4 ms·
> people-powered demonstrations seemed part of what political scientists refer to as a wave of democratization—a larger narrative about inevitable progress towa
by dmix 7y ago
> people-powered demonstrations seemed part of what political scientists refer to as a wave of democratization—a larger narrative about inevitable progress toward ever-greater freedom.
One could argue the opposite, that the governments around the world have only been increasing in size and power (see: surveillance has massively increased and speech is increasingly restricted), they’re not getting any smaller or more liberal, putting greater pressure on citizens freedoms. This could merely be a reaction to that, not some proactive ideological shift seeking greater freedom - just not constantly less.
There was a famous study showing that almost all the major Arab spring protests were initially spark by food prices and similar failures directly affecting peoples day to day lives, not simply changes in political world-views.
There’s also some claiming the policies of the World Bank and IMF have been a big catalyst for these “bread” riots since the 1980s. As they often pushed for greater amounts of food exports as a means of being economically self sustaining. What ended up happening was a top down movement which replaced normal food production with things like fruit popular in foreign countries and run by a bunch of mini cartels in each country backed by the elite. Which only increased the public’s dependency on gov subsidies for basic food costs as it cannibalized the farmers industry and did little to increase the average workers income.
- chewz 7y ago> all the major Arab spring protests were initially spark by food prices and similar failures directly affecting peoples day to day lives, Soviet Union and Mao's China had been able to finance industrialization and military build up through food exports at the cost of tens milions citizens lives. So it all comes to how determined and ruthless regime really is. Arab dictatorships simply got fat, soft and lazy and lost its grip on power for a time. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_famine_of_1932%E2%80%9333 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_famine_of_1932%E2%80%...
- arlk 7y agoArab Spring was more about dignity and oppression Arabs felt with weak government that can't ensure basic rights for its citizens, let alone many treating the people like cattle. Food was part of that but not the main issue. Take Syria for example, after initial protests government raised salaries but lack of food wasn't what brought people together in the first place so protests grew into full revolution then an armed rebellion continued till now. Look at Egypt, now it's way way worse than Mubarak's era. Yet they are not revolting for a reason. In Algeria, they felt humiliated by having such a disabled president that can't even speak. Think about Bahrain too, a rich gulf state that witnessed massive protests. Also not taking into account that people of different sectors of the societies took part in different parts of the revolutions, protesting or fighting, whether poor barely make a living or rich got back from overseas to make history for its home country, is very insulting to their sacrifices, and results in a very shallow and simplified view of how Arabs think.