3 ms·
Indeed. Facebook does this. It deanonymizes Facebook news feed visitors to every third party whose links appear on their news feed. You consider this a better a
by lern_too_spel 7y ago
Indeed. Facebook does this. It deanonymizes Facebook news feed visitors to every third party whose links appear on their news feed. You consider this a better approach? In addition to losing in privacy, it loses in speed because it doesn't prerender the page, and it doesn't know enough to load just the resources needed to render above the fold.
- manigandham 7y agoI don't consider either necessary. Clicking a link and then loading the page works just fine for the web. Creating a custom HTML fork that puts more pressure on limited publisher dev teams to end up with another copy o the site (and now SSR) is a worse approach than placing loading speed into search results ranking and letting sites optimize the site for everyone with a browser.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> Clicking a link and then loading the page works just fine for the web. No, it doesn't. If it did, there would be no need for Facebook Instant Articles, Apple News, or their successor, AMP. > Creating a custom HTML fork that puts more pressure on limited publisher dev teams to end up with another copy o the site They're already doing this with Facebook Instant Articles and Apple News. Imagine if they had to do separate integrations with Bing, Google, Yahoo! Japan, Baidu, and any future link aggregators. AMP lets them publish one page and support all of them.
- manigandham 7y agoNo, none of this is needed. Make speed a factor in search results and sites get faster. The single HTML version will get faster for everyone on every device, not just mobile sites from certain platforms. Facebook IA and Apple News are also attempts to control ads and data, just like AMP. They're all bad for publishers. IA and AN have both failed in providing anywhere near the benefits and revenue they promised. AMP only survives because it's compatible with existing ads served by Google's ad network and given higher placement in their search results. It's rather amazing how Google is specifically offering the solution to a problem caused by their own adtech software.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> No, none of this is needed. Make speed a factor in search results and sites get faster. You can't get faster than prerendered, which is what Apple News and Facebook Instant Articles offer, which AMP is the open alternative to. > AMP only survives because it's compatible with existing ads served by Google's ad network and given higher placement in their search results. If that's the case, why does Bing use it? > It's rather amazing how Google is specifically offering the solution to a problem caused by their own adtech software. What's rather amazing is that after having repeatedly heard the problem that AMP solves (instant loading pages), you continue to straw man what it solves and what technologies it competes with. > Facebook IA and Apple News are also attempts to control ads and data, just like AMP. They're all bad for publishers. Yet only AMP gets the rabid hate. Why is that? AMP is essentially RSS items with support for above the fold prerendering, interactivity, and monetization. You probably love RSS, even though it is even worse for publishers. Why?
- dmitriid 7y ago> which AMP is the open alternative to. It's not an open alternative. All decisions on what AMP should look like and what it supports are done by Google behind closed doors. See, for example, AMP 4 Email [1] The only reason AMP exists is because Google needed its own way to control content. That is it. > If that's the case, why does Bing use it? Because you're forced to compete against the behemoth on the behemoth's terms. > What's rather amazing is that after having repeatedly heard the problem that AMP solves (instant loading pages) AMP's problems are well documented. You chose to ignore all of them and go for "instant loading pages". > Yet only AMP gets the rabid hate. Why is that? Because it reaches a wider audience and Google has the gall to call it "open" and "good for the web". It's neither. > AMP is essentially RSS items It is not like RSS in any way, shape, or form. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16455593 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16455593
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> It's not an open alternative. All decisions on what AMP should look like and what it supports are done by Google behind closed doors. See, for example, AMP 4 Email [1] Your examples predate https://www.google.com/amp/s/blog.amp.dev/2018/11/30/amp-projects-new-governance-model-now-in-effect/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/blog.amp.dev/2018/11/30/amp-pro... and no longer seem to apply. > The only reason AMP exists is because Google needed its own way to control content. That's nonsensical. Why then does Bing use it? > Because you're forced to compete against the behemoth on the behemoth's terms. Why are they forced to use it? I would really like to see your position stated coherently. > AMP's problems are well documented. How do you propose to achieve instant loading web pages, while working around all of iOS's bugs? > It is not like RSS in any way, shape, or form. This just demonstrates that you don't understand AMP, don't understand RSS, or don't understand both. AMP allows the link aggregator to cache and directly serve the article contents, exactly like RSS does.