2 ms·
I have a phobia of MikroTik, especially in the hands of general IT people. Amazing bang per-buck, but I took over a network with 6 sites all with Mikrotik rout
by jimnotgym 7y ago
I have a phobia of MikroTik, especially in the hands of general IT people. Amazing bang per-buck, but I took over a network with 6 sites all with Mikrotik routers and there were some staggering config mistakes. The more I dug the more I became convinced that the OS was, if not to blame, but certainly was a major factor.
I used to test changes (when duties allowed) with nmap, and several times I showed experienced engineers that they had left a service open to the WAN by mistake! When a network is in the hands of general engineers, like it often is in the SME space, I like Watchguard firewalls. Very good defaults, helpful os.
I can imagine in a datacenter where you have network specialists, and robust working procedures Mikrotik could work well.
I use Unifi for Wifi, and have used their routers for a dedicated guest wifi network. For switches I know nothing other than HP, but don't see a lot of issues, especially with the Aruba kit.
- d00bianista 7y agoI again have phobias regarding Watchguard and other products that have the consumer style special WAN-ports and related configuration restraints. Many Mikrotik-devices come preconfigured like consumer devices but the recent CCR-series does not. The firewall in Mikrotik-devices is among the cleanest I've seen and very hard to miss-configure as long as the firewall is otherwise configured to not let unauthorized traffic through. And yes, people are people and this is why we educate people when needed.