment.
> Game theory? Tragedy of the Commons? What all is at play here and then as importantly, how do we do better?
Market failure. Independent actors working for their own self-interest will create a failure in long-term thinking. You address this the same as any other market failure: you create a larger, 3rd party entity which is trusted. This trusted entity allocates funds and makes bigger decisions that the smaller groups of people cannot do efficiently.
- bobthepanda 7y agoYou'd also need to do that for * schools * police/fire/ambulance * pretty much any locally allocated service Which would pretty much be political suicide in any state.
- dragontamer 7y agoNot really. The important bit is that some-degree of resource should be left to higher-level stuff. Ex: Few people bats an eye at FAFSA, which encompasses a nation-wide accreditation system for colleges and nation-wide student loan assistance. There are national-level Police forces: ICE, FBI, and ATF to name a few. Obviously, political groups have taken issue with how these agencies operate, but their efficacy cannot be denied: they can do things more efficiently than local police forces.
- bobthepanda 7y agoColleges get their tuition from students, so the location of where the student's family lives is mostly irrelevant outside of in-state vs. out-of-state. Schools are funded by local property tax and the districts are drawn pretty locally, as are police and fire. They are also subject to the same vicious cycle of people move in -> demand better services -> local taxes go up -> the rich childless leave -> tax base suffers -> local taxes go up, etc.
- Consultant32452 7y agoLarger level government authorities are not more trustworthy than local ones and are likely to have their loyalties further from me geographically than the untrustworthy local government.
- dragontamer 7y agoThe alternative is to live with market failure: watching your locality make poor investment decisions that transfers wealth to neighboring cities and counties. If you want to work together, the cities need to form up a larger scale contract and work together. If you are willing to compete against your local cities, you are allowed to do that as well.
- Consultant32452 7y agoThat's not the alternative. The state transfers my wealth even farther away, not just to my neighbors. The federal government, even farther away.
- dragontamer 7y agoThe market transfers your wealth away to those who are willing to provide services for a cheaper price. At some point, you gotta work together if you want to counteract this force.
- Consultant32452 7y agoThe market allows me to voluntarily trade my wealth for goods and services that I perceive as having equal or greater value than what I'm giving up in trade. Every single voluntary purchase is a net benefit to both me and the seller. The same can't be said for involuntary trades, like those that filter through the government. This is the situation we're discussing right now. The government took your money and spent it on some pet project, probably tied to a donor. They then opened that project to "the public," some of whom use it without paying in. That is definitely a problem. But it is not solved by moving up to the next tier of government. That only makes the situation worse, because the pet project/donor is more likely to be even further from you geographically. At least with the local government there is some chance you will benefit from the project, and you have more ability to oversee and change local political priorities.