6 ms·
The Feynman Lectures on Physics: Algebra (1963)
- smcl 7y agoThis specific Feynmann Lecture popped up very recently either here or on lobste.rs. I have since bookmarked the "FLP" series as I really want to come back to it, but I'm curious if there is any significance to why the Algebra lecture in particular was submitted a couple of times. Is it just coincidence, or was it a particularly good one?
- BucketSort 7y agoI bet it has something to do with the build up to Euler's formula, which is famous for blowing people's minds.
- sooheon 7y agoThe first paragraph seems to address this: because it's enjoyable.
- tim333 7y agoIt's one of my favourites. Aside from Feynman's clear and enthusiastic style, I find it's remarkable you can start from counting 1,2,3 and by a bit of reasoning come up with logs, complex numbers and: >This, then, is the unification of algebra and geometry. I can't help wondering if you could go further and come up with some physics.
- crispyambulance 7y agoThat material is covered in all STEM curriculums as part of the Calculus sequence. For most students, the sublimeness of getting to the Reals and beyond tends to get lost in the grind of lectures, problem-sets and exams. Feynman had a knack for getting straight to the essence of a subject, that's why people love him so much. As for algebra + geometry with physics, there are people who have cut a path to that (see texts by Hestenes), unfortunately, it requires some mathematical sophistication and most curriculums simply don't have the time to reach that level for undergrads, given the way that they're structured.
- StephenDaedalus 7y agoIt recently went rather viral https://twitter.com/Adam8Hasan/status/1137081098381484032 https://twitter.com/Adam8Hasan/status/1137081098381484032
- xref 7y agoI was reading the 1993 bio Hard Drive about Bill Gates recently (great to go back and read old books centered on tech, really makes you remember why people hated Bill/Microsoft...and he’d barely gotten started!) and it mentions several times that Gates would watch these lectures in what he considered his “down time”
- michelpp 7y agoIf you can find it an audio recording of this lecture is also available and it is one of the best lectures in the series. Feynman really brings forward the "soul" of algebra and the illustrates how powerful the art of abstraction is. Audible has all the audio lectures for sale, which is how I got them on my kindle, and I have also seen them floating around the net in other formats. I wish Caltech would release the audio material like they did the books!
- mr_gibbins 7y agoAnd this is what gets me about Feynman, why I am a huge admirer of his work. Take a look at the footnote. An offhand comment of how to calculate the square root of any N using a short iterative loop that you can compute by hand. I'm no mathematician (clearly) but I had no idea that this method even existed. I've just had to try it out. And it's a footnote! I have the book of Feynman's computation lectures and they're dated, but most of the theory is still relevant and his writing remains accessible to anyone.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThat loop is known as Newton’s method, applied to square roots, it is very well known and taught in intro calculus classes.
- grey--area 7y agoHere's the method that's being applied: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton%27s_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton%27s_method It's an iterative method for finding x such that f(x)=0 for a given function f, in this case f(x) = x^2 - N, where N is the number you want the square root of. The special case has such a simple expression, though, that I'm tempted to commit it to memory. Edit: Another nice example, for when you have access to a calculator that can compute powers but not logarithms: a' = a - 1 + x/c^x will converge the base-c logarithm of x (though it will converge slowly if you start very far from the solution).
- fastbeef 7y agoAt it's core, it's also what drives Carmack's Fast Inverse Square Root (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fast_inverse_square_root https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fast_inverse_square_root). Yes, yes, I know Carmack didn't invent it.
- acqq 7y agoThe method in question was known for millennia before Newton, it is believed to be known to Babylonians: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methods_of_computing_square_roots https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methods_of_computing_square_...
- jameshart 7y agoThere’s something delightfully physicsy about deriving Euler’s identity, which famously deals with the irrational and the imaginary, by brute force calculation using log tables and fudging the fifth decimal place. But the approach of sneaking backwards into the algebraic continuation of e^x by actually doing the arithmetic is a great way to viscerally get that it’s all just the same set of mathematical tools.
- jihadjihad 7y agoOne thing I will always appreciate about Feynman as a teacher is that he never shies away from telling you why things work the way they do. I've spoken with a lot of people who "hate math" and it's almost always because they never had a teacher that went into the whys and wherefores behind equations, tables, graphs, etc. Here we have a plainspoken yet rigorous explanation of what algebraic operations actually mean (addition is iteratively adding 1 b times; multiplication is iteratively adding a b times; exponentiation is iteratively multiplying by a b times, etc.). I wish more students would have the chance to build up such intuition, for such intuition is the key to keeping oneself interested in math and not finding that one "hates" it.
- acpetrov 7y agoI stopped enjoying math for about this reason. My university tried to teach with proofs, which to me is about as far from an intuitive understanding as possible Looking for recommendations on lectures / course that goes over linear algebra in this way
- jihadjihad 7y agoIt's honestly harder than it should be to find well-written primers on linear algebra with a geometric focus, which I find to be the most intuitive way to "grasp" the subject and the motivations for it. I like the video lectures on MIT's website a lot for a variety of topics, and the one on linear algebra is pretty solid IMHO: https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/mathematics/18-06-linear-algebra-spring-2010/video-lectures/ https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/mathematics/18-06-linear-algebra... I also like the posts on this blog as well: https://dhruvp.netlify.com/2018/12/31/matrices/ https://dhruvp.netlify.com/2018/12/31/matrices/
- Ntrails 7y ago> I stopped enjoying math for about this reason. My university tried to teach with proofs, which to me is about as far from an intuitive understanding as possible Interesting, because until I had the proofs for eg differentiation, or heck even the quadratic formula - they were meaningless rote learnings. The proof is the intuition imo
- enriquto 7y agoThe Feynman lectures is one of my favourite books ever. Yet, this chapter specifically is the least enjoyable for a mathematician. Somehow I find he's trying to explain very simple concepts using way too many words, which is the opposite style of the rest of the book.
- jonjacky 7y agoIt's deliberate. In his book The Character of Physical Law, Feynman discusses some differences in how physicists and mathematicians approach math.
- mrcactu5 7y agoHe does a numerical computation of the complex powers of 10 (to five decimal places) and they still are on the unit circle. And this was done in 1963.
- gerbilly 7y agoMy high school math teacher taught us a class where he followed this general outline, building up the number systems based on which equations we couldn't solve. Now I know where he must have gotten it from. I think it must have been around grade 10 or 11.