3 ms·
I agree wholeheartedly with the concerns about gambling. I have another concern to toss on the pile while I'm at it though. This what-if was presented by Bellu
by falcolas 7y ago
I agree wholeheartedly with the concerns about gambling.
I have another concern to toss on the pile while I'm at it though. This what-if was presented by Bellular a few days back: (TL;DR: The profit ratio for microtransactions is orders of magnitude larger than expansions)
Assuming a new WoW mount:
- Takes about 1 man-year of effort to create, costing the company $200,000
- 10% of the player population will purchase the mount at $25
- WoW has approximately 4M active players
That mount just made Blizzard/Activision $10M, at a cost of 200,000. That's a profit/cost ratio of 50:1.
It gets even worse when you factor in loot boxes. New mount has a 1% chance (which is very high) and loot boxes are $1 each? That's going to net (a very approximate) $40M in profit for that one new mount, raising the ratio to around 200:1.
Let's compare that to releasing a new expansion:
- 100 man years of development effort (a team of 50 for two years, probably on the low side)
- $10M in marketing budget and other overhead
- 4m players purchase it at $40 each
That's $160M in revenue, but with $30m in costs. Profit to cost ratio of 5:1.
Given the orders of magnitude between the two, there's a strong incentive to only cater to the 10% of players, at the expense of the other players. How will that impact our games going forward?
- root_axis 7y ago> That's $160M in revenue, but with $30m in costs. Profit to cost ratio of 5:1. This doesn't consider the immense second order effects of releasing an expansion. Releasing a new expansion maintains and increases player engagement - i.e. monthly subscription fees. Without new expansions to keep the player base engaged, players won't purchase cosmetic additions like mounts.
- falcolas 7y agoYou're right. But it doesn't change that the focus of the studio changes from "how do I keep these 4M players playing my game" to "how do I keep these specific 400,000 players purchasing my microtransactions". And given some of the monetization industry talks, the strategy doesn't necessarily include "make a good game".
- ativzzz 7y ago> Given the orders of magnitude between the two, there's a strong incentive to only cater to the 10% of players, at the expense of the other players This model is prevalent in mobile gaming as well. Many popular games have IAP of $50 - $99, that you can buy multiple times per month, which is targeted more towards a 1% than a 10%. > How will that impact our games going forward? I think it affects many industries. Real estate is one of them. I've lived in a few cities with rising real estate costs where the majority of new mid-rise apartments are luxury, clearly priced towards those 10% or less. People who have money, want as much money as possible now, at any future cost. This is simply the general outlook of many businesses at the moment. Of course, this is unsustainable, and it will probably crash at some point.