6 ms·
Warrantless cell phone search gets a green light in California
- techsupporter 16y agoI wonder how this would fare if the device had been secured with a PIN or some other password. Are we now back around to a situation similar to the warrantless searches US Customs and Border Patrol can do when crossing a border? Edited to add: I just perused the decision linked to in the article[1] and it doesn't appear that the court addressed that issue. The majority's decision does make reference to a "locked footlocker" that was opened without a warrant, and that the US Supreme Court ruled that the search was invalid because it was "distant from the arrest." It doesn't seem to address breaking open the lock. 1 - http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/opinions/documents/S166600.PDF http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/opinions/documents/S166600.PDF
- tptacek 16y agoNo. If you had read the article carefully, you'd find that the person who had been searched had already been arrested (and with very strong PC). Every ACLU-style "Know Your Rights" video makes this distinction clear: it is not like at the US border, where you can be searched for no reason; there are very specific cases where you can and can't refuse searches. Unlike --- I might add --- large stretches of Europe, where police have far stronger rights to search personal property.
- techsupporter 16y agoI understand that the person had been arrested and was in custody. The question I have is whether or not the police could have demanded the password from his phone if one existed, and what consequences would result from his refusal to provide it. The reference to CBP's searches is that there is some question as to whether or not someone must provide the password to a secured device during an otherwise-legal search.
- CamperBob 16y agoEvery ACLU-style "Know Your Rights" video makes this distinction clear: it is not like at the US border, where you can be searched for no reason And keep in mind that "at the US border" legally means "within 100 miles of any US border." As of 2006 this covers about 2/3 of the US population.
- tptacek 16y agoThe police do not require a warrant to search your immediate person (also your bags and your car) incident to an arrest. They can't search you without arresting you, and they can't arrest you for literally no reason and have that stand (and, apparently, they generally won't arrest you for no reason if you don't provoke them while being detained and sound like you know enough to tell a lawyer what's happened). "Arrest" has a very specific meaning and is a big deal. This guy got arrested, apparently during a hand-to-hand drug sale to an informant. He was screwed no matter what. There are grey areas at play here, but if your phone has no security and they can literally just push a button to see your text messages, I'm not even remotely surprised that what they find there is admissable as evidence. They had the contents of your pockets and your bag. If you had "4 for 80" written in a piece of paper (and, damn, X is expensive!) in a notebook in your bag, that would clearly be admissable after an arrest. Why is your phone different? If you don't want this to happen to you, PIN-lock your phone. They'll ask you for the PIN. You'll refuse. They'll get a warrant almost instantly, and then you won't be able to refuse anymore. So, also, if you don't want this to happen to you, don't get arrested. This headline is extremely misleading. The police in California cannot simply dragnet cellphones. They have to arrest you first.
- ryanwaggoner 16y agoIf you don't want this to happen to you, PIN-lock your phone. They'll ask you for the PIN. You'll refuse. They'll get a warrant almost instantly, and then you won't be able to refuse anymore. I was under the impression that in the US you can't be compelled to disclose your password or encryption key, even with a warrant. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law
- tptacek 16y agoIt looks like you're totally right to point this out, but the situation is not "you have the right to refuse to disclose a key"; its, "you may or may not also be charged with obstruction if you refuse a warrant that demands a key, and the case law isn't settled". Since we're talking about PINs here, by the way, this is a moot point; presumably any major LEO can contract out "recover data on PIN-protected phone".
- dantheman 16y agoThis seems quite dangerous, as we push more and more data into the cloud and use cell phones as the a way to access it. Does this mean when you are arrested, they can read all your emails, get your bank information, amazon shopping history, etc as long as the access is on your phone? If you have a laptop can they do the same thing?
- tptacek 16y agoThere's going to be an interesting Supreme Court case when the police bother to recover a Gmail session cookie from someone's phone or laptop and use it to dive into their email. My guess is the Gmail account owner will win, because when you seize my housekey during an arrest, you do not get to search my house. The reason this hasn't happened already, though, is that the police aren't generally trawling through the Gmail accounts of drug suspects. They have more drug suspects on eyewitness and hand-to-hands than they can deal with; read _Cop in the Hood_ for examples of state prosecutors refusing to pursue cases because drugs seized from suspects "could, for all the apprehending officer knew, have been an Oreo cookie". This is mostly just a fun topic to chatter about.
- tibbon 16y agoCan they compel you to give your phone's password? Otherwise, when in Cali I'm just going to use a password to lock my iPhone
- tptacek 16y agoPassword locking your iPhone is not a forensically secure technique. A better idea would be to keep anything incriminating off it, and (obviously) not to get arrested.
- tibbon 16y agoActually the best way would seem to be some device that would instantly disable the iPhone if you were pulled over. I somehow doubt they are going to start confiscating everyone's phones with dead batteries (with no other reason for arrest or search) just to check the contents. "I'm sorry officer, my phone's battery is dead so I clearly wasn't texting while driving. Am I being detained, or am I free to go?" But probably the easiest thing to do is to quickly slide your phone into a compartment (not hidden, just closed) in your car when you get pulled over. Then they must get a warrant to search your car. Most cops don't push it to this level unless you actually did do something.
- liuhenry 16y agoI know that the iPhones are notoriously bad at securing data when the device is on, but what about the remote wipe option? It's my understanding that 3GS and 4 phones have encrypted HDDs, with the remote wipe clearing the keys. I'm no expert, but wouldn't that be equivalent to any other disk encryption technique (which, to my knowledge, is practically unbreakable if keys are unavailable)?
- Xuzz 16y agoIf they power it off, using the same exploits as the iPhone jailbreaks (and using forensic tools by Jonathan Zdziarski; http://twitter.com/JZDZIARSKI http://twitter.com/JZDZIARSKI) they can easily recover the data. Before the boot-up ROM used on the iPhone was exploited, though, this was much more difficult (if not impossible).