15 ms·
Why does everyone need a place to charge at home? Sure, it is one of the big advantages of an EV, but not everyone can take advantage of it. If the car has a
by rootusrootus 7y ago
Why does everyone need a place to charge at home? Sure, it is one of the big advantages of an EV, but not everyone can take advantage of it. If the car has a 300-400 mile range, then charge it like you fuel up a gas-powered car. Takes a little bit longer, but that will improve over time.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI imagine the same people who are garage orphans are probably also those who haven't got time to charge their machines for an hour or two. That's already a concern for road trips, but day to day that'll be a nightmare. Just hang around the charging station for an hour while your car recharges.
- ecpottinger 7y agoSince it does not take an hour to charge for a normal drive, maybe you are the one with bad timing. If a person is driving 30 miles or less a day they only need less than 10 minutes charging to get by.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoYeah, I didn't consider the reduced time required for the short trip. Though that's adding 10 minutes to every electric car owners commute, isn't it? Can you imagine a large portion of the city all trying to charge up every night?
- gmanley 7y agoElectricity rates and demand are insanely low during the night. In fact whole sale rates can dip into the negatives where they will literally pay you to use electricity. Aluminum smelting plants run during this time. Even if everyone suddenly started charging cars at night at the most we would be back close to daytime demand, but more math is needed.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoSorry, not night - evening - when everyone is all headed home and when one typically would fill up one's car.
- gmanley 7y agoGotcha, that’s actually the time of peak demand and adding a whole new class of high power consumption during that time is indeed scary. In the UK for example where it’s tea time then as well and a bunch of people put on electric kettles. Utilities do a lot of work during that time load balancing and borrowing from other regions for extra power.
- lonelappde 7y agoTaking your car to the fuel station every day is a nuisance. ICE cars only need to go about once a week.
- AshleyGrant 7y agoAnd most people can get by with charging a current gen long range EV once a week if they don't have a charger at their residence. Not everyone, but most people drive less than 250 miles a week.
- stetrain 7y agoIn that scenario stopping at a charger every day would be silly. Stop once a week at a charger that's near a grocery store, movie theater, restaurant, etc. Both of my local Tesla chargers are near grocery stores. Electrify America is installing chargers at Wal-Mart. Charging an EV is less like going to a gas station and more like picking a place to go that happens to have EV chargers while you do other things.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y ago> Both of my local Tesla chargers are near grocery stores. How close? Can you push your cart back to them? > Electrify America is installing chargers at Wal-Mart. How many? If we want this whole "electric car" thing to take off, you're looking at, what, 50% of the whole parking lot? Not a half dozen stalls right beside the store.
- RandallBrown 7y agoNot the post you responded to, but I've seen 20-30 Tesla chargers in the parking lots of several grocery stores. You could very easily push your cart to them. I imagine Electrify America is installing a number that they believe will meet the current demand of electric vehicles. They don't need to fill the parking lot for the hypothetical future where everyone has an EV. That will still take some time and they can easily scale up as they need to.
- stetrain 7y ago
- benj111 7y agoPut them I supermarket car parks. It can charge while you're shopping. Anyway, I would dispute there are people that can't find the time, they may not want to spend 2 hours a week filling up the car, but just like you don't find cars abandoned at the side of the road now, because owners can't find to time to fill up, the problem isn't going to be appreciably worse in the future.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIt's a matter of scale though - filling up with gas is a 5 minute, once every two weeks activity. If you're filling up for 10 minutes every day or an hour a week, that's a hard sell.
- Reason077 7y agoCharging an EV is not really like filling up with gas. You need a slightly different mindset. You're not going to be waiting around constantly for your car to finish charging. In reality, you're charging at night while you're sleeping. Or charging at work while you're working. Or charging at the supermarket while you buy your groceries.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoThe article is about how people can't charge while they are at sleep. There's going to be a huge portion of people who can't charge at work. I guess you have to charge at groceries, which you'll need to go to every day. Though the grocery store will need to be dramatically refitted to support that, and will need to justify having a power grid the size of their parking lot increasing their power bill just because it's convenient for people. It's hard to justify why a grocery store would want to do that.
- benj111 7y agoWhy would you need to do it every day? EV ranges are rising above 200 miles, that's an order of magnitude higher than most peoples commutes, so for most people once a week would be enough. Shops would do it because money and footfall.
- Reason077 7y agoThe latest generation of cars and chargers don't need an hour to charge. A Tesla Model 3 can already charge at 250 kW, which is over 1000 miles per hour. Practically speaking, that means a decent charge in less than 20 minutes. On a long trip, most stops for gas take around that long anyway by the time you use the restroom, buy supplies, eat, etc. The newest chargers being installed today go up to 350 kW, so the charging infrastructure is being future-proofed for even faster charging as the cars improve.
- davrosthedalek 7y agoI buy the "use the restroom, buy the supplies, eat" argument for long road-trips, where it's probably a good idea to stop for 30 min to relax. But not for the fill-up during your commute to/from work when you can't charge at home.
- AshleyGrant 7y agoPut the fast chargers at shopping centers.. Unless the car is run down to nearly a dead battery, it won't need but about 20 minutes on the charger. That's about how long a short trip to the grocery store takes.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIs it feasible to put in hundreds of high voltage chargers?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Reason077 7y agoPerhaps not today, because there aren't enough cars to use them - demand needs to catch up. But yes, it's feasible to fill entire parking lots with outlets at every parking spot. There are already examples of this in Norway. The outlets can be built to share and distribute available power, so the grid connection required is not as huge as you might think. In practice this isn't an issue, as it's unlikely that every outlet will be drawing the maximum current at the same time.
- m4rtink 7y agoIs "garage orphan" really a commonly used term? It sounds really weird & needlessly emotional to me. Just saying "people without a garage" seems perfectly adequate to me & does not require manufacturing new terms.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y ago> Among EV experts, there’s a name for folks who have to park on the street: garage orphans. Apparently The Globe And Mail thinks it has value.
- Excel_Wizard 7y agoThe inconvenience of charging away from home is much bigger than you make it out to be. Other posters here are mentioning ~40 miles of charging in an 18 hour period. That's pretty dang restrictive.
- jfrankamp 7y agoNo one who charges an EV away from home is charging at that rate, that's for an at home 'trickle' charger. Look up any L2 charger and you're well above that rate, and rates are only going for public chargers.
- Excel_Wizard 7y agoI miscommunicated context. The 40 miles in 18 hours is the at-home charging. I wanted to emphasize how restrictive that charging window is.
- stetrain 7y agoThat's also for just a standard 110v outlet. Works fine for me with a ~25 mile round trip commute. And that's usually not charging from 0 to 40 miles of range. The car's battery starts each morning at 90% (a limit set in the car), and ends the day at 90% minus 25 miles. So even though it's only charging 25 miles each night (which doesn't take all night), it's ready to go 300 miles whenever I need to.
- dmitrygr 7y agoA little longer? What am I going to do at a gas station for an hour? I am already bored when I am there for 3 minutes with an ICE car...
- AshleyGrant 7y agoA) It doesn't take an hour to charge an EV unless you're charging past 90%, which isn't typically done as it hurts the battery. B) You're bored b/c you have to stand next to the pump waiting for it to finish. This isn't a problem with EV charging. Go get a coffee or read a book.
- dmitrygr 7y agoNot everyone has time to "get a coffee or read a book" when the car runs empty. Some people live years without a free hour to "just go read a book", for example: anyone with young kids.
- badwolf 7y agoCharge while you go grocery shopping? While you're at work?
- samcheng 7y agoI've found that those same young kids also don't tolerate long periods in the car very well. The periodic stops to charge work pretty well - you stop, plug in the car, then take them to grab a bite to eat and blow off some steam. (Then you end up having to go unplug the fully-charged car long before they finish eating!)
- AshleyGrant 7y agoThe day we ordered our Tesla, my wife and I (without kids) stopped at a truck stop on the way to the Tesla store that we end up stopping at on most of our trips out of town. We did the following: a. Fueled up the car from about half a tank to full b. Used the restroom. c. Bought two fountain sodas We timed the stop from when we parked to when we got back in the car. It was fifteen minutes. I would expect that any family that stops at that stop is there at least that long, if not longer. --- Going back to in-town charging though.. You need to realize that all you need for a charging station is a parking lot, and you can leave the car while it charges. Put DC fast chargers in a grocery store parking lot, and people can charge while they do their weekly shopping. I doubt anyone with young kids is spending less than 30 minutes at the grocery store each week. So instead of getting a coffee or reading a book, they can go buy cereal and frozen chicken nuggets.
- calyth2018 7y agoI don't have a garage, and the work charger charges by the hour. So if one has an EV, and it doesn't charge quickly, you'll be dinged through the nose. Had the charger been charging for the kwh + a margin, then sure. But as is, EVs are off the table for me.
- Reason077 7y agoSounds like a pretty tight-fisted workplace. You would think they'd want to encourage employees to sustainable transport, not try to make a profit on charging.
- robocat 7y agoThey probably just want to discourage one person from hogging one charging station all day. How else would you set up incentives so that many workers can share one charging station?
- chc 7y agoThat's an extremely normal workplace. I've checked out tons of workplaces in my city, and for the ones that actually have chargers, the standard seems to be $2/hr for the first couple of hours and $4/hr thereafter. A workplace that's willing to give up money to help people buy EVs would be uncommonly generous.
- sib 7y agoWhere are you located? In some (US) states, it is illegal to resell electricity, so companies with EV charging networks in those states (including, for example Tesla) charge by time, rather than by the KWh. In this way, they are basically able to claim that they are charging for parking, while the electricity comes along for free. In other states without those laws, many of the networks charge by the KWh.