5 ms·
If UK wants to stay involved and be responsible, they should grant British passport to every HK citizen who was citizen when before handover and their descendan
by nabla9 7y ago
If UK wants to stay involved and be responsible, they should grant British passport to every HK citizen who was citizen when before handover and their descendants.
They should have done that before the handover.
- benj111 7y agoThe Britain that post Brexit will be in desperate need of a trade deal, will be offered a really really bad one by the US that will never be accepted by those that actually voted for Brexit, so those same people will go shopping around for anyone that can possibly replace the EU and US, at the very least if only to give them leverage against the US? I don't think Britain can afford to be pissing off China right now.
- zeristor 7y agoThat’s one way to read it; another might it is not an opportune moment for Brexit.
- benj111 7y agoThat's what I said, isnt it?
- pimmen 7y agoRoughly half of the UK did not want Brexit at all though and wouldn't be that swell to hear that they have to appease a dictatorship now. I doubt Boris Johnson could pull that off with such a razor thin majority in parliament. However, I do agree that China is an option even though it's an unrealistic one and its reception domestically, if the UK has to do major concessions to get it in place quickly, is probably not going to be warm. But, the UK can't afford to have no options on the table.
- benj111 7y ago"Roughly half of the UK did not want Brexit at all though and wouldn't be that swell to hear that they have to appease a dictatorship now" Id count myself in that half, that isnt the half motivated by ideals of sovereignty and control of their own destiny at the expense of all else, plus that half isnt currently in the drivers seat so I kept that half out of the discussion.
- goatinaboat 7y agoI don't think Britain can afford to be pissing off China right now. I’m not sure you understand the Brexit mindset. Everyone knew exiting the EU would be an economic hit, but they believed that some things are more important than just making money and accumulating stuff. A grand gesture in the name of democracy is exactly what a typical Brexiteer would want. Even better that it harks back to the days of Empire, in the case of Hong Kong.
- benj111 7y agoIf that's a part of the Brexit mindset, there's at least an equal part 'keep the Jonny foreigners out'.
- tomohawk 7y agoPutting the onus on Britain, that somehow Britain will be able to do something to not "piss off" the fascists running China? Wow. The CCP doesn't need an excuse. When they see weakness, they use it. Remaining in the EU doesn't help either, as the EU has long been cowed by China. It's almost like the EU thinks that being a suburb of China is their future.
- prewett 7y agoIn fact, they did. Anyone who wanted to could apply to get a British National passport. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_National_(Overseas) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_National_(Overseas)
- nabla9 7y agoIt was not British national passport and it did not give the right to just immigrate. Right to apply means that that only wealthy get to leave. What I'm suggesting is British citizenship.
- prewett 7y agoIt literally is called "British National (Overseas) passport" and they could become citizens: "BN(O)s may become British citizens by registration, rather than naturalisation, after residing in the United Kingdom for more than five years and possessing ILR for more than one year." (from the Wikipedia article) So it's not immediate citizenship in the UK, but it is path to citizenship. They couldn't just grant instant citizenship, because then people in HK would be British citizens in China as soon as the handover occurred. Naturally, China would not go for that. I think what they did was quite reasonable. > Right to apply means that only the wealthy get to leave Your cynicism with no evidence to back it up is not becoming. You did not seem to even know about the BNO program, yet you have certainty that it was administered inequally?
- nabla9 7y agoI remember when it happened. HK citizens felt betrayed. There is also catch that Wikipedia does not explain: BN(O)s of Chinese ethnic origin are entitled to Chinese nationality and do not qualify for British citizenship. The BNO to British citizenship is mainly for BNO holders who are otherwise stateless persons. BNO is only visa free entry for ethnically Chinese. It has been easier to get Canadian citizenship than British.