13 ms·
It used to be that only westerners had the means to afford traveling across the world but recently, with the rising income in China and India, they can too and,
by ChuckNorris89 7y ago
It used to be that only westerners had the means to afford traveling across the world but recently, with the rising income in China and India, they can too and, at least in Europe, you can see this.
Although I'm slight worried for the coping ability of highly touristic places, I think it's great that tourism is becoming more accessible to everyone.
There's no reason why visiting famous cultural places should be reserved for the wealthy only. The wealthy have found new places to hide away from the great unwashed anyway.
- jacquesm 7y ago> There's no reason why visiting famous cultural places should be reserved for the wealthy only. Maybe it should be reserved for nobody at all? Or some lottery system determining who gets to play tourist? All this jetting about to take the 1000,000th identical picture of some landmark just to say you've been there too is a very high cost to both the destinations and the planet as a whole.
- moksly 7y agoWe used to have a good way to regulate the amount of tourists in specific areas, called city planning. Maybe it’s a well known fact, but I didn’t personally know this before I started working at a municipality, but there are entire departments who do nothing but plan. The best description of what they do, is that they play really complicated real world sim city, and at some level they draw “residential area”, “industry”, “commercial area”, “hotel” on a map, and those plans determine what we’re allowed to build on those locations. If they plan correctly, there is a finite amount of hotels or holiday homes available in an area, and once those are full, the town or city can house no more tourists. This means that you could actually regulate how many people could physically visit London at any given time by limiting the amount of hotels and the amount of rooms a hotel was allowed to house with city planning. Private rentals and popular apps to handle it, broke this system. At least until regulation catches up.
- leppr 7y agoWell Airbnb may have merged some % of the "residential" and "hotel" zones, but until tourists decide to sleep in tents they still have some way of approximately controlling the number of people in the city.
- WarDores 7y ago"Number of people in the city", yes. But the relative percentages of tourists to locals, no. Which tends to be the problem. Tourists spend money differently and create different logistical issues than residents.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoTourist destinations being overrun predates Airbnb by several decades. Take Venice, it was operating at maximum hotel capacity for at least 30 years. What happened is people stay in neighboring cities and take the train or bus in, or arrive and sleep on cruise ships. It has much more to do with the increased number of people who can afford to travel. Take China alone. In 1990, the number of Chinese citizens who could afford to travel to Europe for vacation was probable in the tens of thousands. Now it is in the hundreds of millions. Add in low cost airfare, things like Ryan Air, and it is simply that more people are able to afford travel.
- jacquesm 7y agoBeing capped at maximum hotel capacity isn't a bad thing per-se because it gives some measure of control. AirBNB blew that up.
- WillPostForFood 7y agoYes, but being maxed at hotel capacity wasn't solving the the overcrowding problem. It was just pushing tourists further out of the city. It would be like trying to solve traffic in San Francisco by freezing housing construction - it just spreads the problem out over a larger area. Here is a NY Times article from 1987 talking about the overcrowding problem and limiting the number of tourists in Venice. https://www.nytimes.com/1987/05/08/world/venice-moves-to-limit-entrance-of-tourists.html?searchResultPosition=1 https://www.nytimes.com/1987/05/08/world/venice-moves-to-lim...
- magduf 7y agoHow about this crazy idea: allow the governments at those cultural places to decide how and if they want to limit tourism there, instead of some know-it-alls in America. If they want to have 1M tourists there, that's their business, not yours.
- jacquesm 7y agoI'm a know-it-all in Europe, smack in the middle of one of those tourist destinations, where there is no more room for me and mine due to the tourism. Oh, and the government here is doing just that.
- magduf 7y ago>Oh, and the government here is doing just that. Then what are you complaining about?
- wool_gather 7y agoThere's a big difference between being in the same space with the famous thing to experience it with your own body, and just seeing even the best reproduction. While I agree with you that we have to reconsider the way we use our wealth vis-a-vis the environment, I can't share your scorn for people who want to explore and experience things.
- jfnixon 7y agoI'm so old I can remember when people were encouraged to travel and buy experiences rather than goods, to meet different people and cultures, live outside one's comfort zone, and broaden one's horizons. Now it is stay home, don't travel, don't eat meat, don't have kids, don't buy experiences or things. Ain't progress wonderful?
- leppr 7y agoThat's kind of a straw man. The type of tourism that would warrant congestion pricing isn't the one where people really get to "meet different people and cultures, live outside one's comfort zone, and broaden one's horizons" anyway.
- wbl 7y agoDo you think a visit to the Louvre or del Prado doesn't expand horizons?
- dependsontheq 7y agoBoth have opening times and entry tickets, they have very easy solutions. Venice doesn’t...
- jacquesm 7y agoNot everything scales. If you have 7 billion people that take two two week package holidays per year the planet will collapse. Now, we're not quite there yet but the strain is showing in many places and if we don't stop this then there won't be any tourist destinations left to visit. Note that the number of people that make meaningful connections with the locals compared to the number of tourists is vanishingly small. You just can't do that when you fly in on Sunday evening and leave again a few days later. All you get to do is to rush from one photogenic site to another, maybe visit a museum and eat at the local versions of the chain stores from somewhere else.
- yoz-y 7y ago
- wetpaws 7y agoTourism is not about the visiting landmarks (although it's also nice to have). Tourism is more about understanding that the world is small, the people around you are still people and that essentially we are all connected to each other.
- collyw 7y agoIts about selfies and Instagram these days.
- kd5bjo 7y ago> All this jetting about to take the 1000,000th identical picture of some landmark just to say you've been there Like everything else, motivations for travel are many and varied; most people probably have several. Reducing them all to bragging rights is an overly reductive and unhelpful view.
- ljm 7y ago> to take the 1000,000th identical picture of some landmark just to say you've been there too That's only one reason for tourism and is not a motivation we all share. That said, this is perhaps another externality of social media that we should seek to redress, alongside the concerns with privacy and manipulation. Instagram doesn't really help anyone when it sends thousands of people to a landmark, so they can take photos of themselves in front of it.
- robben1234 7y agoTaking a picture, of you, or just an `identical` is not why people travel. It's just the most easy way of documenting your visit and a way to have something from that place without actually taking something from that place. Literally the best way to leave no footprint of your visit and be satisfied, but for some reason gatekeepers hate it. Some people travel to meet locals, some people travel to watch sports, some people travel to just lay at the beach and feel the breathe, some people travel to try the food, some people travel to jump around museums and sights. Nothing wrong with any type of travel, unless you're trying to brake local laws or disturb locals (those who try to meet locals no matter what could do that and not even see what they're doing). For some reason westerners are not able to take easy loitering. Maybe because it's illegal in some states or countries, but in most places around the world it's perfectly legal. If you want to just walk around San Marco square, there's no one stopping you, even if you live in Slovakia or Mexico, or Canada. And there should not be anyone stopping you. It's a public place, it's there for everyone to enjoy. If local authorities think they're unable to maintain infrastructure, they still will be fine after implementing a city tax for visitors. But the nature of public spaces should and will be untouched.
- datenhorst 7y ago> Taking a picture, of you, or just an `identical` is not why people travel. As some who just had the dubious pleasure of sharing a vacation with his 19yo cousin, I can tell you that for her it was exactly like that.
- visarga 7y ago> Or some lottery system They would sell the tickets, and we'd be back where we started, unless they have to travel alone and can't bring any companion.
- svmt 7y ago>It used to be that only westerners had the means to afford traveling across the world but recently, with the rising income in China and India, they can too and, at least in Europe, you can see this. IATA forecasts that by 2037 Asia-Pacific will have more air travelers than North America and Europe combined. Source: https://www.iata.org/pressroom/pr/Pages/2018-10-24-02.aspx https://www.iata.org/pressroom/pr/Pages/2018-10-24-02.aspx
- wasdfff 7y agoMy favorite air travel trivia is that the busiest air route by a huge margin isnt in new york or la or anywhere in the U.S, nor is it in europe, nor japan or china, but in Jeju, a tiny island off the coast of south korea. 13m passangers in 2017 alone. It blew my mind.
- noja 7y ago> The wealthy have found new places to hide away from the great unwashed anyway. Where?
- clydethefrog 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradise_Papers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradise_Papers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bahamas_Leaks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bahamas_Leaks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_Leaks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_Leaks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mauritius_Leaks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mauritius_Leaks
- bootlooped 7y agoTourism being more accessible has some big negatives though: the big ecological cost of air travel, and the fact that generally the more tourists there are in a given area the crappier the experience is per tourist.