6 ms·
Is there any reason why you would want diversity? On its face Indians wouldn't be less valuable per capita than inhabitants of some small Pacific island just be
by whatshisface 7y ago
Is there any reason why you would want diversity? On its face Indians wouldn't be less valuable per capita than inhabitants of some small Pacific island just because there are more Indians alive. In fact if you believe in normal distributions then the best Indians would be better than almost any other country because there are more Indians to draw from.
- pkaye 7y ago> Is there any reason why you would want diversity? Diversity is generally considered a positive thing for companies and countries. Also there have been complaints that US is poaching the best people from other countries so diversity helps moderate that.
- whatshisface 7y ago>Also there have been complaints that US is poaching the best people from other countries so diversity helps moderate that. The US sets US law to serve US interests, so I don't see how that would be a motivation.
- diebeforei485 7y agoDiversity in the green card pool is not the same as diversity of who lives in the country or works at a company.
- golemiprague 7y agoI don't think diversity is important, it is just a meme paddled for a certain political reason, there is no one proof that it is better than an homogenous society and I doubt a proof exists for such a complicated and untestable subject. However, what we do know is that having large groups of various dominant cultures in one country usually brings divisions in the best case and wars in the worst. There is already cultural tension between the large groups in the American society. Adding another large dominant group is not going to make anything better, that's why the immigration policy is trying to make an equal blend as much as it can, it would be more accurate to make it based on culture or race but that would be frowned upon, so the next best thing is by country.
- siphon22 7y agoEven if you're right, I don't think people want a system that benefits a group of people just because they have a bigger population than others. It's the same reason why diversity quotas are pushed for, because we can't have companies only hiring or promoting into leadership positions people who happen to look like them. It is in line with those principles that we would not want to have a system where Indians are being severely advantaged compared to other minorities just because they have a huge population.
- belltaco 7y ago>Even if you're right, I don't think people want a system that benefits a group of people just because they have a bigger population than others. This does not make much sense. People get green cards, not countries. Imagine if you were at the DMV and each region of your city had its own queue. People coming from the smaller parts leave in 5 minutes, and people hailing from the larger parts have to wait 8 hours for their turn. It's their fault for living in a more populous place? What did the people in the smaller areas do to deserve their faster queue compared to others, except being born at a certain place? Work visas should be about the person who passes the interview, is selected and is able to hold said job.
- siphon22 7y agoThat sounds nice and all but the DMV analogy does not hold up. Think about if there were no limits by country population, India has more people and therefore the most applicants, so we would be mainly giving limited numbers of work visas to Indians while others would have no chance. Imagine if there was a company with a white CEO who was only hiring/putting other whites into high level positions because they happen to be in a majority white area. If that makes you cringe, you should have the same reaction regarding this. Diversity = various countries/peoples around the world getting a fair chance Not diversity = Only Indians get work visas
- whatshisface 7y ago>a white CEO who was only hiring/putting other whites into high level positions because they happen to be in a majority white area If 90% of a town is white and 10% is black, 9:1 is a fair ratio for executive boards on average. Anything else would mean that the probability of a person holding a board position given their race would be different for different races. Imagine if every company in Mombasa was required to have an even split between white and black: being born white would guarantee you any job you wanted because you would be competing with less than 1% of the population, while in contrast every other ethnicity would be crowded in to half the number of jobs. In fact if racial quotas were instituted in Kenya and every race was given the same percent quota, 98% of Kenyans would be forced to be unemployed.
- dmaldona 7y agoYes, If you only receive immigration from only one country, it is easier for these newcomers to associate and become a political force that can change your status quo. Whereas if immigration is diverse, this situation is more complicated.
- duckfruit 7y agoI don't think this comment deserves to be dismissed so readily. Although I shudder to think about the xenophobia that could potentially motivate thinking along these lines, it is very much a fact that plenty of people have such concerns, and as such it is an important reason to enact barriers and one that I hadn't thought of before.
- umvi 7y agoAre there any historical examples of large numbers of immigrants politically changing the country they immigrated to?
- cvwright 7y agoHawaii. Texas.
- kthejoker2 7y agoTexas Revolution?
- shard972 7y agoThe western roman empire.
- masonic 7y agoEvery country in the Western hemisphere? India/Pakistan until the mid-20th century and under earlier Muslim rule? The entire Mediterranean under Rome? China after Khan?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]