3 ms·
I've thought about this as well and it seems to be the key to free will. We don't have free will except from our perspective.
by colordrops 7y ago
I've thought about this as well and it seems to be the key to free will. We don't have free will except from our perspective.
- NateEag 7y agoWhich means that we should act as if we have free will, since no other approach is reasonable given our perspective. Interesting to note that the Bible implies something like this paradigm, since it describes God as having total control of the universe but also says we have free will. When you first encounter that pair of ideas in the text they seem contradictory, but further reflection eventually leads many to some variation on this idea. I don't believe it's the full picture of free will and predestination in Christian theology - just think it's interesting that it fits with this perspective that would have been quite non-obvious to its authors (at least in regards its relationship to modern physics).
- Retra 7y agoUnder any practical consideration, free will is nothing more than an emotion; it offers you no capabilities, only a propensity to respond to things in a certain way. Without a useful definition of free will that offers something different to this, you won't have a key to anything.
- colordrops 7y agoWhy it has to be useful? We try to understand countless things without have a use case in mind at the time of study.
- Retra 7y agoSo you're fine with a key that doesn't open anything? How will you know it is a key at all then? >We try to understand countless things without have a use case in mind at the time of study. You're making a pretty clear reference to mathematics & science here, but in those disciplines we study things with well-defined structures. We don't study flighty nonsense because it's not ever going to be useful. You shouldn't invoke this phrase to excuse a lack of precision and clarity.
- colordrops 7y agoCalling it a key is your own reframing, implying a use case.
- Retra 7y agoYou called it a key. I said it is not unless it has a useful purpose.
- colordrops 7y agoA key to understanding free will, not a key to using this understanding in any particular way.
- Retra 7y agoWhat understanding? If you can't do anything with it, what do you understand?
- colordrops 7y agoWhy must understanding be conflated with utility?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]