2 ms·
Attorney here! (This is not legal advice - consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.) This sounds like a garden-variety term of a settlement agreement
by otterley 7y ago
Attorney here! (This is not legal advice - consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.)
This sounds like a garden-variety term of a settlement agreement. The parties disagree as to whether money is owed, and to settle their dispute, the contractor is offering the customer some money (or at least to drop their demand for some amount of payment) in exchange for not publicizing their grievance.
In this case, the homeowner decided not to accept the offer, and so they are exercising their right to complain about the contractor.
The fact that this made the news is probably the most newsworthy thing of all.
What's weird about this is that the CBC is portraying this as though the money involved is not in dispute. But that can't be the case: if you already have a contract, you can't add terms to the contract without changing the consideration in some way. For example, if I agree to lawn for $20, and then I mow your lawn, you can't demand that you sign a non-disparagement agreement for me to get my $20. But if I mow only half your lawn and then demand it, then you can. The consideration for the non-disparagement agreement is your foregoing legal action against me.