9 ms·
Black Beekeepers Are Transforming Detroit’s Vacant Lots into Bee Farms (2018)
- apo 7y agoTwo points: 1. the color of the beekeepers' skin is irrelevant and appears to have been an addition made by the poster 2. "The duo bought their first vacant space on Detroit’s East Side for $340 with the help of the Detroit Land Bank Authority, an agency that works to redevelop abandoned properties." That is a redevelopment effort designed to get action. Can anyone comment on how this program and zoning requirements interact?
- SketchySeaBeast 7y ago> 1. the color of the beekeepers' skin is irrelevant and appears to have been an addition made by the poster It's the title of the original post on the HuffPost.
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoDoesn't matter if that's the original title, the mention of "black" makes many in HN's userbase uncomfortable.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoHe says: > 1. the color of the beekeepers' skin is irrelevant and appears to have been an addition made by the poster It isn't an addition at all, regardless of our comfort.
- peterwwillis 7y agoI didn't realize what was going on in this thread until I double-checked the article - currently, the HuffPost story still has the title "Black Beekeepers Are Transforming Detroit’s Vacant Lots Into Bee Farms". The reason this title has "Black" in it is it's part of a HuffPost column called Black Voices; literally stories concerning African Americans. And the beekeepers noted here are indeed black. And I don't know if many of you know this, but there aren't that many black beekeepers out there. The fact that the beekeepers are black is germane to the column and the story. Removing that from the title is erasing an achievement of a local black community. I think another commenter on here was spot on: someone on HN removed the "Black"ness from the story because it made them uncomfortable. Can a mod please restore the original title?
- dang 7y agoSure, I've done so. Happy to, if it's central to the article. The goal here is to get the fairest, most substantive discussion of the article and minimize predictable, stupid, always-the-same flamewar. > someone on HN removed the "Black"ness from the story because it made them uncomfortable That was me, and it didn't and doesn't make me the least uncomfortable. What does make me uncomfortable: people jumping to conclusions and accusing us of ugly motivations based on a made-up interpretation of almost zero information. Internet users have no compunction about doing that, and there's a kind of widespread implicit agreement to pretend that it's cost free. It's far from cost free.
- peterwwillis 7y ago> I'll tell you what does make me uncomfortable: people jumping to conclusions and accusing us of ugly motivations based on their own made-up interpretation of almost zero information. 1) You're a moderator - literally a person with more power than everyone else. People tend to get upset around the decisions of people more powerful than them, and jump to conclusions. It has happened in every single organization I have ever seen, including freaking yoga studios. It's on page 1 of your job description. So while I have sympathy for you, I don't have pity. 2) Sharing more detail about your changes can make a huge difference to the people that are affected by them. It may not always make people happy, but often a lack of understanding creates frustration. I appreciate the information you added after the fact, and suggest to add these details with your initial changes. 3) I don't know why you made the original change. Perhaps you didn't realize where the story came from, and just wanted to avoid any conflict at all, and so erased whatever seemed like it might generate controversy. But in doing so, you generated controversy. Like I mentioned multiple times in my comments, it appeared that the change was racially motivated ("Unless I missed something ...", "If true, ..."), even if unintentional, as a side-effect of trying to avoid a difficult discussion. And I may have been wrong, and made an unfair accusation. For that I apologize. But it turns out that the motivation didn't matter at all, because the effect was the same regardless of intent. 4) Sometimes we need to have difficult discussions. Yes, even on the fantasy land called HN, where the real world doesn't happen, and all that exists are interesting stories about technology. In this case, the really interesting discussion is not about beehives, it's about the way people interpret what they read, and how they act based on that. As one example, people may see a word that signals in them an unacceptable idea or scenario and jump to conclusions. For another, it's possible for someone to completely unintentionally have a negative effect on a minority community without even realizing it; which is a really important thing to realize, face, and learn from, but that most people in such a position won't want to accept. And another is that sometimes something that could cause a flame war might be there for a good reason, and people may need to learn to deal with it (as we used to say growing up, "like adults"). What could have been a flame war is (to me) a very important lesson about personal bias, how people interpret the world around them, and the effect they have on others. I'm saving this article as a favorite story to remind myself.
- arkades 7y agoIt matters that the person theyre responding to is literally asserting, and I quote, “the color of the beekeepers' skin is irrelevant and appears to have been an addition made by the poster.” It’s ... the point under discussion in this sub-thread.
- shaki-dora 7y agoIf 'the mention of "black" makes many [..] uncomfortable' then that would seem to be their problem.
- apo 7y agoThat's weird. I thought that there was a different title when I read the article. Even double checked the title.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoReally??? That's bizarre.
- steve19 7y agoA/B testing headlines is not uncommon
- arkades 7y agoThe title of the page I’m looking at is the same as the post here, and is in a section entitled “Black Voices.” I don’t see where the poster changed anything.
- hinkley 7y agoAnd with a by-line from Philip Lewis who is conspicuously melanin-advantaged. Look. Every demographic that does conspicuously well in an avocation has role models and mentors that children and young adults can identify with, from hard sciences (Feynman comments on this I think as far back as the 70's) to professional cycling. If it seems childish, recall the target audience. Then take a deep breath, and relax.
- dang 7y agoOk, we've shortened the title. Please let's all step away from the flamebait now. Edit: since some people are arguing that it's an essential element of the story, I'm happy to put it back. The issue here is trying to get the content of the article the most interesting, substantial discussion the community can give it. That requires minimizing the things that push discussions in nasty, stupid directions, which we do routinely on this site all day.
- obese_by_nature 7y agoWhy did you shadow ban my account?
- dang 7y agoWe didn't. Its karma fell below a threshold at which its comments get moderated by default. If you want to email hn@ycombinator.com and commit to posting thoughtful, substantive comments and following the site guidelines, we'd be happy to reset it for you. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- obese_by_nature 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20675363 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20675363 This is not pseudoscience -- unlike many of the other comments on GMOs and hormones. It's backed by research and the FDA. Tell me where I'm wrong.
- obese_by_nature 7y agoI'm commenting here.
- fzeroracer 7y agoReally? No offense Dang but don't you think that is patently ridiculous if a mere mention of skin color for a relatively benign story invites trolling and racism? Why is mentioning the fact that they're black somehow flamebait here on HN? This is a story written by a black man, under 'Black Voices' about Black beekeepers with their race explicitly mentioned in the title of the article.
- dang 7y agoI'm going to collapse this subthread which, predictably, became a flamewar about the title (and the title change (and probably next, the title changeback)). You'd be welcome to repost your point about land redevelopment, which I assume doesn't contain any flamebait, in a comment of its own.
- buboard 7y agoi m happy that they are black, but it s totally irrelevant to the article
- fastball 7y agoSo irrelevant to the article that the race is not even mentioned anywhere in the body, only the title. Textbook clickbait.
- isoskeles 7y agoI thought this was a Vice article based on the headline alone.
- Zenst 7y agoIndeed, it is like putting the word human in there, though the prospect that it may goad a few racists to think they can do better, has many positive outcomes.
- RaceWon 7y agoI'm not being an asshole here I'm Fucking SERIOUS: Why is it "Black Beekeepers..." And not Just "Beekeepers" (And yes I saw the pic of the author who is presumably American of African descent). I fear America will Never shed its segregation roots as long as we keep referring to each other in terms of color. Me, I'm adopted, and when people ask me where I'm from, I'll usually say Earth. Peace.
- bnjms 7y agoThis reminds me of something my girlfriend heard this weekend when she met up with some old friends. She heard an employer say something like: tell the Chinese girls such n such. Where one would expect to hear just tell the girls.
- iron0013 7y agoI'm not sure simply saying "I'm not being an asshole here" precludes you from being an asshole, in the same way that "I'm not a racist but..." is no guarantee that what follows isn't going to be racist.
- RaceWon 7y ago> I'm not sure simply saying "I'm not being an asshole here" Thank you. I was clearly wrong: We absolutely should continue to delineate ourselves in terms of skin hue; Obviously that is the only, and best way to bridge the racial chasm. I must be blind to have not seen this.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- abc_lisper 7y agoArticle from 2018
- dang 7y agoGood catch! Added.
- michaelvoz 7y ago1) Disappointing HN thread - all about race and little about article? 2) Disappointing article. No depth at all. How is the money spent? How many bees are there? Where does one get bees? Are there flowers around for the bees? How did this person get into beekeeping? Why beekeeping and not, say, an organic garden? 3) Disappointing site - tons of flashing banners and ads everywhere. What sounds like an awesome, uplifting story that may be replicate-able across the country was turned into an overall disappointing puff piece.
- aphroz 7y agoI had the same thought, I read the article to see if that was a thing, like black hat hackers. Turns out in the US, they find amazing that black people can be beekeeepers like white people. And yes, I checked who wrote the article, but it is probably a way of thinking that is shared nationwide.
- michaelvoz 7y agoRight? People raise bees. The people may be black. They may be white. They may be yellow. Or Brown. The people might me muslim, or jewish, or atheist. The bees don't care, and neither do I. I have no idea why it matters.
- samstave 7y agoDetroit is such an amazing opportunity for anyone with money. Buy up a shit ton of property for extremely low prices - it already has city infra, power, water, etc. Install solar on lots. Bui;d a fucking datacenter for pennies on the dollar compared to other places. Install municipal wifi with UBNT equipment and transform the abandoned parts of the city for extremely cheap and reap the benefits both socially and financially in ten years. If you have money to speculatively invest in real-estate -- buy everything you can in detroit. Then get celeb detroiters to join and help back you. Detroit is just ripe for innovation and can become a tech hub with LOW COST housing ASAP. FUCKING CANNABIS is legal in MI now -- build a huge extraction lab there easily and cheaper than ANY other state in the nation.
- hinkley 7y agoI've forgotten which movie now, but there's a big scene in a blockbuster where they destroy a building for real. The studio made a deal with the town to take a dilapidated building, destroy it, then build the town a new building to replace it. When I used to watch the Walking Dead I kept thinking there was a missed opportunity to do something similar in Detroit with any post-apocalyptic show and some abandoned neighborhoods. Even razing the properties afterward and paying for disposal would be an improvement in safety.
- eplanit 7y agoIn RoboCop, crime-ridden "Old Detroit" was to be transformed by OCP Corporation into "Delta City"[1]. One can imagine a newer version of the story, with OCP replaced by "The FAANG Group". [1] https://robocop.fandom.com/wiki/Delta_City https://robocop.fandom.com/wiki/Delta_City
- codeisawesome 7y agoYeah but think about the optics - “our city is a perfect setting for the zombie apocalypse with no extra work needed”...
- twic 7y agoPeripherally related: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-16858535 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-16858535
- robocat 7y agoAre there any dangerous substances in an urban environment that are picked up by bees and that would end up in the honey?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whalesalad 7y agoNo more than the dangerous shit that all of us are taking in constantly living in the same environments.
- egocodedinsol 7y agoI'm not sure that logic holds - swimming in the ocean isn't the same as eating swordfish with respect to mercury, for instance.
- adrianN 7y agoYou're forgetting bio-accumulation.
- Zenst 7y agoHoney that bees have harvested from Rhododendron nectar would be one I know of and is recorded in history as the first ever chemical weapon. Highly recommend this fascinating article about the subject: https://www.kew.org/read-and-watch/hidden-poison-rhododendron-nectar https://www.kew.org/read-and-watch/hidden-poison-rhododendro...
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoNo. The pollen is digested by the bees, which end up with all the gunk accumulating in their bodies. Honey from cities tends to also taste better than rural, because the variety of flowers is far higher.
- dragontamer 7y agoDetroit is an interesting case of how a shrinking city becomes useful for some investors. IIRC, I was looking up the prices of various lots, and many homes were $1000! Now, I don't live anywhere close to Detroit, but the idea of spending maybe $10,000 to $100,000 for dozens or even hundreds of houses is interesting. Developing for humans may be a problem: Hundreds-of-thousands of people have left Detroit, leaving the city in the state that it is in today. But the houses and infrastructure (roads, water, electricity) may be useful for some niches, even in a "ghost town" situation (Or perhaps: more of a "ghost suburb" situation. Neighborhoods with shrinking populations will naturally have weaker schools, causing more people to leave, causing taxes to go up on the remaining people, causing more people to leave, etc. etc. Its a bad death-spiral effect). I think I recall an article about how one writers group was buying up neighborhoods to station writers-circles, effectively creating a community of writers imported from around the country to one location, so that the writer-circle can leverage each other as an author support group. I haven't heard of this Bee Farm thing, but I would have expected that sort of thing to be better in a more rural community. In any case: redeveloping all of that land and making it useful (as opposed to broken down neighborhoods with crumbling infrastructure) is a big question for Detroit... and investors / businessmen. There's probably a lot of opportunity there.
- wil421 7y agoMany of the homes came with a caveat that you have to bring it up to code. The home was only a $1,000 but the renovation costs were 10s of thousands.
- phkahler 7y agoNot sure if it's still the case but you could by adjacent vacant lots for $100.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y agoThat is still the case, but only if you own a home on the lot adjacent to the vacant lot.
- 7y ago
- zeeed 7y agoFantastic. Didn’t get why the skin color was relevant though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Causality1 7y agoMight be a victim of A/B testing. The accurate headline would be "three black beekeepers are transforming Detroit's empty lots" but "black beekeepers are transforming Detroits empty lots" implies the existence of a new social movement with many members, which of course is more interesting and drives clickthroughs and hence ad revenue. That said, Detroit Hives is a really cool team who deserve exactly none of the blame for Huffpost's bad journalism.
- inetknght 7y agoWhy "black beekeepers" instead of "three beekepers"?
- Causality1 7y agoThe specific reason is that it's part of a series entitled "Black Voices". The general reason is that Huffpost fetishizes people of color in order to appeal to their target audience.
- ikeyany 7y agoAre you not familiar with the Huffington Post?
- onetimemanytime 7y agoto get clicks probably. As if beekeeping is not on the "what black people can or do do" list...
- rhinoceraptor 7y agoDetroit is 83% black.
- thirdsun 7y agoSidenote: That Oath GDPR / data collection management popup is pretty much unusable. I can't figure out how to make sure that tracking through their "partners" is disabled and judging by how hard to navigate this tool is I guess I can't rely on the assumption that all of those unnecessary, sketchy options are opt-in. And since I refuse to blindly accept those opaque terms Oath popups basically have become an automated call to close the tab for me these days.
- ggm 7y agoA lot of 1960s and 1970s scifi has concept of "disaster recovery zone" lifestyle, where people go and live as they think they want, without huge government buy-in. John Brunner, Philip Dick, Rudy Rucker. It sometimes feels like Detroit is a semi-hemi-mandated version: You want to try and fix dystopia? Sure. try not to kill anyone, try not to over-succeed because we need taxes and you will become a source, but in the meantime, pick a house: we have thousands.
- usrusr 7y agoMeanwhile in Berlin, concerns that excessive urban beekeeping might be putting too much competetive pressure on wild bee species made minor national news. (probably not so much because the situation is actually dramatic but more because the story is both surprising and confirming of "clueless Berlin hipster sustainability" stereotypes) Did not find a good source in English, just a German article: https://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/kritik-an-bienenkaesten-auf-hochhaeusern-experte-wirft-berliner-imkern-tierquaelerei-vor/24304670.html https://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/kritik-an-bienenkaesten-a... and a terrible translation thereof: https://www.archysport.com/2019/05/criticism-of-bee-boxes-on-skyscrapers-expert-accuses-berlin-beekeepers-animal-cruelty-berlin/ https://www.archysport.com/2019/05/criticism-of-bee-boxes-on...
- stinos 7y agoCame here to post similar. I don't think there are enough and/or large scale studies already, but there are 'local' studies showing negative effects of honeybees on wild bees (and all other pollinators, not to forget). It depends on a number of factors of course, but the general idea is pretty logical: suddenly there's a thousand extra eaters in your area but the amount of food didn't change. Meaning unless you have enough food for all, some are going to suffer. So most people I know with a job in nature conservation and similar think it's really about time this gets studied properly and then possibly regulated; not just Berlin has problems. There are places in the Netherlands and Belgium for instance where beekeepers drive the hives to the border of nature reserves to have their bees have a go at them. If that happens to be a place with only a small population of an endangered pollinating species left, it's not unlikely they will be effected negatively. At the same time there seems to be a rise in people interested in 'amateur' beekeeping, at least around here. And from experience they either simply don't realize that might be a problem, or they just ignore it / don't want to believe it because they think they're doing a good thing, taking care for bees (even though it is debatable whether it's really ok to just take their honey), solving the global bee decline, etc. tldr; the initiative sounds good but there might be unwanted and unknown side effects.
- Gravityloss 7y agoI guess I don't understand - the mead for the honey has to come from somewhere. So there must be flowers near the nests - a lot of them. So one must also create meadows. If they are on polluted ground (common in cities), probably the mead and thus the honey will also contain poisons.