74 ms·
I love when people double down out of principle, when the only person getting hurt is themselves. He refuses to change it because he did nothing wrong...sure,
by cortesoft 7y ago
I love when people double down out of principle, when the only person getting hurt is themselves.
He refuses to change it because he did nothing wrong...sure, but you are also the only one being hurt by it. Is this really the hill to die on?
- xxs 7y agoDie on? But how - he can challenge the fines in a court of law. Since it's a vanity plate, adding an extra notoriety won't hurt.
- xeromal 7y agoCourt isn't cheap. You're paying for it with a lawyer or with your own time
- giancarlostoro 7y ago> Droogie contacted the DMV who told him to change his plate. He refused because he didn't do anything wrong. While they wiped the fines off his record, unfortunately for him, they didn't fix the problem in the system so once again, Droogie has accrued another $6,000 in tickets that he had nothing to do with. He says he won't be paying those either. Except he just contacted the DMV. No lawyers necessary.
- jedberg 7y agoKnowing the California DMV, that contact probably took at least two hours.
- dawnerd 7y agoNumber of years ago I was frustrated because they never sent me my renewed card and it turned out they never updated my address even though I did the paperwork. Took it to twitter and tagged @CA_DMV and they responded pretty quickly and took care of it. Got my new card pretty much next day.
- rtkwe 7y agoReally I'm surprised they didn't just add NULL to the list of banned words and ban/refuse to renew the tag which seems eminently within their powers.
- c22 7y agoPerhaps they did and the renewal system just assumed that banned word was missing and silently skipped it.
- kelnos 7y ago... and then the second half of the parent's sentence (which you conveniently ignored) applies: he's paying with his own time. I dunno about you, but I value my time way too highly to voluntarily use it to spend time on the phone with the DMV every month or three.
- xeromal 7y agoYeah, we're on Hackernews so I assume most people on here make at least 50+ an hour. The CA DMV will cost $200+ at least.
- vageli 7y ago> Court isn't cheap. > You're paying for it with a lawyer or with your own time At some point surely you can countersue for harassment?
- kelnos 7y agoFor the first time or two, maybe. But you'll be paying for it with hours, possibly tens of hours, of your own free time. And the US legal system is a fickle beast; what seems to you like a slam dunk might not actually be so certain. After the second or third time, the judge will ask, "why didn't you just change your license plate to something else and avoid all this hassle?" And when you answer, "I've grown fond of the plate, and want the DMV to fix its systems", the judge will sigh, and rule against you for wasting his/her time instead of just changing your license plate.
- vageli 7y agoWhat do you mean "after the second or third time"? Are you suggesting that if this person were to sue for the repeated harassment and presumably prevail (with some kind of damages attached) that the behavior would persist?
- foepys 7y agoI can image something more fun to do with my free time than sitting in court every few weeks...
- exfed 7y agoOn top of that, if anything, forcing the government to fix it's bad code (insert snarky ambiguity between software code and legal code) can't be a bad thing. I'd buy the guy a beer.
- cortesoft 7y agoExcept they won't fix it, and he will have to keep filing protests
- jspash 7y agoThe problem is it's a "a privately operated citation processing center" that's causing the problem. They might even be instructed to hand-enter a NULL for these cases. I'm don't really see an incentive for the govt agency to do anything about it. It's no skin off their nose. They'll just keep sending the tickets.
- samthecoy 7y agoAt some point, can you not file some kind of harassment lawsuit? Is it legal to continue to send someone bills for which they aren't liable?
- Grollicus 7y agoDon't you have some kind of illegal prosecution laws? In my home country people could go to jail for that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- saalweachter 7y agoThat's assuming it's an error in their code. For all you know, they have a list of too-clever license plates (null, no plate, etc), and they purposefully divvy up the no plate tickets among them.
- xxs 7y ago"hand-enter a NULL for these cases" <-- should be a reserved word then.
- cortesoft 7y agoFigure of speech... I just mean he is making a stand for something not that important but causes him (and only him, really) inconvenience
- shawnz 7y agoMaybe this particular bug inconveniences only him, but it exposed an improper practice that in general could have affected others too.
- xxs 7y agoI know what "die on" is - it's just inappropriate in the context: nothing bad has actually happened to him.
- esoterica 7y agoYou obviously still don’t know what the phrase “choosing to die on a hill” means.
- xxs 7y agoYeah, just b/c he is stubborn enough and doesn't wish to give up his vanity plate instead of folding. Pretty much nothing that hard/uphill battle has happened to him.
- alanbernstein 7y agoThere are two options: die on the hill, or retreat. He is not retreating. Therefore he has chosen to die on the hill.
- shawnz 7y agoThose would be the options if there was an attack against him, but there's not any attack against him. Wrongly addressed tickets are hardly even a minor inconvenience. I think that's what the parent is saying.
- macspoofing 7y ago>he can challenge the fines in a court of law. If he sees spending time and effort expunging his record every few weeks as worth the trade-off for the 'extra notoriety', then power to him. I wouldn't do that.
- xxs 7y agoI'd presume - the court decision may force the agency to fix their code.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoHe can challenge the fines but still has to pay court costs most likely.
- ars 7y agoBut it does actually work! He can never get any tickets. If he does he'll just claim it was a false one.
- Topgamer7 7y agoExactly! All he has to do is collect all the notices and deal with them every few months. Not to say there aren't other implications that might be more troublesome :P
- SilasX 7y ago“It made my tickets free (if my time is worth nothing)!”
- umvi 7y agoYeah he ends up paying all those tickets with his time though. And time is more valuable than money for a lot of people...
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoAfter the second go round or so he'll have a form letter. After the 4th or 5th time the DMV people will recognize it when it arrives. If it goes on long enough eventually all the employees will be aware of this edge case and he can probably appeal legitimate tickets.
- juancb 7y agoSure he did nothing wrong because it backfired like one of Wile E. Coyote's schemes but the article makes it clear he was hoping to confuse automatic ticketing systems. He was trying to get out of tickets. Sure he didn't break the letter of the law but he tried to break the spirit of the law and it bit him. Some might call that karma, I think he needs a better hobby than standing in line at the DMV which is ultimately what he has taken up. I wonder how long he'll keep going.
- kosievdmerwe 7y agoAKA he was attempting to commit fraud or rather obstruct justice. I don't particularly feel sorry for him.
- ryandrake 7y agoIt reminds me of the guy who owns nissan.com, who probably blew his life savings on lawyers defending himself from Nissan Motors lawyers for decades.
- asdfman123 7y agoI wonder how much you could sell that to them for if you were really good at negotiating. Maybe as much as $100k?
- mcbits 7y agoMultiply that by a thousand or more if they had already accrued $10 million in "damages" by 1999 as they claimed. Apparently it would be extremely valuable to them.
- fortran77 7y agoNissan treated that man very badly. I never owned a Nissan car, and never would because of this. His family name was Nissan, and he registered the domain when Nissan still called itself "Datsun" in the U.S.A.
- jopsen 7y agoYeah, pick your battles. Sure, it would be nice if the systems where patched. But maybe he should just get a job at the DMVs IT department instead :) In the end I would probably rather pay the fines than fix this bug, it's probably a lot of horrible systems barely held together..
- outworlder 7y ago> But maybe he should just get a job at the DMVs IT department instead :) Ew.
- elihu 7y agoThe DMV made a mistake, they know it, and they aren't fixing it. In this case, the problem is relatively inconsequential but it is an institutional failure. The DMV is a government agency which is, at least in theory, somewhat indirectly accountable to the people. Which means that if they're treating one particular citizen unfairly, one option that citizen has is publicly shaming them. (Another option is to file a lawsuit. That's more work, though.) As I see it, this person is performing a public service by not budging on this. It's nowhere near on the same level as Rosa Parks not going to the back of the bus, but sometimes we need people to not simply go with the flow because it's the easiest thing to do.
- crazygringo 7y agoBut they're only performing a public service if it gets fixed -- which there's no indication in the article is happening. And frankly, why would it? Different government agencies likely have zero reason to cooperate on it. Especially if, say, the DMV is responsible for the error, but the courts are the ones dealing with the cost. So unless this guy has a reason to think it will get fixed because of him... he's just wasting his time, no?
- kelnos 7y agoConsidering that the DMV in most places already has a lot of shame heaped on it, I doubt this extra spoonful meaningfully moves the needle. This guy is really just wasting his own time for no actual benefit to anyone. If he genuinely enjoys it, then sure, I guess each to their own, but if not...